CHAPTER XXVIIGOVERNOR OF OHIO -- FIRST TERM 1868-1869
HAYES was nominated for governor in June, 1867. He
resigned from Congress on the adjournment of Congress
late in July and immediately entered upon his canvass.]
SPRINGFIELD, OHIO, August 17, 1867.
DEAR UNCLE:--I write from here not knowing if I shall
have time to do so at home. I go home to spend Sunday today.
Thus far all goes pleasantly. Luckily my best speech was to
my best audience, and where I would have preferred it, at Day-
ton. Nobody with me yet. I expect Buck[land] next week.
Yours,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
PORTSMOUTH, August 25, 1867, Sunday.
MY DARLING:--I could not get to Chillicothe today. Had a
great crowd yesterday. In the middle of my speech a terrific
rain-storm broke us up. At night we had a fine meeting. "Old
Ben" [Wade] made a glorious negro suffrage [speech], fre-
quently rough, but great.
Mrs. Buckland is with Buck. We all enjoy it. Spoke at night
three times the last week as well as daily. Am quite hoarse but
it [the hoarseness] wears off entirely as I warm up. Love to
Rud. Oceans to yourself.
Affectionately,
R.
MRS. HAYES.
COLUMBUS, September 29, 1867.
MY DARLING: -- I am writing from Laura's pleasant home--
the next place to my wife's in homelikeness and comfort.
(47)48 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
I did hope to see you at 383 this morning but to do so would
give me two night rides, one to go and another to get back to the
Reserve. So, tired as I was, I gave it up.
A pleasant week, this last. I enjoyed Delaware particularly.
I made only a so-so speech there -- not a failure, but not one of
the good ones. Sorry for that, but couldn't help it. At Tiffin
and Bucyrus, three hours each had used me up a trifle. I am
better than ever.
Affectionately,
R.
MRS. HAYES.
CINCINNATI, October 6, 1867.
DEAR UNCLE:--We are all very well at our old home on
Sixth Street. My last speech of any consequence was made Fri-
day night. One of the best I have made, and particularly with
the best voice. It was rather queer. Governor Morton made a
noble speech but [he] could not be heard by half his audience.
I reached them all more easily than ever before.
It looks well here. We shall elect our county ticket and do
well for the amendment. But the Cary affair* is very much
mixed. I shall not be surprised at any result. It has been badly
managed -- very.
I hope to be with you next Sunday.
I sent my card to Judge Thurman [the opposing candidate]
when he was here. He was not in his room. He afterwards
sent me a note which I prize. He says: "Whatever the result, it
is a great satisfaction to know that you and I have behaved like
gentlemen and friends."
Love to the boys and Sarah.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
*Samuel F. Cary was the Democratic candidate for Congress in the
Second District to fill Mr. Hayes's unexpired term, opposing Richard
Smith. editor of the Gazette. As Mr. Hayes apprehended, Cary was
elected.
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 49
CINCINNATI, October 9, 1867.
MY DEAR UNCLE: -- You need not be told how much the re-
sult of the election disappoints me. You know I will bear it
cheerfully and with philosophy. It is however a puzzling thing
to decide now what is next to be done. Assuming that I am
beaten, which I do not doubt, I must choose my path anew. I
will see you and talk it all over soon. No man in my place
would probably have done differently, but the thing is over, and
now for a sensible future. I feel sorry for the boys -- especially
Birch.
I hope your health is good, and that you will borrow no trou-
ble on account of this.
Sincerely,
S. BIRCHARD. R. B. HAYES.
CINCINNATI, October 11, 1867.
DEAR SMITH:--I am obliged for your letter of yesterday. It
is to be hoped that the corrections will not upset the apple-cart.
I am going to Fremont tomorrow. Please send a dispatch
about noon Saturday, stating the majority for me as it then
stands, addressed to S. Birchard, Fremont, Ohio.
Sincerely, R. B. HAYES.
P. S. -- If it holds out I shall be at Columbus next week.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH,
SECRETARY OF STATE.
CINCINNATI, November 17, 1867.
DEAR S--:--I went to Columbus to get quarters and for noth-
ing else. I did hear General Cox's whole mind, as I suppose,
and I agree with him throughout. That does not include your
ideas as to General D--. I do not hear that he is a candidate
for the adjutant-generalship. The pressure idea is foolish
enough.
Be serene! I'll talk it all up before jumping in.
Sincerely,
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH, R. B. HAYES.
Columbus, Ohio.
4
50 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
COLUMBUS, December 27, 1867.
MY DARLING:--Am here waiting for my traps and calami-
ties -- I should say our--which will be here this afternoon and
I hope to get them all in the house tomorrow. The carpets and
other things I wish to get ready to put down and put in; but
really very little in that way can be done without you. I have
an impression we shall feel very homelike here when we do
settle.
Love to all. I shall come up [to Fremont] in time for din-
ner New Year's day, if not before.
Affectionately,
R.
MRS. HAYES.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, January 11, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:--I suppose you are entitled to an advance
copy of my inaugural. Here it is. It contains but three days
[ideas]. First, a compliment to Governor Cox; second, advice
against too much legislation; and third, it shows that I still stand
by equal suffrage. It is the shortest ever delivered in Ohio.
Our new home is most agreeable. I can give you a pleasant
room with an air-tight wood-stove and a bedroom opening into
it, so much like your own that I am sure you would be safe in
health and feel at home. . . .
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, January 13, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:--I now send you another copy of the inau-
gural containing a fourth idea. I found our Democrats foolish
enough to be repealing Ohio's assent to the Fourteenth Amend-
ment. So I put in some words on that head. -- All well.
Yours,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 51
COLUMBUS, January 17, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:--I am enjoying the new office. It strikes me
at a guess as the pleasantest I have ever had. Not too much
hard work, plenty of time to read, good society, etc., etc. . . .
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, February 3, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:--Tell the boys that if nothing occurs to pre-
vent I hope to reach Fremont on the evening train that will ar-
rive Friday evening.
I send you T. D. Jones' design for a Soldier and Lincoln Mon-
ument. We hadn't money enough to accept this design. It is in
three parts:--(I) At the bottom, the uprising of the people
when Sumter was taken; (2) The surrender of Vicksburg to
Grant; and (3) The bust of Lincoln. I am not sure but pre-
sume you will think it worth express charges and houseroom.
We adopted Jones' bust from this design.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, February 17, 1868.
DEAR S-:--I have thought of writing to the friends of
some of the early governors for portraits. Some I am sure I
can get by simply asking -- as McArthur, Trimble, etc., etc. I
merely write for suggestions supposing you may know or may
have done something which would change my idea.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH.
STATE OF OHIO, EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT.
COLUMBUS, April 15, 1868.
SIR:--I am requested to write you in relation to the va-
cancy in the consular office at Cincinnati, Ohio, occasioned by
the death of Mr. C. F. Adae.
52 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
Honorable John B. Stallo has been named as a suitable person
to fill the vacancy. I am personally well acquainted with Judge
Stallo. He is an able lawyer and an influential and upright citi-
zen whose reputation, experience, and capacity fit him in an
eminent degree for the position of consular representative for
any European Power desiring such representative in one of the
important cities of the United States.
I have the honor to be,
Very respectfully,
Your obedient servant,
R. B. HAYES,
GOVERNOR OF OHIO.
COUNT BISMARCK,
CHANCELLOR NORTH GERMAN CONFEDERATION,
Berlin.
(Telegrams.)
WASHINGTON, D. C., May 5, 1868.
To GOVERNOR R. B. HAYES,
Columbus, Ohio.
What do Ohio Republicans desire as to impeachment? Answer
fully.
J. C. LEE,
Care Judge Welker.
COLUMBUS, May 6, 1868.
To GENERAL J. C. LEE,
Care of Judge Welker, M. C.,
Washington.
Conviction.
R. B. HAYES.
FREMONT, OHIO, May 23, Saturday, 1868.
MY DARLING:--Came from Chicago this morning. Had a
fine time. . . . All well here. Young Mrs. Wade came
over with me -- vexed of course with the doings of a few Ohio
anti-Waders, but took it well. The Convention [National Re-
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 53
publican] with that exception was a great success. Mrs. Lane
sends her regards. She was full of praises of you; the old Sen-
ator, ditto. Affectionately,
R. B. H.
MRS. HAYES.
COLUMBUS, June 27, 1868.
DEAR SMITH:--In reply to yours of yesterday: The Youngs-
town address is now half written--a dull affair, nothing fresh,
original, or even passably good in it. I rely upon a rapid, spir-
ited delivery to get it off on the audience and prefer not to let it
get into any daily. But if it must be, your wishes will be com-
plied with, but with the distinctly expressed wish that you don't
call attention to it by praise or otherwise. It will be platitu-
dinarily-tion stupid. Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH,
Chronicle Office, Cincinnati.
COLUMBUS, July 2, 1868.
MY DEAR S--:--I hope I have not got myself in a scrape
with you. I did not dream that your paper would not appear
Saturday P. M. Your letter spoke of "selling it by the time I
had comfortably concluded, etc., etc.," and so I gave it to all the
other Cincinnati papers and I now have slips this morning from
the Commercial, etc. But how will it do to print in your last
edition Friday? There was no understanding with other papers.
Their correspondents asked for it, and they copied it. Do just
what you please with it. Mahoning is a great way off.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH,
EDITOR, Chronicle.
July 9, 1868. -- Horatio Seymour nominated because:--
1. He was more distinctly and decidedly committed against
the Greenback theory of Mr. Pendleton and the Western De-
mocracy than any other man before that convention.
54 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
2. He was by his record more completely identified with
the peace party than any man except Mr. Pendleton.
3. He is for a reconstruction of the South which will be
agreeable to the Rebels, and opposes the reconstruction which
gives safety and power to the loyal.
COLUMBUS, July 14, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:-- . . . Joel Bryan's wife, son, and
daughter were here this morning. Had a pleasant time with
them. The son, Guy, is a fine, excellent young man of twenty-
six years--sensible, intelligent, etc. The old friends are all
prosperous. Negro business in that county works well -- no fuss
or trouble. The young man is a Democrat and was at New
York [National Democratic Convention], but is free from bigot-
ry and nonsense; takes cheerful and sensible views of things.
I go to Cincinnati tomorrow to stay a few days. Yes, hurrah
for Seymour and Blair! The thing is a wet blanket here to our
Democrats. The prospect has certainly improved for us.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, July 25, 1868.
DEAR GENERAL: -- You make me feel "wuss and wuss" but I
can't make the trip. Her beauty and "incomparable" charms of
all sorts I am sure are of the lasting kind. I can't say as to
how she will "keep" in other respects. There is one thing (to
the shame of our society be it spoken) which makes it probable
that she will stay. She has no fortune to attract the flies.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL M. F. FORCE,
Cincinnati.
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 55
Private and Confidential.
COLUMBUS, October 27, 1868.
MY DEAR S--:--The Chronicle contains an unlucky little
sentence. Of course it is not to be corrected or alluded to, but
the governor neither can nor ought "to prevent breaches of the
peace." Yet there are people who expect it, and that makes the
sentence unlucky. If there was an insurrection or mob which
the civil authorities could not control, I could call out the military
(if there was any?) but it is the business of the civil authorities
to take care of "breaches of the peace." The governor has no
civil authority. I write merely out of abundant caution.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH,
Cincinnati.
COLUMBUS, November 3, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:--Platt heard my talk about the taxes for
ditches and roads on your Wood County lands with the great-
est good humor. He laughed about it; said he rather thought
the lands might about as well be given up, but would leave all
that to you and Doctor Rawson. He seemed to regard the big
figures I gave him as a good joke. There will be no trouble
or feeling with him.
Judge Matthews staid with us during the session of the
Electoral College. His daughter Bella, the eldest and favorite,
aged seventeen, died suddenly while he was here.
Lucy has gone down to Glendale. We got home in five hours
from Fremont by way of Monroeville and Clyde. The quickest
time I ever made. All well.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
WASHINGTON, November 9, 1868.
DEAR GUY:--I came here last night chiefly to attend to your
cause. The President has just given me an order for the par-
don of yourself and brothers. I congratulate you all.
56 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
I concur fully with the sentiments of your letter. I hope
you will all agree to one further amendment of the Constitution,
viz., the basis of representation to be voters. This I deem very
essential. Don't commit yourself against it until I can write
you fully.
I return home tomorrow. All Cincinnati friends are well.
Regards to your wife.
As ever,
R. B. HAYES.
GUY M. BRYAN,
Texas.
COLUMBUS, November 11, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:--We are jogging along as usual--a little
more to do than heretofore. The Legislature meeting soon and
various matters overlooked claiming attention.
I spent the election day [at Cincinnati] looking at Mr. Pro-
basco's fine pictures, statuary, library, and house. The house
is much the finest I ever was in. He has a few pictures of all
peoples -- English, German, French, Italian, Asiatic, etc. He
prefers French art to any other.
We hope to spend Thanksgiving with you and shall do so
if not prevented by something I don't now foresee. Grant's
election was a happy thing. He seems to behave admirably.
The effect South and everywhere seems good.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, December 19, 1868.
DEAR UNCLE:--Got home safe this morning. Had a good
time. The most satisfactory part of the trip was several hours'
quiet talk with General Grant. It was a most delightful talk.
After he warms up he is just about such a man as Charley Boalt
used to be--quite as cheerful, chatty, and good-natured, and so
sensible, clear-headed, and well-informed. I feel just as much at
ease with him as I do with intimate friends like Hastings or
Force--more so than with Bushnell or even Buckland! This
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 57
sounds strange, but I mention it because it will give you an
idea how completely and wonderfully he remains unspoiled by
his elevation. I think I will come up soon and give you some
of his talk.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, January 18, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE: -- I received yours enclosing draft for $551.68.
proceeds of bond for which I am obliged.
We are all very well. The Legislature comes together in
good feeling, and the past week has been an animated time,
meeting friends, acquaintances, and strangers. Mr. Emmitt
has placed two more statues in the rotunda which I suppose
are really by Mead. They are about one-third life-size and
very pretty.
The best book of the sort I have seen is "Personal Sketches
of Grant" by Richardson, author of "Field, Dungeon, and
Escape," which you have. I will bring it up when I come two
or three weeks hence.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, January 21, 1869.
MY DEAR GUY:--Your New Year's letter made me happy.
Time is rapidly getting our political differences out of the way.
We shall hardly be as wide apart again as we were ten years
ago. Personally, we never were divided. Hereafter I hope we
shall meet in as complete accord as need be for close friendship.
I was at Gambier Monday to see the inauguration of a new
president. The enclosed gives you a report of it. Altogether a
good time. I spoke of you to numbers of old friends who have
friendly recollections of auld lang syne. Hurd, Buttles, Jones,
etc., always ask about you.
Excuse this. I am writing in the office with too many inter-
58 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
ruptions to write consecutively. My regards to your wife
and children. I hope to see you again soon.
As ever,
R.
GUY M. BRYAN,
Texas.
Private.
COLUMBUS, February 15, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR:--I am in receipt of yours of the 13th. I
have taken some pains to keep posted on the state of things
at Washington and from different sources, as well informed,
perhaps, as anybody, I get advices which lead me to think
"pressure" a bad thing. I have so far kept away designedly,
and think it would have been better if others had done so.
If anything turns up changing the looks I'll act at once. You
evidently think as I do about it. Grant's little speech has
different versions and the words you quote are not probably
"verbatim copy." However, I have no misgivings. There will
be dissatisfactions, of course, but I think nothing serious.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
[Unidentified.]
COLUMBUS, February 18, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR:--I received today the Globe containing the
debate on the Butler resolution of censure.* I have felt like
thanking you for your part in that debate ever since I read it,
and I congratulate you very heartily upon it. It is absolutely
necessary that on such occasions somebody should have the
pluck to talk truth and sense, and it is a fortunate circumstance
to have a man of position and ability to do it.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
JAMES A. GARFIELD.
*A resolution censuring the Vice-President pro tempore, Benjamin
Wade, for ordering the electoral vote of Georgia to be counted in the
joint convention of the two houses of Congress for counting the vote
for President
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 59
COLUMBUS, March 7, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--We are all well. Political talk is just now
all the talk. Grant's inaugural strikes me as capital. His
Cabinet looks like a revolution, an experiment. If it succeeds,
as I hope it will, all will applaud him for his courage and wis-
dom. Otherwise, otherwise. It is a Cabinet for work, for
honesty, and for economy. It contains three radicals, Wash-
burne, Creswell, and Howe; three conservative Republicans,
Cox, Stewart, and Borie. It is outside of political circles--
no man of political strength in the list, and is therefore un-
trammelled, owes nobody anything. It contains no Presidential
aspirants, and may therefore be regarded as organized for
harmony. No man being conspicuous, Grant's leadership and
rule is beyond question. It seems to mean business and not
political scheming. It is an attempt to put fitness and qualifi-
cations before what is called "claims" and "political services."
If anybody could overthrow the spoils doctrine and practice,
Grant is the man. It has been thought impossible hitherto,
but I hope with some confidence that he will win.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, March 10, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR: -- I sent two letters to Mr. Barrett this morn-
ing, one to General Cox, and one to General Grant.
Your letter indicates that you are in doubt of the future.
I suppose there is some reason for it, but I confess I don't
feel it. There is just now a wild hubbub at Washington and to
some extent in the country, but I think I see the main points
are all right and think that before a great while the present
doubting will disappear. "Wait for the facts."
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH,
Cincinnati, Ohio.
60 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
COLUMBUS, March 24, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--I spent four days in Washington most
pleasantly. There is still a lack of harmony on the Tenure of
Office Law, but generally the prospect is good of a strong, suc-
cessful, and popular Administration. On all essentials, Grant is
more perfectly in accord with Republican ideas than was gen-
erally supposed was the case. The Cabinet is personally likely
to be very popular. Economy and good sense seem to be in
power.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, April 3, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--. . . The best thing of my administra-
tion, I suspect, will be the beginning of the geological survey.
It carried very handsomely in both branches. Now comes the
important point. Who is to be chief geologist? My preposses-
sions are for Professor Newberry. Please ask Mr. Bushnell
about it and get him to write me, showing him or telling him
what I say.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, April 15, 1869.
DEAR GENERAL:--The Fifth Virginia was commanded by
Colonel Zigler until about 1863, then by Colonel Tomlinson
until the end of its first term of enlistment, and in 1864 re-
enlisted and became the First West Virginia Veteran Volunteers
under Colonel Wm. H. Enochs. Its men would naturally claim
the veteran regiment to be the same as the former Fifth, as it
was principally composed of the officers and men of the Fifth,
consolidated with the Ninth however.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
[Unidentified.]
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 61
COLUMBUS, April 19, 1869.
MY DEAR BOY:--I am sending Uncle a box containing oats
and barley and also a small box inside of it with fossil shell-
fish, a fossil shark's tooth, and a bud, I suppose it is, of a lily
fossilized. I visited a small but valuable collection of such
things this morning. They were found near here and at Dela-
ware. At Delaware they find bones of enormous fishes of
species long since extinct. There are septaria, or large round
stones like Uncle's, formed around large fish bones--particu-
larly the bones of the head and the jaws, six and eight feet
in diameter! That story will make Uncle open his eyes. Mr.
Herzer, the German who gave me the fossils, has a micro-
scope which magnifies three hundred times. A small-sized
louse looks as big as a full grown rat, and [a] much more ter-
rible beast than a rat he is with his claws and pinching appara-
tus.
Affectionately,
WEBB C. HAYES, R. B. HAYES.
Fremont.
Private.
COLUMBUS, April 26, 1869.
DEAR S--: -- Enclosed I send you a letter for Nixon to
Delano. What are your ideas on school commissioner? Cow-
dery, White, Harvey, and Henkle seem ahead. As Lincoln
would say, I have very little influence with the governor, but
would suggest names in about the above order.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH,
Chronicle Office, Cincinnati.
COLUMBUS, April 29, 1869.
DEAR S--:--I rather like your ticket. But Mr. Henkle is
not a candidate. No recommendations are on file for him, (a
circumstance which perhaps ought to be decisive in his favor!),
and having said I would try to give the school men their choice,
I propose to do it if they can make one.
62 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
You don't say White once. Warner is strong for him, and a
good crowd of first-class school men. I am in no hurry.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH.
COLUMBUS, May 1, 1869.
DEAR S--: -- I am obliged for your frank letter. It comes
nearer the core of the matter than any word I have yet had.
I may not act on it, but the chances are that I shall. I have
a sort of pledge out to appoint the choice of the school men. If
they by their letters, etc., etc., do decidedly make a choice, I
shall act on it even of it takes the man you dislike. But it
looks now as if I should be left free.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH.
COLUMBUS, May 6, 1869.
DEAR S--:--The use of the phrase, "the man you dislike,"
in my note to you, was unfortunate. I am sorry for it. No
meaning containing an imputation on your motives was in my
mind--none whatever. Your letter shows a dislike for one
of the gentlemen named, as I thought, but it did not, and does
not occur to me that therefore you opposed him. You named
another and a solid reason--a reason which deserves to be con-
sidered. The part of your letter enclosed in brackets contains
what I refer to as showing "dislike." The last sentence in your
letter of the 5th will, I trust, on reflection be reconsidered.*
Sincerely,
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH. R. B. HAYES.
*Mr. Smith had written: --"I am not in the habit of letting my
personal dislikes enter into the consideration of public matters, and I
am not aware of having indicated to you any dislike for any one among
the candidates for school commissioner. . . . I endeavored to answer
your inquiry as a friend who is not afraid to speak the truth at all times,
and to give you the inside view among the best of the teachers. As this
effort has been construed as an expression of my 'likes and dislikes,'
I would suggest that hereafter you apply elsewhere for information."
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 63
May 7, 1869.--The Legislature adjourns today. Now for
the result. Prepare accurate and full tables showing the ex-
penditures authorized by this Legislature. Divide them into
ordinary and extraordinary. Show then in some detail how
they compare with former years, with ten, twenty years ago,
and with last year
Apply this to state and local affairs. Show amount of taxes
authorized and amount that goes upon the future. Give a list
of all unusual appropriations, all unusual burdens.
When the white flag was raised at [the] Chicago [Democratic
National Convention in 1864] by recommending "immediate
efforts for the cessation of hostilities," Judge R- was a state
delegate for Ohio.
COLUMBUS, May 17, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--. . . Colonel Whittlesey is very angry
and very vindictive because he is not State Geologist. He threat-
ens terribly to defeat my nomination and the like!
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, June 4, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE: -- I returned from the East Tuesday night, and
found all at home as usual. My trip was in all respects very
interesting. Nothing was pleasanter than a look through the
Art Gallery, Stewart's new store, and the view from Nordhoff's
cottage on the Palisades of the Hudson. The best talks I
heard were those of Mr. Kennedy, the superintendent of the
metropolitan police, the successor of old Hayes. I was with
him the most of two days. -- All well.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
64 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
COLUMBUS, June 26, 1869.
DEAR GENERAL:--Looking over the letters opened and read
hastily on the day of the convention,* I find the enclosed which
is no doubt the lost letter to you.
Your capital speech the other day, the night of the 23rd,
I have read with great satisfaction, and I hope you will make
your arrangements to speak for the committee during the can-
vass and at a long list of meetings.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
J. A. GARFIELD.
COLUMBUS, July 13, 1869.
DEAR S--: -- I am sorry not to be here to meet you.
I think of nothing in particular to say. There is a whispering
which leads me to suspect that they [the Democratic leaders]
are hoping, and perhaps trying, to get Rosecrans to decline. If
he declines it will change the programme essentially. Until
that matter is decided I suspect we had better show up their
talk about him, and his talk about them as our principal topic,
so far as merely personal issues go.
I am ready to begin [the canvass] whenever it is deemed
best, and would advise going first and chiefly into doubtful or
Union counties.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES
WILLIAM HENRY SMITH.
COLUMBUS, August 9, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--. . . I begin campaigning Wednesday.
Rosecrans' declination does not affect it much. He would have
been beaten. So I think will whoever they run.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
*The State Republican Convention, June 23, at Columbus, which re-
nominated Mr. Hayes by acclamation.
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 65
COLUMBUS, August 16, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE: -- The business of the office and the canvass
keep me busy. I go to Chillicothe at noon and will be absent
"on the circuit" two weeks before I return. Things look well.
Pendleton's nomination makes the race more interesting and
more doubtful. But I guess it will be all right.
My health, voice, and spirits are of the best.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
Private.
COLUMBUS, August 27, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR:--I wrote the enclosed [following] letter to the
editor of the Democrat, but noticing that he refers to you, it
seems more proper to write you on the subject, and as I am
pressed for time I send you the letter to show you that I take
it all in good part.
I add two things: First, I regret you did not write me after
the state convention your views; and, secondly, I did tell all
our Republican friends who conversed with me on such topics
to oppose debts except in the extremest cases.
I hope it will do us no injury, and trust you will agree with
me that the long sessions and excessive legislation of the last
Legislature ought to be avoided.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
D. W. CANFIELD, ESQ.,
Chardon, Ohio.
Confidential.
COLUMBUS, August 27, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR:--I have read the article you send me. The
spirit of it is so just and fair that I cannot complain of it. At
the same time I must think as to the Commisisoners' Bill that
it violates the spirit of the constitution in not placing limits
or conditions upon the power of the board. You do not allude
to the most objectionable bill--the Road Bill.
5
66 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
But I write merely to say that I think we can't differ on my
main objection, viz., the long sessions--the overlegislation.
To that I did object in my inaugural message and this is what
led to the greatest abuses. I shall listen to all such friendly
suggestions as yours, and so far as I can do it, without for-
saking principle, will accommodate my discussions to the views
of the friends. It is perhaps a hobby with me, but I do hate
debt, and I am opposed to authorizing it except as a dernier
ressort.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
P. S.--The canvass looks well so far.--H.
JULIUS O. CONVERSE, ESQ.,
Chardon, Ohio.
COLUMBUS, August 30, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--. . . I am over my hardest week's work
and find myself still in good condition in all respects. I shall
drift up into your vicinity next week. I can form no very
definite notion as to prospects. There are some clouds at Cin-
cinnati and Cleveland growing out of local troubles, but with
these exceptions the coast is clear and appearances encouraging.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, September 27, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE: --I am getting on very well. Came home last
Saturday. . . . I start out again this afternoon to be gone
until the last of the week.
As I have told you all along, the result of an apathetic election
is always in doubt and this election is badly apathetic. But
it looks better to me and I now think our chance is decidedly
the best.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 67
COLUMBUS, October 8, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--I have no new opinion about the election.
The vote will probably be light--so light that an adverse re-
sult would not surprise me, and yet I think we shall get through.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, October 13, 1869.
DEAR UNCLE:--. . . We are in the midst of the doubt
as to results. I am laughing and serene as usual. But there are
anxious faces over the figures. It looks as if I was carried
through again by a close vote. I saw the moon over my right
shoulder and I think that will win.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. BIRCHARD.
COLUMBUS, November 4, 1869.
Honorable Richard M. Corwine, of Cincinnati, Ohio, is a
lawyer of large experience, whose practice in the higher courts
of the State and of the United States for many years has given
him wide reputation. He has devoted himself to his profes-
sion almost without interruption more than twenty-five years.
Whatever qualifications for the discharge of important judicial
duties can be acquired by a gentleman of intellect, of excellent
temper and manners, and of great industry, may be justly
claimed for Mr. Corwine.
R. B. HAYES.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 8, 1869.
DEAR CORWINE:--You have the joke on me if I have not
on you. The word to my eye is plainly judicial not political.
Either my writing or your reading is greatly at fault.
I can say nothing further as yet. Indeed, I feel some em-
barrassment may arise in doing so much as I have. I trust my
letter will not be used or mentioned, if it does not seem neces-
68 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
sary to do it. It is strictly within my rule and perfectly proper,
but others might not so see it.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
RICHARD M. CORWINE.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 6, 1869.
DEAR GENERAL:--My wife and I both wish to say thank
you for the beautiful pictures [reproductions of paintings in
European galleries]. They are so fine that I want to be able
to talk about them--how they are done; where are the
originals; whose? etc., etc. I am told that a negative is ob-
tained from the painting by the ordinary process, that the
negative is retouched, and these pictures printed from the im-
proved negative.
The next time I meet you I propose to hear you on your
trip. So try not [to] forget it altogether.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
M. F. FORCE.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 7, 1869.
MY DEAR WEBB:--. . . Yesterday one of the teachers
in the public schools tried an interesting experiment in the
rotunda of the State House. He suspended an iron ball weigh-
ing twenty pounds by a fine wire from the top of the dome and
by letting it swing as a pendulum demonstrated very satisfac-
torily that the earth moves from the west to the east. The wire
had to be one hundred and twenty feet long to reach from the
dome to the floor. A line was drawn on the floor due north
and south and the ball set to swinging directly over the line.
In an hour the line of the ball's motion was nine degrees variant
from the north and south line, showing that in forty hours the
variation would go clear around the circle. It was a curious
demonstration, but while everybody saw the result, only a few
seemed to fully comprehend it.
I have a large number of the coats of arms of the
States cut from the letters I get. If you want them I'll send
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 69
them to you. . . . You must always write with ink. You
forgot to give the year in dating your last letter. Your letter
as a whole was very well written.--Ruddy and your mother
send love to you and Birch.
Affectionately, your father,
R. B. HAYES.
WEBB C. HAYES,
Fremont.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 7, 1869.
DEAR COLONEL:--Thanks for your call and pencil note at
Cincinnati. I was sorry not to see you. I wanted to hear your
talk --not more than I always do, -- and as I am not likely to
meet you often, I now want to know where you are to settle, if
you do settle, that I can have the next best thing to your talk --
your writings.
Judging by our last conversation, for pecuniary and other
reasons you prefer a position to being merely a disturbing ele-
ment; but as I see it, the latter is your vocation -- a vocation in
which you can do great things in the present political, religious,
social, etc., etc.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
COLONEL DONN PIATT.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 8, 1869.
DEAR GENERAL:--I congratulate you back again [--on your
election to the state Senate]. Some enemy of yours reported
that you would be badly beaten in any event. But I didn't believe
it. I agree with you. Our lines didn't fall in the right years.
The "off years," as Greeley calls them, are bad years to run for
office.
The missionary story is out of whole cloth. I went to church
like a good Christian on the Sunday I was reported to be
ploughing with the Hamilton County Reform Members and
didn't see one of them. Bishop Thompson preached a capital
discourse on the text, "Be ye faithful to the end and I will
give you a crown of life," or words to that effect. If you had
70 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
heard it you wouldn't have thought of that infamous suspicion
that I was imitating Sam Cary because I quoted scripture in
my Thanksgiving proclamation. Hassaurek says the Reformers
will be with us on the Fifteenth Amendment. I think so too.
Lew Campbell, it is said, boasts that he will prevent the ratifi-
cation in the Senate, but as both of the Reformers are perfectly
sound I suppose it is safe. . . .
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
Kind regards to Mrs. Potts.
GENERAL B. F. POTTS,
Carrollton, Ohio.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 9, 1869.
DEAR SIR:--I am in receipt of your favor of the 6th inst.
in relation to the appointment of State Librarian, and in reply
I must frankly say that, as at present advised, the incumbent
will at the end of his term be reappointed. If I had an oppor-
tunity to talk with you face to face I would go into the reasons
for this course. I recognize the validity of your claims and
under other circumstances would be glad to give them a favor-
able hearing.
Supposing your letters may be of value to you, I respectfully
return them.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL H. K. McCONNELL,
Yellow Springs, Ohio.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 10, 1869.
DEAR NORDHOFF:--You are not the only "wretch" (I have
adopted that good word from you) who harrows up the feelings
of my wife by sending the Harper's picture of me. It has
driven me into the photograph business and I am now jawing
back in this way.
I want to send Walter "The President's Words"--the book
of Lincoln's wisdom, I named to you. How--by express or
mail, and direction?
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 71
I have not seen Aunty Davis since your article on the Bible
question. I fear she will think you have gone back on her
hopes of you. I take the Bible side, largely because this war
on the Good Book is in disguise a war on all free schools.
Sincerely, R. B. HAYES.
CHARLES NORDHOFF.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 10, 1869.
DEAR SIR:--I am in receipt of your note of the 8th. I agree
with you as to the importance of securing a fire-proof building
for the library. It seems to me so important that I would not
wait until the society can build or purchase such rooms. Can't
a room that would answer the purpose be rented? I, however,
ought not to make suggestions. My income does not permit
me to do more than pay the ten dollars assessment in aid of
the society's object. I would be glad to do more if I could.
Sincerely, R. B. HAYES.
JULIUS DEXTER,
RECORDING SECRETARY, HISTORICAL AND PHILOSOPHICAL
SOCIETY.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 11, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR:--I am in receipt of your favor of the 9th
in relation to the claims of Mr. Forster and Dr. Morton. I
had some knowledge of the merits of Mr. Forster's applica-
tion and have written two letters in his behalf. In reply to
one I was told that consulates are all gobbled up long ago--
that his only chance is the resignation or death of the present
incumbents; and you know "few die and none resign."
As to Dr. Morton, I know him well, but I suppose Mr. Har-
bough, who is a faithful good officer, ought not to be turned out.
If more letters or good words in behalf of Mr. Forster are
wanted, I am ready to furnish them. But as Mr. Lincoln said
when he was President: "I have very little influence with this
Administration."
Sincerely, R. B. HAYES.
HONORABLE O. FOLLETT,
Sandusky, Ohio.
72 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
COLUMBUS, OHIO, November 13, 1869.
DEAR SAGE:--I am in receipt of yours of yesterday. I will
send you reports of [the] Ohio Penitentiary and Reform Farm.
No report of Girls' Reformatory yet made. But the rules
adopted may answer your purpose and I will try to get them
for you. They were approved by me as the law required and
were in the handwriting of Judge M-- [Matthews (?)].
I have the Thanksgiving proclamations of twenty-seven
States--all recognizing religion, nearly all the religion of the
Bible, and several the Divinity of Christ. More are coming,
doubtless. Our Legislature for many years has passed a joint
resolution annually authorizing a thanksgiving and frequently
in terms which recognized the religion of the Bible. The last
Legislature omitted to do so by a mere accident this year, but in
[the] Sixty-fifth volume Ohio Laws, page 306, passed one last
year. If you wish to borrow my bundle of Thanksgiving
proclamations I will send them to you. All state institutions
have religious exercises, some of them chaplains paid under
state laws. The meetings of the two houses of the General As-
sembly are always opened with prayer in accordance, some-
times, with resolutions (passed unanimously usually), and
sometimes by common consent. The inaugurations of governors
are prefaced by religious exercises.
The general proposition on which you stand is undoubtedly
sound. Whether your particular relief can be granted by a
court is perhaps doubtful; and if you are beaten I am not sure
but the question will go before the committee in a better form
for a final and correct decision by the people without the
intervention of the courts in opposition to the late action of
the School Board than it will with such intervention. But if
I can aid you, call on me.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
[Unidentified.]
COLUMBUS, November 23, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR:--I am in receipt of your favor of the 20th
as to a recommendation for an office in the revenue service. I
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 73
am called upon to sign so many recommendations that I have
acted upon a rule which practically destroys in a great measure
the value of the testimonials I give, viz., to give only general
recommendations, and to give those to all who desire it with this
qualification, that I state what I know or believe to be true in
each case. In this matter I have already given a general testi-
monial to a gentleman who applied to me before your letter
came to hand. If a general letter of the sort indicated will be
of service to you I will be glad to furnish it. Should you wish
a letter, please send me a specimen of the testimonials you are
furnished with.
My kind regards to Mrs. Pittenger.
R. B. HAYES.
MR. J. H. PITTENGER,
Tiffin, Ohio.
COLUMBUS, November 23, 1869.
DEAR H--:--I have been absent or busy moving these last
days or I would have said a word in reply to yours of the 10th.
I published the article* in the Journal. No reflection was of
course intended on you in particular. The general practice you
evidently regard just as I do, and I am sure there is no mis-
understanding on your part of my motives. I regard you as a
man whose soundness of judgment and integrity of purpose in
*The article read:--"An illustration of the thoughtlessness with which
good men sign important petitions occurred at the governor's office a few
days ago. A petition for the pardon of a convict numerously signed was
presented to Governor Hayes. Among the signers was a gentleman
known to the governor to be a man of integrity and good sense. The
gentleman was written to and asked what he knew or could learn as to
the merits of the case. A few days afterwards the governor received a
reply, marked 'private', in which the writer said: 'I signed the petition
for his pardon presented to me by his wife. My tenderness of heart in
the case overcame my judgment. As no good would be accomplished
by his pardon, I fully investigated the case. I could obtain no redeeming
quality in the convict from those familiar with him. He is represented
by all as a very dangerous person to run at large, and from reports he is
a natural thief and would, no doubt, continue his former career if par-
doned.'"
74 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
such a case may be implicitly relied on; and the point was made
clearer to my mind than it can be to the public.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
JOHN J. HOOKER, ESQ.,
Cincinnati.
Private.
COLUMBUS, November 23, 1869.
DEAR GOVERNOR:--I thank you for your efforts in the Le-
roy matter. I have no doubt he is deliberately trying to levy
blackmail on me. The pretext is a deposit claimed to have
been made by his son when a soldier in my command. I find
abundant evidence that the claim is a fabrication of Leroy.
At first I did not know but he was acting in good faith, and
that the fraud was in the informants.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL LUCIUS FAIRCHILD,
Governor of Wisconsin.
Columbus, Ohio, November 28, 1869.--On the 17th we be-
gan to move from our late residence, 51 East State Street, to
Judge Swayne's residence on Seventh Street, facing west and
opposite the centre of East State Street. We are to pay eight
hundred dollars per year and to have the use of some articles of
furniture. It is a fine, large house with ample grounds. The
rent is cheap.
I was re-elected by 7501 majority over Mr. Pendleton, and
shall remain in office two years from next January, if nothing
occurs to prevent.
December 2, 1869.--I now begin to collect materials and set
down a few items for my annual message:--
1. Fifteenth Amendment--a few words of emphatic recom-
mendation and approval. 2. Soldiers' Orphans' Homes. 3.
Reform, improvement, or progress in prison discipline. 4. The
Reappraisement. 5. The Geological Survey. 6. Inebriate
Asylum. 7. Incurable Insane. 8. Agricultural fund; college
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 75
to be located, (See 1859, p. 51). --(Mem.:--In my brief in-
augural why not suggest topics, improvements, or amendments
of the Constitution?)
Take up the benevolent and reformatory institutions; give
their condition, number of inmates, cost, etc., etc. (See Gov-
ernor Chase's message 1860.)
To recommend clearly and briefly the things deemed best
without argument or illustration.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, December 2, 1869.
DEAR HASTINGS:--I am in receipt of your note of the 30th
ult. It is of course flattering and pleasant to be thought of in
that connection, and I appreciate the value of the support sug-
gested, but I do not feel like scheming to that end. Perhaps
I may be ready sometime to do what is commonly done, but so
long in advance, I am indisposed to make figures, or even to
decide the question of giving my own consent to a continuance
in public life. I feel now like quitting. I hope for your pocket's
sake that the business will be in your hands.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL RUSSELL HASTINGS.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, December 4, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR: -- Yours of yesterday received. I think there
will be small opposition in the committee to keeping the Lincoln
out of sight until the inauguration of the complete work. But
we do insist upon getting it here away from your tinder-box.
I expect to hear you have been burnt out by next mail, and shall
continue in that agreeable state of mind until relieved by the
happening of that event! It is only the special providence which
watches over you and the sparrows which has saved you so
long!
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
T. D. JONES, ESQ.,
76 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
COLUMBUS, OHIO, December 6, 1869.
DEAR GENERAL:--I am just in receipt of your note of the
third with an article from the Statesman annexed. The article
had not attracted my attention, but of course I should not have
publicly noticed it. There is not a word of truth in it so far
as I am concerned. I have spent but two days in Washington
since Grant's inauguration--yes, it was four or five days-
and took no part against you then or at any time. No assur-
ance was needed that neither you nor your friends are respon-
sible for this sort of insinuation; but I am glad to feel safe that
such things can't sow tares between us.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL HICKENLOOPER,
Cincinnati, Ohio.
Private.
COLUMBUS, December 7, 1869.
DEAR SIR:--I concur with your views of prison discipline
so far as I know them. In my next message I wish to say a
few words recommending the creation of a prison for young
offenders to be conducted on the principles of your report of
December, 1868, (Twenty-fourth Annual Report), and to call
attention in a general way to the Irish convict system. The
present Board of Directors and the Warden of the Ohio Peni-
tentiary are prepared to take enlightened and humane action.
But I do not anticipate the immediate adoption of your theory.
My desire is to say enough to open the subject to the considera-
tion of the people of the State. If you have issued, or can refer
me to any new publications on the subject, I will be glad to send
you their cost.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
E. C. WINES,
Prison Association of New York.
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 77
COLUMBUS, December 11, 1869.
DEAR SIR:--I am today in receipt of your letter of the 8th
inst., expressing the opinion that Mr. James Leroy is honest
in making a claim against me for money left with me by his
son. There is no foundation for the claims and to enable me
to discover who is the guilty party in getting up the claim, I
will be obliged to you if you will give me the names and address
of the parties whose statements you refer to, "oral and written,"
which you have heard and seen.
Respectfully,
R. B. HAYES.
HONORABLE D. W. C. WILSON,
Sparta, Wisconsin.
COLUMBUS, December 11, 1869.
DEAR SIR:--I am today in receipt of your letter of the 8th
inst., inclosing letters from gentlemen of your acquaintance,
showing their opinion that you are acting in good faith in mak-
ing a claim on me for money deposited with me by your son.
Assuming that they are innocent, somebody is guilty of an at-
tempt to impose on you. There is no truth whatever in the
story about Leroy leaving money with me. Your friends can
have no objection to giving me the names in full and post-
office addresses of your informants that I may investigate the
whole matter.
Yours, etc.,
R. B. HAYES.
JAMES LEROY,
Sparta, Wisconsin.
COLUMBUS, December 19, 1869.
DEAR SIR: -- I am exceedingly obliged by your prompt reply
to my letter as to prison reform and for the volumes of valuable
documents on the subject which you forwarded. No sudden or
sweeping reform will be attempted here. But we desire to en-
courage the formation of correct opinions and hope that a
gradual but steady advance may be made towards a reformatory
system. The principles of the Irish system can I believe be
78 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
introduced in practice without undertaking to copy in detail
a scheme which may in some of its features be unsuited to our
conditions.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
E. C. WINES.
COLUMBUS, December 20, 1869.
DEAR GENERAL:--A scoundrel in Wisconsin is trying to
blackmail me. He claims that on the morning of Sheridan's
victory of Winchester, October 19, 1864, his son deposited with
me from eight hundred to one thousand dollars, money lately
received for pay and veteran bounty. The boy was killed in the
battle. It is all false, and I now desire to get the amounts paid to
the boy between January I, 1864, and October 19, 1864. I will
pay any clerk you may set at the job of digging it up for his
trouble and be greatly obliged for a statement or certificate that I
can show if necessary. The boy's name was Nelson J. Leroy,
private Company I, Twenty-third Regiment 0. V. I.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL B. W. BRICE,
Washington, D. C.
COLUMBUS, December 21, 1869.
DEAR GENERAL:--I have your letter of the 20th and am
glad to know, what I believed before, that you would stand by
the flag notwithstanding the attractions of Montana until the
crisis of organization and the Fifteenth Amendment is passed.
I am advised, I think authentically, that the Hamilton members
have settled to give the pro tempore Speaker of the Senate
to the Democrats, Clerk to the Republicans, and so alternate
through the offices and committees. In the House, Speaker,
Republican, Clerk, Democrat, etc., on down. [The prospect
for the ratification of the] Fifteenth Amendment [is] hopeful.
Russell's vacancy will be filled in time. There may be an effort
to claim that no vacancy existed authorizing a special election,
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 79
Russell not being a Senator until admitted and sworn. But
West says it is all bosh. There was a vacancy, etc., etc.
Congratulations and regards to Mrs. Governor Potts.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL B. F. POTTS.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, December 23, 1869.
MY DEAR SIR:--I received your dispatch about the Chase
portrait. I think it altogether probable that Mr. Cook would
like to do the graceful thing in that behalf. But the main ques-
tion which I now put is, who shall bell the cat? Who shall
name the matter to Mr. Cook? In scriptural phrase may I
not say: "Thou art the man"?
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
S. C. L'HOMMEDIEU,
Cincinnati, Ohio.
COLUMBUS, December 29, 1869.
DEAR SIR:--I am asked to write you in behalf of young
Hosea, now in the State Prison of your State. I have no
knowledge of him or of his crime. There is no doubt that his
widowed mother is a most estimable woman, and that the
gentlemen who take an interest in the case are worthy in all
respects. Dr. Wadsworth, who will visit you, is, I know, an
upright, conscientious, and truthful gentleman. I bespeak for
him and his statements the utmost confidence and consideration.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
GENERAL J. W. GEARY,
GOVERNOR OF PENNSYLVANIA.
COLUMBUS, December 29, 1869.
DEAR SIR:--I thank you for your kind favor of the 17th
inst. I will now give you a few of the facts which I have ascer-
tained bearing upon the merits of Leroy's claim.
80 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
1. N. J. Leroy re-enlisted as a veteran January 1, 1864, and
was at Cleveland and at home on a veteran furlough in Feb-
uary, 1864, and at the end of his furlough borrowed money of
a comrade to enable him to return to his regiment.
2. After his return to his regiment he was paid only once
prior to his death, and the amount paid was $169.75.
3. The rest of his pay and bounty due from the Govern-
ment was paid to his "legal representatives" after his death,
amounting to $365.
4. His local bounty due from the town of Youngstown was
paid after his death to his mother, amounting to
These facts I have from three sources, viz., the first from his
comrades in Cleveland; the second, third, and fourth from cer-
tificates of the proper officers of which I enclose you copies.
I think you will now agree with me that the only remaining
question in this matter is, whether your townsman, James Leroy,
has been himself deceived, or whether he is guilty of an attempt
to defraud?
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
HONORABLE D. W. C. WILSON,
Sparta, Wisconsin.
COLUMBUS, December 31, 1869.
DEAR LAWRENCE:--You are perfectly right in your view.
We must have a genuine retrenchment and economy. The
monthly reduction of the debt is of far more consequence than
the reduction of taxation in any form. I hope too you will
abolish the franking privilege, and adopt the general principles
of Trumbull's bill and Jenckes' bill. It would please the people,
and [is] right and wise. I will act on your suggestions.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
HONORABLE WILLIAM LAWRENCE,
Washington.
January 2, 1870. -- We have enjoyed the holidays better than
ever before. All the boys at home, happy, well-behaved, and
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 81
promising; litle Fan a sunbeam; Lucy improved and appreciated.
Our large, fine house, belonging to Judge Swayne, our re-elec-
tion, and many circumstances combine to make this a time of
great satisfaction and enjoyment. My inaugural, I thought of
at church. To be very short; a sentence or two of acknowledg-
ment and then, as the Constitution is to [be] amendable in my
time -- in my new term -- suggest for consideration changes as
to subscription to railroads, as to temperance, as to courts, as to
suffrage, as to minority representation, as to local debts -- all
debts.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, January 5, 1870.
DEAR SIR: -- My attention has been called to the claim of the
State of Ohio against the United States for two per cent of
the net proceeds arising from the sales of public lands within
the State to be expended by Congress in constructing roads. It
is believed that the State has a valid claim and Mr. William A.
Adams visits Washington to investigate the facts. I trust you
will afford him such facilities and assistance for his work as
you may deem proper.
Respectfully,
R. B. HAYES.
HONORABLE JACOB D. COX,
Washington, D. C.
COLUMBUS, January 6, 1870.
MY DEAR SIR: -- In reply to your favor of the 4th: I do
not regard the organization of the [Ohio] House as an indica-
tion of any new difficulty. The House contains one hundred
and twelve members as at present organized. One Republican
member represents a county which Democrats claim is not en-
titled to representation. Mr. Blakeslee, of Williams County,
feels confident that he can't be ousted. One Republican seat
is contested, viz., Mr. Glover, of Scioto. I am confident he is
also safe. The House therefore stands, and I think will stand
to the end, Republicans, straight, 53; Democrats, straight, 49;
Republican Reformers 5; Democratic Reformers 5. The Demo-
6
82 RUTHERFORD BIRCHARD HAYES
cratic Reformers will probably all vote against the Fifteenth
Amendment making 54 negative votes.
We regard it as certain beyond contingency that three Re-
publican Reformers will vote for the Amendment making 56
affirmative votes, or exactly one-half of the House. The other
two Republican Reformers we think will vote for the Amend-
ment, or at the worst will refuse to vote either way. In either
event the Amendment is ratified. I say probably the Democratic
Reformers will vote no. Many of our friends are confident
that two of them will either vote aye or refuse to vote. They
and others in the Democratic party want the Amendment rati-
fied. But I do not reckon on their help.
In short, I regard the chances as good. If you can help us
in any way, do not fail to do it. The Amendment will probably
not be ratified in the Senate until a week from today, January
13. It then goes to the House, and the final struggle is there.
I am quite confident of success.
Sincerely,
HONORABLE O. P. MORTON, R. B. HAYES.
Washington, D. C.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, January 12, 1870.
DEAR AUNTY DAVIS:--It pleased me to know that you ap-
proved of the message. It is a matter of no consequence who
wrote it. The rule as to public documents is that the signature
determines the authorship. I will send you the inaugural also.
You will like the enclosed slips written by Nordhoff and which
he desired me to send to you. I would like to keep them and
will thank you to return them. The ground is the true one. We
must not let them push religion out of the schools, but we must
avoid forcing it on anybody. You may ask, How are the two
things to be accomplished? Well, it is easier to do the thing
than to tell how to do it.
Regards to Dr. Davis and the young people.
Sincerely,
MRS. DR. JOHN DAVIS, R. B. HAYES.
Cincinnati, Ohio.
GOVERNOR OF OHIO--1868-1869 83
Confidential.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, January 13, 1870.
MY DEAR SIR:--I think we can now give the result of the
struggle on the Fifteenth Amendment. The subject is under
debate in the Senate and ratification will carry when the vote
is reached--probably tomorrow. In the House of one hun-
dred and twelve members we reckon certain fifty-seven votes,
fifty-three straight Republicans and the Speaker (Mr. Cunning-
ham), Mr. Bates, Mr. Hill, and Mr. Kleinschmidt, Republican
Reformers. These are all openly and decidedly now with us on
the main question, and on all questions likely to affect our strength
on the main question. Besides, we have the best chance for the
vote of Mr. Hambleton, Republican Reformer, and some chance
of getting two or three Democrats to dodge the vote.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
HONORABLE O. P. MORTON,
Washington, D. C.
COLUMBUS, January 15, 1870.
MY DEAR SIR:--I congratulate you very heartily on the re-
sult of the election in your State. Having some knowledge by
reputation and otherwise of General Hamilton, Governor Pease,
and Judge Bell, I felt some doubt when I last saw you as to the
true condition of affairs in Texas. I was unwilling to think
that those gentlemen intended to abandon the Republican Party.
I regret their course. Your opinions and conduct have been
fully vindicated by the issue, and I trust your services will
secure you the honorable recognition which I am told your
friends propose to give you.
Sincerely,
R. B. HAYES.
MR. JOHN W. GLENN,
Washington, D. C.