Ohio History Journal

NOTES                                                                         191

 

180. Lucy Hayes to Fanny Hayes, November 26, 1885; note added by Hayes, Hayes

Papers.

181. Lucy Hayes to Fanny Hayes, February 4, 1886, Hayes Papers.

182. Mitchell, "Reminiscences," Rutherford B. Hayes Library.

183. William H. Smith, memo of a conversation between Hayes and Smith, August

9, 1890, ibid.

184. Lucy E. Keeler, "Account of the Last Hours of Lucy W. Hayes," manuscript

written at the request of R. B. Hayes, 1889, ibid; Hayes, Diary and Letters, IV, 471-474.

185. Webb Hayes to Elizabeth Tod, July 5, 1889, draft of letter in Webb Hayes

Papers, Rutherford B. Hayes Library.

 

GOVERNOR RUTHERFORD B. HAYES

1. Charles R. Williams, ed., Diary and Letters of Rutherford B. Hayes (Columbus,

1924), III, 39. Hereinafter cited as Hayes, Diary and Letters.

2. Ibid., 25.

3. State of Ohio, General and Local Laws and Joint Resolutions (Columbus, 1867),

328-329.

4. Warren Bateman to W. H. Smith, April 28, 1867. William Henry Smith Collec-

tion, Collection 2, Box 3, Ohio Historical Society.

5. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 39-40.

6. Ibid., III, 41.

7. Hayes unrealistically and perhaps purposefully made no reference as to how

this might be accomplished.

8. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 39.

9.  Ibid., III, 42-43.

10. Morning Journal (Columbus), August 6, 1867.

11. See the Gazelle (Cincinnati), Commercial (Cincinnati), and Enquirer (Cin-

cinnati), June 10, 1867, et seq.

12. Morning Journal, July 8, 1867.

13. Ibid., August 27, September 11, 1867.

14. Ohio Statesman (Columbus), August 6, 1867.

15. Ibid., July 17, 26, 1867.

16. Mac-a-Cheek Press, 1867; Morning Journal, October 29, 1867.

17. Morning Journal, December 31, September 18, 1867; Mary R. Dearing, Veterans

in Politics (Baton Rouge, 1952), 113; T. D. McGillicuddy, comp. and ed., Proceedings

of the Annual and Semi-annual Encampments of the Department of the Ohio Grand

Army of the Republic (Columbus, 1912), 4.

18. New York Times, October 10, 1867; New York World, October 10, 1867; New

York Commercial, October 10, 1867.

19. On November 17, 1868, Hayes moved from this house to that of Judge Swayne

on Seventh Street at the head of State Street on the present site of the Columbus

Public Library where "the rent is cheap," $800 a year. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 74.

20. Francis R. Aumann and Harvey Walker, The Government and Administration

of Ohio (New York, 1956), 88-89

21. William Henry Smith Collection, Collection 2, Box 15.

22. Morning Journal, January 7, 1868.

23. Ibid., January 14, 1868.

24. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 51; Morning Journal, August 27, 1868.

25. McGillicuddy, Proceedings, 12-15.

26. Morning Journal, July 4, 1868.

27. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 55.

28. Morning Journal, November 24, 1868.

29. State of Ohio, General and Local Laws and Joint Resolutions Passed by the

Fifty-eighth General Assembly (Columbus, 1868, 1869).

30. Morning Journal, June 24, 1869.

31. Ibid., August 13, 1869.

32. Ohio Statesman, July 8, 1869.

33. Morning Journal, September 13, 1869.

34. Speech, General George A. Sheridan, Bellefontaine, ibid., September 18, 1869.

• 1
 

192                                                         OHIO HISTORY

 

35. Hayes to Smith, Columbus, July 13, 1869; Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 64; Ohio

State Journal, October 13, 1870.

36. Ibid., October 14, 1869; Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 81-82.

37. Ohio Governors Letterbook, December 7, 1869, Ohio Historical Society.

38. Hayes to Wines, December 14, 1869, Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 77.

39. Ohio State Journal, January 4, 1870.

40. Ibid., January 8, 1868.

41. Ibid., May 14, 1869.

42. Ibid., January 11, 1870.

43. Ibid., April 14, 1870.

44. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 61-62.

45.  Ibid., 63.

46. Ohio State Journal, October 14, 1869.

47. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 99-100.

48. Ohio State Journal, April 18, 1870.

49. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 103.

50. Ibid., 84, 99-100, 106; Ohio State Journal, July 5, 1870.

51. Ibid., October 11, 1870.

52. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 91; Hayes to J. Irving Brooks, March 1, 1870,

ibid., III, 90.

53. Ibid., III., 135-136; Hayes to Charles Nordhoff, March 13, 1871, ibid., III, 134.

54. For a discussion of the efforts to secure Hayes's candidacy for the U. S. Senate

in 1872 and 1873, see E. H. Roseboom, The Civil War Era (Carl Wittke, ed., The

History of the State of Ohio, IV, Columbus, 1944), 478-480.

55. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 244, 249, 269.

56. Ohio State Journal, June 3, 1875.

57. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 82.

58. Ohio State Journal, June 3, 1875; Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 283, 284-285, 287.

59. Ohio State Journal, August 2, 1875.

60. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 290, 293, 295, 352-353; Enquirer, September 22,

1875; Claude M. Fuess, Carl Schurz, Reformer (New York, 1932), 217-218.

61. Ohio State Journal, January 11, 1876.

62. State of Ohio, General and Local Laws and Joint Resolutions Passed by the

Sixty-second General Assembly, LXXIII, (Columbus, 1876).

63. Hayes, Diary and Letters, III, 189, 313.

64. For a preliminary study of this subject, see Catherine S. Bartlett, "The Prison

Reform Activity of Rutherford B. Hayes, 1868-1893" (M.A. thesis, The Ohio State

University, Columbus, 1958).

65. Harry Barnard, Rutherford B. Hayes and His America (Indianapolis, 1954),

242.

 

JOHN A. BINGHAM AND RECONSTRUCTION:

THE DILEMMA OF A MODERATE

1. Biographical Dictionary of the American Congress (Washington, 1950) 850;

Biographical Cyclopedia and Portrait Gallery . . . of the State of Ohio (Cincinnati,

1894), III, 691-694; Dictionary of American Biography (New York, 1964), Vol. I, Pt.

II, 277-278; Benjamin B. Kendrick, The Journal of the Joint Committee of Fifteen on

Reconstruction, 39th Congress, 1865-1867, Columbia University Studies in History, Eco-

nomics, and Public Law (New York, 1914), 183-185; Benjamin P. Thomas and Harold

M. Hyman, Stanton: The Life and Times of Lincoln's Secretary of War (New York,

1962), 25; Bingham's License to Practice Law, October 14, 1841, in the possession of

Mr. Milton Ronsheim: J. L. Conwell, "Recollections of Lincoln and Stanton . . . By

Hon. John A. Bingham . . . ." (n.d.), in the possession of Mr. Milton Ronsheim,

Cadiz, Ohio.

2. Thomas and Hyman, Stanton, 136, 367; Guy W. Moore, The Case of Airs. Surratt

(Norman, 1954); David M. DeWitt, The Judicial Murder of Mary Surratt (Baltimore,

1895).

3. Ibid., 27; John T. Morse, Jr., ed., Diary of Gideon Welles, Secretary of the Navy

Under Lincoln and Johnson (Boston, 1911), III, 274.

• 2