Ohio History Journal

INDEX TO VOLUME XXXII

 

 

Alder, Jonathan, early pioneer, honored                                  Bible, Indian   translates Gospels into

with marker, 533-536; sketch of life                                        Shawnee language, 339-340; Bibles pro-

by great-granddaughter, 534-535; ad-                                     vided for prisoners at Ohio Peni-

dresses by C. B. Galbreath, L. C.                                              tentiary, 390.

Dick and others, 535; unveiling by                                   Bibliography:   Shorthorn  Cattle, 65-66;

descendants, 535; list of descendants                                       works of George Kennan, 226; Mitch-

present, 535-536.                                                                       ener's Legend of the White Woman,

Alford, Thomas Wildcat, descendant of                                          299-300; Hicks' History of Penal In-

Tecumseh, sketch of, 339; at dedica-                                       stitutions in  Ohio, 423-426; Cady's

tion of monument to George Rogers                                         Western Opinion and the War of

Clark, 497.                                                                                 1812, 475-476; works of Frank G. Car-

Algonquin Indians, language of, 519.                                               penter, 530.

Allen, Governor William, 182.                                                 Bigelow, Russell, 399.

American Historical Association, meets in                              Billings, Josh, pseud. See Shaw, Henry

Columbus, 95-103; address by Dr. H.                                      W.

A. Garfield, 96-97; by Dr. E. P. Chey-                             "Black Beard," pirate, 4.

ney, 97-101; by Professor Carl Wittke,                            Blackfoot Indians, language of, 518-519.

101.                                                                                    Blue-laws, cited, 210.

Ames, Nabby Lee, Chapter, Daughters of                               Book Reviews: Sargent Genealogy, 318-

the American Revolution, 87-89.                                              321; Scenic and Historic Ohio, 324-

Andrew, John A., quoted, 218.                                                         325; The Mythology of All Races--

Andrews, Charles M., 102.                                                               Vol. XI--Latin American, 325-328;

Annual address of president of Amer-                                             Logan the Mingo, 536-537.

ican Historical Association, excerpts                               Booth, Henry J., address at dedication

from, 97-101.                                                                            of James E. Campbell Elm, 83-84.

Armstrong, John, 361.                                                               Bradford, Gamaliel, his estimate of John

Ashby, Benjamin, 93.                                                                        Brown, 217-218.

Assenisipia, 119.                                                                         Bradford, Thomas, Jr., 375.

Athens, exercises at, preliminary to ded-                                 Brazil, local architect plans building for,

ication of tablet at Fort Gower, 87-88.                                     107.

Brough, Mayor Bernard F., Address at

Backus, Mrs. Herbert, 105.                                                               dedication of Peter Navarre memo-

Badgley, George, prosecutor in case, State                                     rial, 86.

of Ohio vs. Abigail Church, 206.                                      Brown, John, Gamaliel Bradford on, 217-

Baker, Rev. Purley A., sketch of, 216;                                              218; Frederick Douglass on, 218; John

birth, connection  with  Anti-Saloon                                         A. Andrew on, 218; influence of song,

League, death, appreciation of, 216.                                        "John Brown's body---," 218, 224;

Bancroft, George, quoted, 155.                                                        C. B. Galbreath on, 217-224; Leland

Bassett, John S., 102.                                                                         H. Jenks on, 218-224; J. J. Ingalls on,

Bates, Cadwallader, 33-34, 55.                                                         221.

Bates, Thomas, of Kirklevington, 31-34,                                  Buckingham, Ebenezer, 379.

40-41, 55; independence of, 55-56.                                  Bundy, Maj. Gen. Omar, 493, 494.

Battleship Ohio, silver service of, trans-                                   Burdell, 406, 409.

ferred to Ohio State Archaeological                                 Burr, Aaron, agents of, cause discontent

and Historical Society, 527.                                                       among Indians, 441-442.

Benton, Thomas H., 111; detraction of                                     Business meeting of American Historical

Dane, 130-132; ascribes authorship of                                     Association, 101.

Ordinance to Jefferson, 131; answered                            Butler, General Richard, 237.

by Webster, 132; 136, 137, 142, 143; ex-                          Butterfield, Consul W., quotation from,

tracts from  his Thirty Years' View,                                             283; assertion concerning first white

146-147.                                                                                      woman settler in Ohio, 283-284.

For Index to Annual Meeting of Society and Board of Trustees, see page 613.

(597)

• 1
 

598                                   Index

 

Cady, John F., "Western Opinion and                                               Civil Service  Commission, first men-

the War of 1812," 427-474.                                                                   tion of, 189-191.

Calhoun, John C., 304; and the War of                                             Civil Service Reform, Ohio's Contribution

1812, 459.                                                                                               to, 176-204.

Camp Charlotte, 80, 92, 105.

Clark, General George Rogers, sketch of

Campbell, Ex-Governor James E., tree

life, 483-487; dedication of monument

planted in honor of, 80-86; presides

to, 492-499.

at meeting of American Historical

Association, 96; debate with William                                        Clay, Henry, interested in importing of

McKinley, 183; address at dedication                                                   good cattle, 30; Clay and the War

of George Rogers Lark monument,                                          of 1812, 459-464; quotation from, 470-

495-497; misses Ohio History Day, 531.                                   471.

Campus Martius, first court held at, 362;                                          Coates Herdbook of Shorthorn Cattle,

first jail and courthouse, 365.              54-55.

Canada, 432, 441, 443-444, 448, 451, 454-455,                               Cockins, Miss Edith D., presents wrist-

458, 465-466, 467-468, 469-470, 472.                                                   watch, 315.

Carlisle, John F., address on Ohio His-                                             Cole, Professor A. C., 102.

tory Day, 105; 531-533.                                                             Conkling, Roscoe, 187.

Carlisle Indian School, graduate of, in                                              Contributors and contributions, Plumb,

Columbus, 532.                                                                                       Charles Sumner, "Felix Renick, Pio-

Carpenter, Frank G., sketch of, 528-530;                                                     neer," 3-66; Miller, Aaron, "Diary

list of books by him, 530.                                                                       of Aaron Miller," 67-79; Galbreath,

Carrington, Colonel Edward, 164, 165, 175.                                                 C. B., "The Ordinance of 1787, its

Carter, Howard, sketch of, 332; lectures                                          origin and authorship," 111-175; "Ohio's

in Columbus, 332; visits Ohio State                                                        Contribution to National Civil Serv-

Archaeological and Historical Museum,                                  ice Reform," 176-204; Douglas, Albert,

332; autograph of, 333.                                                              "Ohio's Only Witchcraft Case," 205-

Carthage, Ancient, lecture on, 334.                                                  214; Sargent, Charles Sprague, "Win-

Cary, Samuel, 182.                                                                             throp Sargent," 229-236;  Sargent,

Catalogues, of cattle purchased in Eng-                                                       Winthrop, "Diary while with General

land by Felix Renick, 35-36; of cattle                                       Arthur St. Clair's Expedition against

sold at first sale of Ohio Company                                            the Indians," 237-273; "Journal, 1793-

for Importing English Cattle, 45-48;                                         1795, Extracts from," 273-282; Smythe,

of dispersal sale, 49-50.                                                                         George F., "Mitchener's 'Legend of

Cattle, Shorthorn, introduced in Amer-                                             the White Woman, and Newcomers-

ica, 21-54.                                                                                              town',"  283-300; Galbreath, C. B.,

Caughnawaga Indians, 285-287.                                                                   "Thomas Smith   Grimke,"   301-312;

Centenary of Lafayette's visit to Amer-                                                       Shetrone, H. C., "Exploration of the

ica, suggested by McGuffey Society,                                       Wright Group of Pre-historic earth-

323-324.                                                                                      works," 341-358; Hicks, Clara    B.,

Chase, Chief Justice Salmon P., 112.                                                             "History  of Penal Institutions in

Chase, Samuel, 117, 131, 133, 136.                                                               Ohio to 1850," 359-426; Cady, John F.,

Cheves, Langdon, and the War of 1812,                                           "Western Opinion and the War of

459.                                                                                             1812," 427-476; Thompson, William O.,

Cheyney Dr. Edward P., address to the                                            "Significance of Memorials," 477-491;

American   Historical Association on                                       Galbreath, C. B., "Dedication of Mon-

"Law in History," 97; excerpts from                                         ument to George Rogers Clark," 492-

address, 97-101.                                                                         499; "Funeral of Adam Willis Wag-

Chubb, Dean Edwin, address on "The                                               nalls," 500-504; Markham, Edwin, "Ad-

Larger Patriotism," 89.                                                               dress at Funeral of Adam W. Wag-

Church, Abigail, defendant in case of                                              nalls," 504-514; Galbreath, C. B., "The

State of Ohio vs. Abigail Church,                                              Funk and Wagnalls Company," 514-

206-214.                                                                                      515; Silver Service of the Battleship

Chute, James, 391.                                                                                          Ohio, 527; Frank G. Carpenter, 528-

Cincinnati, suggested as site for new                                                530; Ohio History Day at Logan Elm

penitentiary, 379.                                                                        Park, 530-533; Honors to the Memory

• 2
 

Index                                    599

 

of Jonathan Alder, 533-536; "Logan                                  Daughters of the American Revolution,

the Mingo," 536-537.                                                                 Ohio, erect monument at Fort Gower,

Convict Labor, inaugurated in Ohio Peni-                                        87-94.

tentiary, 375.                                                                       Daughters of the War of 1812, unveil

Cook, I. S., on cattle industry in the                                                  marker in honor of Jonathan Alder,

Scioto Valley, 64.                                                                      535.

Copeland, Mrs. John, reads sketch of                                       Davis, Jefferson, his relationship to Gen-

Jonathan Alder, 534.                                                                 eral Grant, 323.

Cornstalk,  Shawnee    chief,  concludes                                  Debtors' prison, 365.

treaty at Camp Charlotte, 92.                                             "Dedication of Monument to George

Corwin, Thomas, 363.                                                                       Rogers   Clark,"  492-499; Battle  of

Craig, Governor, of Canada, 470.                                                    Piqua, 492; birth-place of Tecumseh,

Craig, Mrs. T. W., 89.                                                                       492; program   of exercises, 49-499;

Cree Indians, 519.                                                                             excerpts from addresses of Dr. B. F.

Creek Indians, 450, 456, 519.                                                           Prince, Ex-Governor James E. Camp-

Crosby, Otis, 380.                                                                              bell, Governor Vic Donahey, General

Crosby, Samuel, 380.                                                                         J. Warren   Keifer and Dr. W. O.

Cunningham   Miss Gladys, 62.                                                         Thompson, 494-499.

Cunningham, Renick, 35, 62.                                                     Deerfield, Massachusetts, massacre, 285-

Cunningham, Mrs. Renick, 62.                                                          287.

Cunningham, Robert, 26.                                                           Democratic party in Ohio, attitude to-

Curtis, George William, 186.                                                            ward Civil Service Reform, 194, 198-

Custis, Miss, 275.                                                                               202.

Cutler, Julia P., "Life, journals and                                           Demonstration, after Indian Chief's ad-

correspondence of Manasseh Cutler,"                                     dress at Logan Elm Park, 533.

155.                                                                                     Denny, Captain Ebenezer, 237.

Cutler, Manasseh, 112; urged     by  Dr.                                   Deshler, Miss Helen, sponsor of Battle-

Poole as author of Ordinance of 1787,                                     ship Ohio, presents loving-cup, 527.

149-170; by Cutler's grandchildren, in                              Deshler, Mrs. W. G., presents two flags

his Life, journals and correspondence,                                      to Battleship Ohio, 527.

155-158; Mr. Stone's view, 158-160;                                 Deshler, W. D., 380.

Mr. Barrett's, 160-161; Life, journals                                Diaries, Miller, Aaron, 67-79; Sargent

and correspondence, 161-162; opens       Winthrop, 237-273; 273-282.

first court held in Northwest Terri-

tory, 362.                                                                            Diary of Winthrop Sargent, while with

Cutler, William  P., Life, journals and                                               General Arthur St. Clair's expedition

correspondence of Manesseh Cutler,                                       against the Indians, 237-273.

quotations from, 155-158.                                                  Dimick, Mrs. Helen W., unveils Peter

Navarre -nemorial, 86.

Damaged Souls, by Gamaliel Bradford,                                   Donahey, Governor Vic, 83, 84-85; at ded-

quoted, 217.                                                                               ication of Clark Monument, 493; in-

Dane, Nathan, endorsed by Rufus King                                           troduces guests from other states, 497-

as author of Ordinance of 1787, 112;                                       498; assists in securing silver service,

on committee to draft form   of gov-                                        527.

ernment for Western Territory, 123-                                Douglas, Albert, "Ohio's Only Witchcraft

125, 129; Webster's references to, 130,                                   Case," 205-214.

132-133; Benton's detraction of, 139-                               Douglas, Richard, sketch of, 205-206; ar-

132; Webster sustains claim to Dane's                                     gument in case of State of Ohio vs.

authorship, 132-134, 135; his letter to                                       Abigail Church, 208-214.

J. H. Farnham, 136-137; referred to                                 Douglass, Frederick, on John Brown, 218.

by Governor Coles, 146; by Senator                                  Dryer, Mrs. O. D., 532.

Benton, 146; by Mr. Poole, 148, 149;                                 Dublin, Earthworks found near, 341-358.

but what of slavery, 150-151; claims                                 Dun, Walter, imports Shorthorns, 27.

to authorship upheld by Stone, 160;                                   Dunmore's, Lord, War, 90-94.

by Dane himself, 162-164, 165, 168,

170; sketch of, 170-172.                Eagle Feather, story of, 292-293.

• 3
 

600                                    Index

 

Eaton, Dorman B., head of National                                          First observance of Ohio History Day,

Civil Service Reform Association, 198.                                      104.

"The Education of Henry Adams," ref-                                     First penitentiary in Ohio, projected, 371;

erence to, 182-183.                                                                     built, 372, 374; occupied, 374.

Egypt, Ancient, lecture on, 332.                                                 First physician at Ohio Penitentiary, 387.

Ellery, William, 133.                                                                  First president to recommend Congres-

Elliot, Colonel Robert, killed by Indians,                                            sional action on civil service reform,

278-279.                                                                                       187.

Elliott, Eva L., 107.                                                                     First prisoners in Ohio Penitentiary, 374.

Elwood, Professor P. H., compiler of                                        First sale of cattle by Ohio Company for

Scenic and Historic Ohio, 324-325.                                           Importing English Cattle, 44-49, 62.

Embargo Act, one cause of War of 1812,                                First suggestion of any governor that

433.                                                                                             the state provide for criminals, 371.

Emerson, Ralph W., 218.                                                           First visit of Felix Renick to Ohio, 6-8.

Ewing, Thomas, 363.                                                                 First warden of Ohio Penitentiary, 381.

Ewing, Senator Thomas, 206.                                                    First warden of the New Penitentiary,

398.

Farmer and Mechanic, extract from, 37.                                 First white woman settler in Ohio, 283.

Farnham, John H., letter to, from                                              First women's building at Ohio Peni-

Nathan Dane, 136-137.                                                             tentiary, 381-382.

Felix Renick School-house, 57.                                                 First writing, in America, of Poland-

Fess, Senator Simeon D., 499.                                                           China swine pedigrees, 62.

First address by an Indian chief, before                                   Flags, from Battleship Ohio, 527.

the  Ohio  State  Archaeological and                                Florida, Spanish West, annexed by Pres-

Historical Society, 336.                                                              ident Madison, 465; more of Florida

First Board of directors for Ohio Peni-                                             threatened, 465.

tentiary chosen, 379.                                                         Foot resolution, Webster's speech on, 129-

First chaplain  provided at Ohio peni-                                               130; Benton on, 130-132.

tentiary, 399.                                                                      Force, Peter, on the Ordinance of 1787,

First company in America, formed to im-                                         147.

port improved cattle from   England,                                Foster, Sir Augustus J., 463, 465.

28-30.                                                                                 Friends, Society of, 339.

First convict labor at Ohio Penitentiary,                                   Frontier, character of, 429-430.

375.                                                                                     Funk, Isaac K., sketch of, 514-515.

First court held in Northwest Territory,                                    Fur trade, dependence of red men upon,

362.                                                                                             439.

First drove of fat cattle taken East, 20.                                     Fur-traders, sinister influence of, on In-

First herdbook of any breed of cattle,                                               dians, 443-444.

54-55.

First importation  of pure bred    cattle                                     Galbraith, Mrs. Nelson A., 86.

from  England, 21-22.                                                       Galbreath, C. B., Dedication of the

First improved cattle to go west of the                                              James E. Campbell Elm, 80-86; Peter

Alleghanies, 22.                                                                         Navarre Day, 86; Unveiling of Tablet

First interview granted by a Chinaman,                                            at Fort Gower, 87-94; The Ordinance

529.                                                                                             of 1787, its Origin and Authorship,

First judges in the Northwest Territory,                                            111-175; Ohio's Contribution to Na-

361.                                                                                             tional Civil Service Reform, 176-294;

First keeper at Ohio Penitentiary, 383.                                              Thomas S. Grimke, 301-312; Dr. Wil-

First law  providing for punishment in                                              liam O. Thompson, 313-317; Howard

the penitentiary, 373-374.                                                          Carter, 332; Count Byron K. de Pro-

First law  providing religious help and                                              rok, 334; Buffalo Child Long Lance,

instruction in penitentiary, 391.                                                 336; Thomas W. Alford, 339-340; Ded-

First mention of a Civil Service Com-                                               ication of Monument to George Rog-

mission, 189-191.                                                                       ers Clark, 492-499; Funeral of Adam

First monument in America to a cattle                                              W. Wagnalls, 500-504; Buffalo Child

importer, 62.                                                                               Long Lance Visits Ohio, 516-526.

• 4
 

Index                                      601

 

Gallatin, Secretary Albert, 461.                                               Grimke, Thomas Smith, ancestry, birth,

Gallia County, 205.                                                                           303; graduation, legal studies, extract

Gard, Dr. B. F., 411.                                                                         from   earliest address, 303-304; devo-

Garden, John, 65.                                                                              tion to the Union, 304; elected Sen-

Garden and Forest, 321.                                                                   ator from South Carolina, 304; strug-

Garfield, Dr. Harry A., address to Amer-                                       gles against nullification, 304; pleads

ican Historical Association on "Re-                                         for "Liberty and  union," 304-305;

cent Political Development: Progress                                       deeply religious, 305; a Bible student,

or Change?" excerpts from, 96.                                                305; interest in Sunday-school work,

Garland, Dr., address at dedication of                                             305-306; speaks at Sunday-school jubi-

tablets at Fort Gower, 88-89.                                                    lee, compares Lafayette and Robert

Garrison, William   Lloyd, 311.                                                        Raikes, 306-307; no bigot, but a re-

Gault, W. W., 389, 399.                                                                    former, 308; opposed to war, 308-309;

Gay, Dr. Norman, 411.                                                                     advocate of temperance and popular

Geisinger, A. W., 532.                                                                      education, 309; of agricultural and

Gessner, Frank, 322.                                                                         mechanic arts, 309; lectures in Ohio,

Ghent, Treaty of, 470; changes character                                       309; portrait, 309; denounces predom-

of war, 471; reveals true animus of                                          inance of classics and mathematics,

Great Britain, 471.                                                                     310; death, 310; burial, 311; epitaph,

Gist, Christopher, mentions Mary Harris,                                         311; daughters, 311; tribute to, 311-

288.                                                                                            312; his optimism, 312; quoted, 324.

Glick, Governor George W., 221.                                            Gross, T. Wallace, 494.

Gobel, Charles J., 493.                                                              Grundy, Felix, 459.

Gough and Miller, first cattle importers

from  England, 21-22; 25.                                                 Hale, Dr. Edward E., 154.

Gower, Fort, Unveiling of Tablet at, 87;                                  Hamilton, Mrs. Kent, 86.

program, 87-88; excerpts from Athens                             Hamilton, Fort, 237.

Messenger, 88-89; speech of Mrs. O.                               Hammond, Charles, 363.

D. Dailey, 89-91; speech of Mrs. O.                                 Harding, President Warren G., 107, 187.

D. Dryer, 92-94.                                                                Harness, Edwin J., associate of Felix

Grant, President Ulysses S., first presi-                                             Renick, 32, 35, 40.

dent to recommend Congressional ac-                              Harness, Joseph, 5.

tion on Civil Service Reform, 187;                                     Harris, Mary, Story of, 283-300; first

quotations from   messages and inau-                                        white woman settler in  Ohio, 283;

gural, 187-190; disappointed, 190; the                                       controversy concerning, 283-284; false

Commission authorized, 189-190; John                                      statements in histories, 284; Coshoc-

J. Ingalls' estimate of, 221; side-                                                ton county histories mislead, 284; true

lights on his last days, 321-323; his                                             sketch of Mary Harris' life, 285-290;

relations with  Judge Taft, 231-323;                                          Deerfield massacre, 285; Mary Harris

his relationship to Jefferson   Davis,                                          a captive, carried to Canada, 285-286;

323.                                                                                              training, 286-287; becomes a Catholic,

Grayson, William, 123.                                                                       287; marries, 287; testimony to, by

Christopher Gist, 288; James Smith

Great Britain, could not influence West-                                           also, 288-289; Robert Eastman cor-

ern politics, 431; her strength, 432;                                             roborates her story, 289; summary,

her disregard of maritime rights, 433-                                        290;  false story in "Legend of the

434; suspected of stirring up trouble                                           White Woman," 290-299; sources, in-

among Indians, 438440; British prop-                                         accuracies,  discrepancies,  anachron

aganda, 443, 448, 450, 451, 453, 457;                                         isms, 290-293; all successfully   com-

her active aid to Indians, 454, (and                                             bated, 290-299.

notes); demand for war against, 454;                                  Harrison, General William H., 86; favors

intrigues  at Tippecanoe, 461; real                                              Indian land purchases, 435-436; makes

causes of War of 1812, 462-463; Treaty                                    large  purchases, 436, 440; deplores

of Ghent, 470-473.

effect of liquor on Indians, 437-438;

Green Lawn Cemetery, tribute to, by C.                                             pleads for justice to red man, 438-

B. Galbreath, 301.                                                                        439; complains of high price of land,

• 5
 

602                                    Index

 

Harrison, General Wm. H. -- Concluded.                                        in  Northwest Territory, 361; first

440; bribes chiefs, 441; opposes divi-                                        judges in the Northwest Territory,

sion of Indiana Territory, 442; sus-                                           361; influence of Puritan ideals, 361-

pected  of playing politics, 442; re-                                           362; first court in Northwest Terri-

ports peace on the frontier, 444; re-                                         tory, 362; General Rufus Putnam

ceives the "Prophet,"  445; makes                                             quoted, 362; early courts described,

favorable reports, 445-446; sympathizes                                  362-363; wide travels of judges, 363;

with Indians, but covets their lands,                                          Recollections of life in Ohio quoted,

446; corresponds with United States                                         363-364; high standard of morals, 364;

Secretary of War, 447; buys three                                           severe punishments, 364; prices fixed

million acres of land, 447; begins war                                      by court, 364; Cincinnati settled, 364-

preparations, 448; sees in Indian ac-                                        365; first courthouse and jail in Mar-

tivity the hand of Great Britain, 448-                                        ietta, 364; criminal laws promulgated,

449; marches against the "Prophet,"                                          367; various punishments, 367-369; Sab-

and defeats him at Tippecanoe, 452-                                        bath observance, 369; speedy justice,

453; is rebuked by Tecumseh, 453;                                           369; law for building county jails,

collects a company of volunteers, 456;                                    370; land offered to state for building

is chosen military leader, 467; Bat-                                           state prison, 371; offer accepted, 371;

tle of Raisin River, 468; victory at                                            Columbus laid out, 371; committee

the Thames, 469.                                                                        appointed to consider building   of

Hayden, Peter, 406-407, 409.                                                           state prison, 372; first penitentiary

Hayne, Robert Y, 111, 129; Webster's                                             built, 372; description, 373-374; first

reply to, 132; Webster's eulogy of                                            prisoners in penitentiary, 374; a new

Ohio precipitates the Webster-Hayne                                      building needed -- built, 374; enlarged

Debate, 134; resents Webster's refer-                                     plans, 374-375; workshops included,

ences to slavery, 134-135; partner of                                       375; convict labor introduced, 375;

Thomas S. Grimke, 303, 304.                                                    new penitentiary described, 376; prison

Health, Poor, among Indians, 520-521;                                            labor, 376; cost, 376; great increase

made a world correspondent, 529.                                           of crime, 377; need for further en-

Heaton, Mr., imports cattle from    Eng-                                           largement, 377; new   building urged,

land 22.                                                                                      378; Auburn plan of solitary con-

Hedrick, H. L., 324.                                                                          finement urged, 378; fire at the pen-

Hegler, E., 43.                                                                                   itentiary, 378; old prison undesirable,

Henry, John, of Maryland, 125.                                                        378; new  building urged, 379; corn-

Henry, John, his mission to New Eng-                                              mittee urges removal from     Colum-

land, 462.                                                                                   bus, 379; Zanesville suggested as site,

Herdbook, First ever published, 54-55.                                            379; Columbus chosen, 379; directors

Hicks, Miss Clara Belle, "The History                                              selected, 379; their duties, 379; Na-

of Penal Institutions in Ohio to 1850,"                                       thaniel Medbury chosen superintend-

359-426.                                                                                     ent of buildings, 379-380; site decided

Hiermann, Rev. Francis, speaks at ded-                                           upon and land bought, 380; new pen-

ication of Peter Navarre memorial,                                          itentiary erected, 381; occupied, 381;

86.                                                                                              first women's building, 381-382; total

Higginson, Thomas W., 218.                                                             cost, 382; litigation, 382; inspectors

Hills, F. P., 350.                                                                                  appointed, 385; James Kooken chosen

Hinsdale, Dr. Burke A., 154.                                                            Keeper, 383; duties of inspectors,

Historical Society of Clark County, 494,                                          383-384; election of keeper, 384; his

499.                                                                                            duties, salary, etc. 385; state agent

"The History of Penal Institutions in                                             chosen, his duties, salary, etc., 385-

Ohio to 1850," 359-426; early terri-                                         386; H. Brown appointed Director,

torial period, 359-370; character of                                         386-387; first physician selected, 387;

early settlers, 359-360; Washington's                                       aims and policies, 387-388; discipline,

testimony, 359-360; growth of Mari-                                        388; B. Wright chosen Keeper, 389;

etta, 360; influence of New England,                                       N. McLean succeeds, 389; other keep-

360; French, Irish, Germans, etc., 361;                                    ers, and abolishment of office, 389;

influence of the South, 361; leaders                                         methods of punishment, 389-390; the

• 6
 

Index                                    603

 

stepping mill, 390; Bibles provided,           Hoyt, Helen O., "What the Trees teach

390; chaplains, 390-392; prison labor,       us," poem, 81.

392-394; commutation of sentence, 394-  Hull's defeat, 467; fires the West, 467.

395; satisfactory  results,  394-395;           Hume, Dr. R. H., 499.

health of prisoners, 395-396; cholera       Huston, James A., 62-63.

in penitentiary, 396; board of direct-

ors, 397; warden, his duties, 398;              Illinoia, 119.

offices of superintendent of building        Illustrations:

and warden temporarily united, 389;         Felix Renick, 1.

R. Bigelow  appointed first chaplain,         Residence of, and Monument to, Felix

399; I. Cool named deputy warden,           Renick, 18.

400; his duties, 400; Dr. M. S. Wright        Bronze Plate on Monument to Felix

chosen physician, 400; H. Z. Mills ap-      Renick, 23.

pointed  clerk, 400; directors  visit             Facsimile of title-page of Renick's sale

many other prisons, 400-401; new rules    catalogue, 42.

enforced, 401; aims of the new pen-         Residence of Felix Renick on Indian

itentiary, 401: chaplain dropped, 401;       Creek Farm, 53.

Y. M. Prison Society of Columbus             Silver Trophies won by Felix Renick, 53.

supplies place, 401-402; S. F. Mills           Visitors at Dedication of Monument

acts as chaplain, 402; J. B. Finley,                                            to Renick, 61.

also, builds up a library, 402; Miss             Descendants of Felix Renick at Ded-

M. Williams chosen women's matron,                                     ication, 61.

403; severe punishments, 403; public        Aaron Miller, 68.

opinion aroused, 405; Warden Pat-           Marker and Tablet at Fort Gower, 94.

terson           mitigates     punishments, 405;                              Frank L. Packard, 106.

contract       labor           introduced, 406-410;                         Nathan Dane, 110.

opposed, 408; hostility of Legislature,       Map of Cessions of Territory of the

408-409; forbids renewal of contracts,                                    United States after the Revolution,

409; they expire, 409; Warden Stad-                                        113.

den removed, 410; Asiatic cholera at        Map of Proposed Division                                                     of the

Penitentiary, 410-412; many                      deaths,                        Western   Territory  in                        Jefferson's

410-411;  discipline  relaxed,                     411-412;                     Plan, 120.

good behaviour of prisoners, 412;             Map of Division of the Western Ter-

many win pardons, 412; Penitentiary                                       ritory in the Ordinance of 1774, 122.

becomes a source of income to the           Map of Division of Northwest Ter-

State, 412-413; other improvements,                                        ritory proposed by Grayson, 1786,

413; Warden Dewey advocates erec-                                     124.

tion of House of Correction for boys,        Facsimile of Ordinance of 1787, as

413; Legislative committee urges more                                    first printed, 139-141.

progressive methods, 414; appendix,        George H. Pendleton, 181.

containing rules of New Penitentiary,       Winthrop Sargent, from photograph

414-420; names of officers 1834-1850,                                   of painting by Stuart, 228.

421-422; bibliography, 423-426.                                               Winthrop Sargent, from mezzotint by

Hoar, Senator George F., 154.                                                              St. Memin, 234.

Hobart, Mrs. Lowell F., accepts memo-            Thomas Smith Grimke, from photo-

rial to Fort Gower, 89; presides, 89.                                         graph of painting in Miami Univer-

Hockingport, Dedication of tablet at, 87-                                         sity Library, 302.

94.                                                                                              Dr. William  Oxley Thompson, 313.

Hodgdon, Samuel, letter to, from   Tim-            Charles Sprague Sargent and John

othy Pickering, 112-114.                                                            Singer Sargent, 320.

Hosterman, A. D., 493, 499.                              Facsimile from  Interview  with Gen-

Howe, Elias, 220.                                                                                  eral Grant, 322.

Howe, Mrs. Julia Ward, 224.                             Howard Carter, 333.

Howe, Samuel G., 218, 220. 224.                                                      Facsimile of Signature of Howard

Howell, David, 117, 131, 133, 136.                                                       Carter, 333.

Howells, William C., quoted, 363-364.              Count Byron Khun de Prorok, 335.

• 7
 

604                                   Index

 

Illustrations -- Concluded.                                                                  of their land, in the West, one cause

Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance, 337.                                      of War of 1812, 428, 434-440; British

Facsimile of signature of the Chief,                                           influence upon, 440-457; rise of Te-

337.                                                                                         cumseh, 445-452; Battle of Tippecanoe,

Thomas Wildcat Alford, 338.                                                    452-454; massacres, 456-457; death of

Monument to Leatherlips, 341.                                                  Tecumseh, 469; Indian menace ends,

Wright Group of Earthworks, 342.                                           469; what it cost, 469; demand recog-

Circular Enclosure, Wright works,                                           nition as a nation, 471; address on,

345.                                                                                         by Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance,

Stone Mound, Wright works, 346.                                             618-526; Indian  languages, 518-519;

Cremated Burial, Wright works, 348.                                       deterioration of the tribes, 520, phy-

Stone-covered Burial, Krumm mound,                                     sically, 520, 522; prevalence of tuber-

351.                                                                                          culosis, 521; the sun dance, 521; In-

Stone-covered Burial, exposed, Krumm                                   dian nomenclature, 521-522; dancing,

mound, 351.                                                                            and marriage customs, 522-523, 525-

The Smith works, 352.                                                               526; food, 522-523; the calendar, 523;

Human Parietal, with Arrow Wound,                                        tribal customs, 523, suffrage, 523;

McGuerer Burial Site, 354.                                                   amusements, races, etc., 524; early

Interior Aspect of Fig. 9, 355.                                                   rising, 524; honesty, 524; family life,

524; eloquence, 525; how history is

Human Vertebra, Pierced by Flint,

recorded, 525.

Arrow-point, 355.

Indian barrier-state, 470-471.

Court House and Jail at Marietta,

Ingalls, J. J., quoted, 221.

Ohio, 366.

Iroquois Indians, 285; 520.

Scene at the Ohio Penitentiary, Co-

lumbus, 404.

Jackson, Andrew, 185.

Ohio Penitentiary, 407.

Henry Clay, 460.                        Jefferson, Thomas, on committee on form

William  Henry Harrison, 460.                                                  of government of Western Territory,

George Rogers Clark Monument, 479.                                     117, 133; report of committee, 117-119;

Adam Willis Wagnalls, 501.                                                      a second report, 120-121; votes against

Mrs. Mabel Wagnalls Jones, 503.                                             slavery, 121, 133; his plan called im-

Wagnalls Memorial, Lithopolis, Ohio,                                      practical, 123; goes to France, 123;

505.                                                                                           129; 131; Benton ascribes authorship

Buffalo Child Long Lance, 517.                                                of Ordinance to him, 131, 136, 137,

Immigration, before and after 1812, 472.                                    142, 143; Governor Coles fails in his

attempt, 144-146; Senator Benton on

Indian Creek Farm, home of Felix

authorship, 146; Dane's alteration of

Renick, 10, 59; submerged in flood                                           Jefferson's proposal, 151, 155, 158, 169,

of 1913, 35.                                                                                173.

Indians: kill pioneers, 7; Chief Logan,                                         Jefferson, Fort, 237.

6, 8, 15, 80; defeated at Point Pleas                                          Jencks, Thomas A., makes "starting-

ant, 14; Felix Renick's contact with,                                          point of civil service reform," 186.

14-17; Logan's speech, 15; Renick's

Jenks, Leland H., "The John     Brown

map of Indian towns, 16-17; Indian

Myth," criticism of, 218-224.

fight, 17; picture of Indian life, 17-18;

Cornstalk and treaty at Camp Char-                                         "Joannasburg," 529.

lotte,  92;  St.  Clair's  expedition                                              "The John Brown Myth," by Leland

against, 237-273; depredations by, 276-                                   H. Jenks, criticized, 218-224.

280; Robert Elliot killed by, 278-279;                                        Johnson, Richard M., 468.

Iroquois, 285; Deerfield massacre, 285;                                  Johnson, Will, of The Short-Horn World,

Caughnawagas, 285-287; "Praying In-                                     speaks on   Ohio  Shorthorns, 64-65;

dians," 286; story of Eagle Feather,                                         extracts from address, 65.

292-293; Chief Long Lance speaks in                                     Johnson, William S., 123.

Columbus, 336, at Logan Elm, 336;                                          Johnson and Burdell, 406.

sketch of Thomas Wildcat Alford,                                           Jones, Mrs. Howard, originates Ohio

descendant of Tecumseh, 339-340; sale                                   History Day, 104; tribute to, 531.

• 8
 

Index                                    605

 

Jones, Dr. Howard, entertains party on                                     Li Hung Chang, 629.

Ohio History Day, 533.                                                      Lincoln, Abraham, John J. Ingall's esti-

Jones, Mrs. Mabel Wagnalls, 500-501.                                             mate of, 221.

Lithopolis, Ohio, 500; Letters to, 502;

Kansas, statues of men from, in Statuary                                          Wagnalls Memorial, 501-504.

Hall, Washington, 220-221.                                                Logan, James, Mingo Chief, 6, 8, 80;

Kean, John, 175.                                                                         text of his speech, 15.

Keck, Charles, sculptor, 497.                                                     Logan, John A., 187.

Keifer, General J. Warren, delivers ad-                                   Logan Elm, 15; seedling from, planted

dress at dedication of monument to                                           at State House, 80-86; poem on, by

George Rogers Clark, 498-499.                                                C. B. Galbreath, 105; Ohio History

Kelley, Alfred, 379.                                                                           Day observed at Logan Elm Park,

Kellogg, Joseph, captive among Indians,                                          104; Chief Long Lance speaks at, 336.

287.                                                                                     Logan Historical Society, 15-16.

Kelly, Edward S., 65.                                                                 Logston, Joe, noted frontiersman, 17.

Kennan, George, sketch of, 224-226; birth,                              Long Lance, Chief Buffalo Child, speaks

224; education, 224; life in Near East,                                     at Annual Meeting of Ohio State

224; in America, 224-225; investigates                                     Archaeological and Historical Society,

Russian exile system, 225; writer, lec-                                     336; introduced by Ex-Governor Camp-

turer and war correspondent, 225;                                           bell, 336; text of address, 518-526;

ejected         from  Russia, 225; reports                                    speaks on Ohio History Day at Lo-

eruption        of Mt. Pelee, visits Far                                          gan Elm    Park, 336, 516, 530-533; at

East, California, England, 225-226;                                          Columbus Chamber of Commerce, 516;

list of his works, 226; marriage, death,                                     at the Exchange Club, 516; excerpts

226.                                                                                            from  Watchman, concerning Ohio

Kenyon College, receives cattle  from                                            History Day, 531-532; from Circle-

English breeder, 41.                                                                  ville Union  Herald, 532-533; great

King, Rufus, on origin of Ordinance of                                            success  of meeting, 530-533; joins

1787, 111-112; 131; 133; 136.                                                   Prince of Wales' party in Canada,

Kooken, James, first Keeper at Ohio                                               526.

Penitentiary, 383; his character, 388.                                Louisiana purchase, 435.

Krumm, C. S., 350.                                                                     Loving cup, gift of Miss Helen Deshler

Krumm mound, exploration of, 350-352.                                         to Battleship Ohio, is transferred to

Kuntz, Mark, pioneer on the Tuscarawas,                                       Ohio  State Archaeological and His-

283.                                                                                            torical Society, 527.

Lowndes, William J., and the War of

Lafayette, Marquis de, compared with                                            1812, 459.

Robert Raikes, 306-307; McGuffey So-                           Ludlow, William, 373.

ciety of Columbus suggests centen-                                  Luskey, Henry, 414.

nial celebration of his visit to Ohio,

323-324.                                                                             McArthur, Ex-Governor Duncan, 28; let-

Land, Government, exempt from taxation,                                      ter to Felix Renick, 39-40; quoted, 378.

121.                                                                                     M'Coy, 406.

Lands, Military, suggested as reward for

officers and soldiers, 114-117.                                          McGrew, John B., 493.

"The Larger Patriotism," address by                                        McGuerer, Chauncey, 353.

Dean Edwin Chubb, 89.                                                    McGuerer Burial Site, 353-358; discovered,

Lathrop, Dr. H., 411.                                                                        353; explored, 353-358.

"Law in History," address by Dr. Ed-                                       McGuffey, William  H., excerpts from

ward P. Cheyney, 97-101.

reader of, on Robert Raikes, 306-

Lee, Richard Henry, sketch of, 172-174.

Legend of the White Woman, Mitch-             307; on North American Indians,

read on Ohio History Day, 532.

ener's, 290-299.

Leonard, Byram, 322, 389.                                                       McGuffey Society, adopts resolution con.

Leonard, Lewis A., Life of Alphonso                                                cerning Lafayette centenary, 323-324.

Taft," excerpts from, 321-323.                                          McKinley, William, 183.

• 9
 

606                                   Index

 

McLaughlin, Mrs. Martha, reimbursed,                                     Monroe, James, favors natural boun-

382-383.                                                                                      daries for states, 123; chairman of

McLene, Jeremiah, 388.                                                                     committee on, forming new states,

123.

Madison, President James, joins war                                         Monuments: to Felix Renick, 59-65; in

party, 462; annexes Spanish     West                                         honor of Lord Dunmore, and Colonel

Florida, 465; seeks further annex-                                             Robert Patterson, at Hockingport,

ation, 465; calls out militia, 465.                                                 Ohio, 87; to George Rogers Clark,

Maris, Dr. G. W., 411.                                                                       on site of Battle of Piqua, 492-499;

Maritime rights, disregard of, one cause                                           in honor of Jonathan Alder, 533-536.

of War of 1812, 471-472.                                                  Moore, Charles, 102.

Markham, Edwin, address at funeral of                                    Morrison, Dr. J., 411.

A. W. Wagnalls, 504-514.                                                 Morrow, Governor Jeremiah, 377.

Martin, Mrs. James, 535.                                                            Munro, Dana A., 102.

Massie, Colonel Nathaniel, his work as a                                  Myers, Allen O., on Civil Service Re-

pioneer, 19.                                                                                 form, 201.

Meckstroth, J. A., address at dedication                                    "The Mythical Exposition of a 'Myth',"

of James E. Campbell Elm, 84-85.                                             by C. B. Galbreath, 218-224.

Medbery, Nathaniel, first superintendent

of buildings at Ohio    Penitentiary,                                   National Intelligencer, 146.

380; first warden of the new    peni-                                 Nationalistic spirit, War of 1812 result

tentiary, 398.                                                                              of, 473; victorious, 474.

Meigs, Governor Return J., suggests a                                      Navarre, Peter, Day, celebrated, 86; pro-

state prison in Ohio, 371; 387.                                                   gram, 86; brief sketch, 86.

Mellott, M. H., 493.                                                                    New England, opposes War of 1812, 458;

Memorials, The Significance of, 477-491.                                       refuses to fight, 466; happy over end

Mendenhall, Dr. Thomas Corwin, death                                           of war, 471.

of, 215.                                                                               Noble, Henry C., 414.

Merriam, John M., quoted, 154.                                                North vs. South, in the making of the

Merwin, Mrs. James T., presides at ded-                                          Ordinance of 1787, 131.

ication of tablets at Fort Gower, 89.                                  Northwest Company, 444.

Metropotamia, 119.

Michigania, 119.                                                                        Obituaries:

Migration, 121.                                                                           Baker, Purley A., 216.

Miller, Aaron, Diary, 67-79; birth, 67;                                             Carpenter Frank G., 528-530.

family, 67-68; with six   companions                                Kennan, George, 224-226.

travels to Ohio; after prospecting for                                Mendenhall, Thomas C., 215.

a month, buys farm in Highland                                        Packard, Frank L., 106-108.

County, 76-77.                                                                           Scott, Austin, 329-330.

Miller, Daniel, 68.                                                                              Wagnalls, Adam W., 500-509; 515.

Miller, Jacob, 68.                                                                       Ohio, Battleship, silver service of, trans-

Miller, Jesse, 68.                                                                                ferred  from   Navy   Department to

Miller, Moses, 67.                                                                              Ohio State Archaeological and His-

Miller, Peter, 68.                                                                                torical Society, 527; also loving-cup,

Miller, Thurman, "Dusty," 68.                                                           bell and two flags, 527.

Miller, William H., 68.                                                               Ohio Company for the Importation of

"Millerites," 329.                                                                                English Cattle; organized, 28-29; sends

Milne, 65.                                                                                           buyers abroad, 30-40; purchases cat-

Missouri, John Brown's raid on, 222.                                                tle, 35, 40-41; holds sale, 49-51; closes

Mitchener, Charles H., "Historic Events                                           up affairs, 49; is praised, 52.

in the Tuscarawas and Muskingum                                    Ohio Daughters of the American Revo-

Valleys, etc., 290; sketch of, 290-291.                                      lution, unveil tablet at Fort Gower,

Mitchener's "Legend of the White Wom-                                        87-91.

an, and Newcomerstown," by George                              Ohio History Day, 104; great success of

F. Smythe, 283-300.                                                                   meeting this year, 530-533.

• 10
 

Index                                    607

 

Ohio, Scenic and Historic, by P. H. El-                                              Civil Service   Commission, 189-190;

wood and H. L. Hedrick, 324-325.                                            not renewed, 191; President Hayes

Ohio State Archaeological and Historical                                         friendly to movement, 191; quotations

Society, presents to Ohio memorial                                           from  messages, 191-193; no advance

tree, 80-86; accepts custodianship of                                        steps taken, 193; President James A.

Felix Renick monument, 62-63; gives                                        Garfield, attitude toward Civil Serv-

reception to American Historical As-                                       ice Reform, 193-194; attitude of Dem-

sociation, 101; gives smoker also, 101;                                      ocratic party, 194; the "spoils sys-

possesses copy of Winthrop Sargent's                                       tem," 195-197; quotation   from  San

Journal, 273; hears address by Indian                                       Francisco Call, 195; George H. Pen-

Chief, 336; explores Wright group of                                       dleton espouses the cause, 196; quo-

pre-historic earthworks, 341-358; re-                                       tations from   speeches, 196-198; Na-

ceives silver service, flags and bell                                          tional Civil Service Reform     Asso-

from  Battleship Ohio, 527.                                                        ciation, 198; Pendleton chief influence

Ohio, State of, importance of, as breeder                                         in enacting law, 198; a word as to

of Shorthorns, 65; Webster's eulogy                                         "practical             politicians,"  199;                    law

of, precipitates Webster-Hayne    de-                                      passed  and          approved, January                 16,

bate, 134; vs. Abigail Church, defend-                                     1883; 199; courage of Pendleton, 199;

ant, 206-214.                                                                              contest for re-nomination, 200; let-

Ohio State University, holds silver jubi-                                           ter of ex-Senator Allen G. Thurman,

lee dinner in honor of President W.                                           200-201; Pendleton defeated by Payne,

O. Thompson, 313-317.                                                               202; election of Cleveland, 202; his

Ohio University Girls' Glee Club, 88-89.                                          debt to Pendleton, 202; appoints Pen-

Ohio-Virginia boundary, lawyer in case,                                         dleton  minister  to  Germany, 203;

205.                                                                                             death of Pendleton, 203; family, 203;

"Ohio's Contribution to National Civil                                               characteristics of "Gentleman George,"

Service Reform," 176-204; the great-                                      203-204; the law his monument, 204.

ness of Ohio, 176; statesmen vs. pol-                                        "Ohio's only Witchcraft Case," by Albert

iticans, 176-178; ancestry of George                                        Douglas, 205-214.

H. Pendleton, 178; birth, 179; edu-     One hundred and forty-seventh Regiment,

cation, pupil of W. H. McGuffey,                                                                         O. N. G., at dedication    of Clark

179; travels, 179; becomes Democrat,                                      Monument, 492.

179; his independence, 180; state sen-                                      Orders in Council, failure to withdraw,

ator, 180; in Congress, 180; runs for                                         one cause of War of 1812, 464; con-

Vice-president, 180-181; defeated, also                                   cessions of Great Britain, 463-464.

for Congress, 181-182; advocate of pay-                                 Ordinance of 1784, 121, 123.

ment in greenbacks, 182; candidate                                          "The Ordinance of 1787, its Origin and

for governor of Ohio, 182; defeated                                         Authorship,"  111-175; its great im-

by  R. B. Hayes, 182; Pendleton-                                              portance, 111; its origin, 111-112; rival

Garfield  Debate, 183; compared   to                                       claims to authorship, 111-112, 128-170;

McKinley - Campbell Debate, 183;                                          proposal to reward soldiers with land,

elected to United States Senate, 183;                                        112; a new state proposed, 112; Tim-

the spoils system, 184; death of Presi-                                       othy Pickering's plan for allotment

dent Garfield, 184-185; civil service re-                                  of military lands, 114-117; committee

form initiated, 185-188; sketch of civil                                     of Continental Congress, reports, 117-

service reform, 185-202; Civil War                                          121; second report, 119; provisions,

crowds out, 186; bills introduced by                                         121; ordinance of 1784 in force for

Charles Sumner and Thomas Allen                                           three years, 121; Monroe's ideas, 123;

Jencks, 186; endorsed by George W.                                       Congressman William   Grayson's sug-

Curtis and Carl Schurz, 186; by Presi-                                       gestions, 123; new committee reports

dent U. S. Grant, 187; first president                                         on government of Western Territory,

to recommend Congressional action on                                     124-128; text of first Ordinance, 125-

civil service reform, 187; quotations                                         128; compared with later one, 128-129;

from  annual messages, 187-190; from                                      W. F. Poole's opinion as to author-

second inaugural, 189; disappointed                                         ship, 129; the question one of national

in Congress, 190; Congress authorizes                                       interest, 129; Webster's speech  on

• 11
 

608                                   Index

 

"The Ordinance of 1787" -- Concluded.                                    Pew, Professor William H., address on

Foot resolution, 129-130; Senator Ben-                                     Felix Renick, and the Ohio Company

ton replies to Webster, 130-132; as-                                          for the Importation of Cattle from

cribes authorship of Ordinance to                                             England, 64.

Jefferson, 131; Webster's reply    to   Phelps, William  Lyon, tribute to John

Hayne, 132-134; references of Web-                                       Singer Sargent, 320.

ster to   Ohio  precipitate  Webster-                                   Phillips, Wendell, 311.

Hayne debate, 134; Hayne throws                                    Pickering, Timothy, drafts form  of gov-

down   gauntlet, 134-135; letter from                                         ernment for proposed state, 112; plan

Dane, 136-137; notes on the Ordinance,                                   for allotment of military lands, 114-

137-143; Governor Coles on its author-                                     117.

ship, 144-146; Senator Benton    sup-                                Pinckney, Charles, 123.

ports Jefferson's claim, 146-147; Peter Piqua, Battle of, 484-488, 492.

Force on the Ordinance, 147, 148-149;                             Pirates, Felix Renick's ancestors' expe-

Poole's opinion, 147-153; new   light,                                        rience with, 4.

147; the two ordinances compared,                                   Pittsburgh, Winthrop Sargent at, 276.

148-149; a new claimant, 150-170; Dr.                             Plumb, Professor Charles S., sketch of,

B. A. Hinsdale supports him, 154-155;                                      108; article on "Felix Renick, Pio-

the claims of Cutler, 158-162; the ar-                                       neer," 3-66.

gument for Nathan Dane as chief                                     Point Pleasant, 91.

author, 158-170; sketches of Nathan                                 Polypotamia, 119.

Dane, 170-172, R. H. Lee, 172-174,                                Pomerene, Senator Atlee, 187.

Melancton   Smith, 174-175, Edward                               Poole, William  F., 125, 128, 129.

Carrington, 175, John Kean, 175.                                     Powder horns, made of Gough and Miller

Otstot, Sherman, 493.                                                                         horns, 25-26.

Powell, Colonel John H., decides Felix

Packard, Frank L., sketch of life, 106-                                             Renick to buy Shorthorns only, 30-31.

108; death of, 107; tribute to, 107.                                     "Praying Indians," 286.

Paley, W. F., 31.                                                                        Prince, Dr. B. F., address at dedication

"Paragon of the West," 49.                                                                of monument to George Rogers Clark,

Parker, Theodore, 218, 219.                                                              494-495.

Parsons, Samuel, 361.                                                                Proctor, Colonel Henry A., 468.

Patriotic Societies, Conference of, 101;                                   "Prophet, The" (Ellskwatawa), 445-449;

address on "What patriotic societies                                         452-453.

can do to aid the organization of                                    Prorok, Count Byron Khun de, lectures

work in Ohio history," 101.                                                     in Columbus, 334; shows pictures of

Patterson, John, donates tablet, 89.                                                 excavations at Carthage, 334; visits

Patterson, John, 405.                                                                         State Archaeological Museum, 334.

Putnam, General Israel, 6.

Patterson,  Colonel Robert, tablet in

honor of, 87.                                                                      Raikes, Robert, compared to Lafayette,

Patterson, W. D., 414.                                                                       306-307.

Patton, Matthew, takes first improved                                      "Recent Political Development: Progress

cattle west of Alleghanies, 22.                                                  or Change?" address by Dr. H. A.

Patton, Michael, 373.                                                                         Garfield, 96.

Patton cattle, history of, 24-25; bought                                     Renick, Felix, character sketch of, 3-65;

by Felix Renick, 26.                                                                   Irish ancestry, 3; birth, 4; removal

Payne, Henry B., 200; 201.                                                               to      Ohio, 5; adventures, 6-9; buys

Pelisipia, 119.                                                                                    farm, 9-10; visits Tennessee, 10; travels

Pendleton, Mrs. Alice    Key, wife    of                                           West, 10-13; description  of prairie,

George   H. Pendleton, 203; tragic                                          12-13; enters land in Missouri, 13;

death, 203.                                                                                 visits New Orleans, 13-14; his knowl-

Pendleton, George H., his contribution                                            edge of Indians, 14; Point Pleasant,

to national civil service reform, 176-                                       Battle of, 14; Logan's speech, 14-15;

204; life and work, 176-204.                                                    Logan        Elm, 15; first president of

Peter Navarre Day, celebration of, 86.                                           Logan        historical society, 15-16; his

• 12
 

Index                                   609

 

versatility, 16; "map of Indian towns,"                               Renick family, debt of Scioto Valley to,

16; describes Slover's escape from                                           19.

the Indians, 17; writes for American                                 Renicks, J. O. B., 407.

Pioneer, 17-18; wins national repu-                                  Reviews, Notes and Comments, by the

tation as cattle-breeder, 19; founding                                       Editor, Meeting of American     His-

of Chillicothe, 1796, 19; drives fat                                            torical Association, 95-103; Ohio His-

cattle to eastern market, 21; first im-                                        tory Day at the Logan Elm, 104-

portation of cattle into America, 21-                                         105; Frank L. Packard, 106-108; Pro-

22; Shorthorns, 21-22; 27; Gough and                                       fessor Charles S. Plumb, 108; Dr.

Miller cattle, 22-25; Patton  cattle,                                            Thomas C. Mendenhall, 215; Rev.

22-26; Renick breeds Patton cattle,                                           Purley A. Baker, 216; A Late Esti-

26-27; "Ohio Company for Importing                                        mate of John Brown, 217-218; Myth-

English Cattle," organized, 28-29; ob-                                       ical Exposition of a Myth, 218-224;

ject, 30; Henry Clay's interest in it,                                           George Kennan, 224-226; Sargent Gen-

30; Renick inspects cattle in Phila-                                            ealogy, 318-321; Sidelights on the Last

delphia and  Baltimore, 30; Renick                                           Days of General U. S. Grant, 321-

goes to   England, 30-40; purchases                                          323; Celebration of Centenary of La-

nineteen head of Shorthorns, 35; bill                                         fayette's Visit to America, 323-324;

of sale of same, 35-36; reasons for                                           Scenic and   Historic  Ohio, 324-325;

buying only Shorthorns, 36-39; letter                                        The Mythology of All Races-Latin

to Renick from Governor McArthur,                                        America, 325-328; Josh Billings once

39-40; Renick corresponds with Mr.                                         lived in Norwalk, Ohio, 328-329; Dr.

Whitaker, 40-41; buys more cattle,                                          Austin Scott, 329-330; Silver Service

40-41; holds sale, 43-50; sale-catalogue,                                  of the Battleship Ohio, 527; Frank G.

42-48; Ohio Company closes up af-                                          Carpenter, 528-530; Ohio History Day

fairs, 49; holds sale, 49-51; anecdote                                        at Logan Elm Park, 530-533; Honors

of Lyne Starling, 51-52; Ohio Com-                                          to the Memory of Jonathan Alder,

praised, 52; James St. Clair eulogizes                                        533-536; Logan the Mingo, 536-537.

Renick,  54; Coates' "Herdbook,"                                      Reynolds, J. S., 39.

54; first Herdbook ever published,                                    Ridgway, Joseph, Jr., 380.

55;  Renick's  ill-health,  55; inde-                                      Robinson William, 6.

pendence of Bates, 55-56; Renick

Rockville, Ohio, suggested as site for

retires from  importing business, 56;      State penitentiary, 379.

his family, his school-house, 57; home

"Rose of Sharon," 33, 34, 36, 49.

life, 57; tragic death, 57; tribute to,

57-65; burial place, 58; meeting of      Rosenberger, W. C., 65.

Ross, Colonel Simon, 493.

Ohio Shorthorn Breeder's Association,

58-65; monument, 59-62; dedicated, 62-

65; address by C. B. Galbreath, 63-64    St. Clair, Governor Arthur, Winthrop

address by Will Johnson, extracts         Sargent's connection with, 319; diary

of St. Clair's Expedition, by W. Sar-

from, 64-65; Ohio's importance as a

breeder of Shorthorns, 65; debt to       gent, 237-273; appointment, 361; chooses

laws for Northwest Territory, 365-

Edward S. Kelly, 65; bibliography,

65-66.                                                                                          367; criminal laws promulgated, 367.

Renick, George, settles in Scioto Valley,                                   "St. Clair's campaign, 1791," in Winthrop

8; takes first drove of fat cattle to                                              Sargent's Diary, 237-273.

eastern market, 20-21; 29.                                                  Sanders, Colonel Lewis, imports Short-

Renick, Jonathan, settles at Chillicothe,                                              horns from England, 27.

8-9; 10.                                                                                 Saratoga, 119.

Renick, Josiah, associate of Felix  on                                         Sargent, Charles Sprague, "Winthrop

first European trip, 32, 35, 40.                                             Sargent," 229-236; 318; most eminent

first European trip, 32, 35, 40.                                                    living dendrologist, 320-321.

Renick, Thomas, 9.                                                                      Sargent, Epes, 318.

Renick, William, western journey of, 10-                                  Sargent, John Singer, tribute to, 320.

13; its discomforts, 12-13; enters land                                Sargent, Paul D., 321.

in Missouri, 13; memoirs, 20, 21, 26.                                  Sargent, Winthrop, IV, 319.

Vol. XXXIII -- *39.

• 13
 

610                                     Index

 

Sargent Winthrop, VII, Diary while                                             Silver service of the Battleship Ohio,

with  General McArthur St. Clair's                                            transferred from Navy Department of

expedition against the Indians, 237-                                          the  United   States to   Ohio   State

273, extracts  from, 273-282; visits                                            Archaeological and Historical Society,

Washington, 273; describes Mt. Ver-                                        527.

non, family life, etc., 273-275; visits                                     Sioux Indians, language of, 519; 520.

Philadelphia, 275-276; visits Pittsburgh,                                Skeletal remains, found in Ohio, 354-358.

276; Ohio, 276; describes Indian hos-                                   Slavery, in Ordinance of 1787, 121; 130;

tilities, 277-279; visits Cincinnati, 279-                                      133-134; a Northern, not a Southern

280; tries horticultural experiments,                                          measure, 133; 134-135; Dane on slavery

280-281; complimented, 321.                                                     in Ordinance, 136-137; Thomas Jeffer-

Sargent Genealogy, review of, 318-321.                                          son opposes, 155; Rufus King strength-

Sater, Lowry F., tribute to  President                                                 ens the measure, 155; Congress passes

William O. Thompson, 315-317.                                                it, 155.

Schlesinger, Professor A. M., 102.                                               Slover, John, Indian captive, 17.

Schurz, Carl, 186.                                                                          Smith, Gerrit, 218.

Scioto Valley, first place in Ohio to pro-                                      Smith, Melancton, 123, 174-175.

duce fat cattle, 19.                                                                 Smith group, 352-353.

Scott, Dr. Austin, sketch of, 329-330.                                           Smythe, George F., "Mitchener's 'Legend

Seamen, impressment of, one cause of                                             of the White Woman, and Newcom-

War of 1812, 433, 452, 454, 461-462,                                      erstown'," 283-300.

464.                                                                                         Solitary confinement urged in Ohio Pen-

See, Frederick, 7.                                                                                itentiary, 378.

See, Hannah, wife of Felix Renick, 56, 58.                                  South: Did it originate the Ordinance

Seminole Indians, 451.                                                                       of 1787? 146-147.

Shaw, Henry Wheeler 328-329; lived in                                      Spelling, reformed, fostered by Thomas

Ohio, 328; sketch of, 328-329; his                                             S. Grimke, 309.

pranks, 329.                                                                            Stadden, Richard, 407-408; 410.

Shawnee, Oklahoma, 340.                                                            Starling, Lyne, anecdote of, 51-52.

Shawnee Mission School, 339.                                                      Stephen, General Adam, 93.

Sheets, Honorable George, address on                                        Stevens, Mrs. Helen F., 88.

Peter Navarre, 86.                                                                 Stockholders, names of, in Ohio Com-

Sherman, W. J., 86.                                                                            pany for Importing English Cattle,

Shetrone, H. C., "Exploration      of the                                             28-29.

Wright Group of Pre-historic Earth-                                    Stone, Frederick D., disagrees with Dr.

works," 341-358.                                                                        Poole and others, as to authorship

Shook, C. B., 532.                                                                               of Ordinance of 1787, 158-160.

Shorthorn cattle, sketch of their intro-                                          Sumner, Charles, introduces civil service

duction into Ohio, 22-23; Felix Ren-                                         reform  bill, 186.

ick's reasons for purchasing, 36-39.                                     Sylvania, 119.

"Sidelights on the Last Days of General

U. S. Grant," 321-323.                                                           Taft, Alphonso, Life of, by L. A. Leon-

Siebert, Professor Wilbur H., 102.                                                    ard, 321-323; his relation to General

"Significance of Memorials," history of                                            Grant, 321-322.

memorials, 478-481; introduction to                                     Tallmadge, Frank, 82; appreciation of, 85.

sketch of George Rogers Clark, 481-                                   Tanner, Judge John R., 534.

483, birth, training, 483-484, seeks to                                   Taylor, John L., Secretary of the Ohio

settle  Indian  controversies, 484-485,                                      Company for Importing English Cat-

recaptures Vincennes, 485; Battle of                                        tle, 28.

Piqua, 485, 487; physical conditions                                     Tecumseh, sketch of descendant of, 339-

in Clark's day--difficulties of travel,                                         340, 497; Tecumseh and the Confed-

etc., 486-487; our debt to Clark, 488-                                       eracy, 445; Battle of Tippecanoe, 452-

491.                                                                                             454; joins British Army, 453; death,

Silver Jubilee dinner for Dr. W. O.                                                  469; end of Indian menace, 469; birth-

Thompson, 313-317.                                                                  place, 492.

• 14
 

Index                                    611

 

Tennessee militia, called to defend "lower                                       Washington, General George, visited by

country," 465.                                                                             Winthrop Sargent, VII, 273-275.

Thames, Battle of the, 468, 470.                                                        Washington, Mrs. Martha, 275.

Thomas, Griffith, 383; elected state agent,                                       Washington, (State), 119.

386.                                                                                             Washington County, first courthouse and

Thompson, Benjamin, 373.                                                                jail in, 365.

Thompson, Dr. J. B., 411.                                                                  Washington, Fort, 238.

Thompson, Dr. T., 411.                                                                      Webster, Daniel, 111, 112; speech on the

Thompson, Dr. William O., honored, 313;                                                    Ordinance of 1787 and its authorship,

silver jubilee dinner, 313; addresses                                         129-130, 132-134; eulogy of Ohio pre-

by Judge McCann, 313, Dean White,                                       cipitates Webster-Hayne Debate, 134;

313-314, G. G. Atkins, 314, ex-Gover-                                    Hayne replies, Webster throws down

nor James E. Campbell, President                                             the gauntlet, 134-135; debate arouses

Henry C. King, Dr. F. P. Graves,                                              much discussion, 143-144; 146; Web-

Mr. Lowry F. Sater, 314-317; "Sig-                                          ster reads Cutler's journal, 157; Rufus

nificance of Memorials," 477-491; 499.                                   King   corroborates  Webster's  opin-

ion as to authorship, 165; quotation

Thompson, Mrs. William O., presented                                                        from  Webster 169; 323.

with wrist-watch, 315.             Weld, Miss Emmaline Rathbone, mar-

Thoreau, Henry D., 218.

ries George Kennan, 226.

Thurman, ex-Senator Allen G., on Sen-                                           West, W. S., 60.

atorial nomination, 1884, 200-201.                              West, The, influence of, on national pol-

Thurston, Honorable George Rogers Bal-

icy, 427-428; development of public

lard, 494.                                                                                              opinion in, 429; character of, 429;

Torrey, Dr. Joseph, 157.                                                                   patriotism  of, 429-430; nationalistic

Townsend, Miss Helen M., 88.                                                    spirit of, 430-431; industrial independ-

"Trees, What they teach us," rhymes,                                                          ence of, 433; need of more settlers

recited at dedication of James E.                                              and land, 434-435; pleased with Louisi-

Campbell Elm, 81; "Trees," poem by                                                    ana purchase, 435; feeling against In-

Joyce Kilmer, 81; "Planting Song,"                                                        dians, 435-436; Harrison's land pur-

80, 82.                                                                                                     chases, 440-441; division of Indiana

Trevitt, Dr., 411.                                                                                Territory, 442; Harrison's land pol-

Tribute to Green Lawn      Cemetery, by                                          icy, 442; activity of politics, 443; in-

C. B. Galbreath, 301.                                                                 creasing Indian menace, 443-445; in-

Trimble, Governor Allen, 28, 377.                                                    fluence of Tecumseh and the "Proph-

Tuberculosis, prevalence of, among North                                                  et," 445; alarm  over Harrison's atti-

American Indians, 521.                                                             tude, 450; purchase of land, 447; war

inevitable, 447; Western Confederacy,

United States Daughters of 1812, dedi-                                            448-449; West alarmed, 450; asks aid,

cate Peter Navarre Memorial, 86.                                            451; Battle of Tippecanoe, 453; West

would conquer Canada, 455; Indian

Vance, Gov. Joseph, 412.                                                                  massacres, 456; West demands right

Varnum, James M., 361.                                                                    to protect homes, 456; supports Pres-

Villard, Oswald Garrison, 217.                                                                      ident in declaring war, 458; Clay,

Vinton, Samuel F., sketch of, 205; argu-                                           western leader in Congress, 459; his

ment in case of State of Ohio vs.                                               powerful influence, 459; his support-

Abigail Church, 208.                                                                  ers, 459; their youth and vigor, 464;

British minister fails to understand,

Wagnalls, Adam Willis, funeral of, 500-                                          463; frontiersmen enthusiastic for war,

514; address by Edwin Markham, 504-                                     466; the physical difficulties in their

514; sketch of life, 506-509; 515.                                              way, 467; choose Harrison leader,

Wagnalls Memorial, 501-504.                                                           467; Battle of River Raisin, 468; Te-

Walters, Barton, 105.                                                                         cumseh's death settles Western land

"War of 1812, Western Opinion and the,"                                        problem, 469; Indian barrier-state the

462.                                                                                             fundamental issue, 470-472; victories

Ward, Durbin, 200.                                                                            of the West, 472.

• 15
 

612                                   Index

 

West, The -- Concluded.                                                                    449; he visits the Southern Indians,

"Western Opinion and the War of 1812,"                                      449-450; the West alarmed, 450; asks

427-474; influence of the back country                                     protection, 450; British intrigue active

on national policy, 427-428; Congres-                                       in Canada and the South, 451; the

sional influence, 428; causes of the     West appeals to President for aid,

War, 428; development of Western    451; Harrison ordered to protect the

opinion, 429; character of frontiers-   West, 455; he expects no fighting, 452;

men, 429; their patriotism, 429-430;    Battle of Tippecanoe, 452-453; U. S.

their nationalism, 430-431; quotation   maritime   interests, 452; Tecumseh

from  Clay, 431; strength of Great       joins the British, 453; Battle of Tip-

Britain, 432; danger of internal col-    pecanoe attributed to British influence,

lapse in America, 432; industrial in-    453; proofs, 454; Governor Meigs ad-

dependence of the West, 433; Clay     vises preparedness, 454; Niles Register

opposes war, 434; causes of change   quoted 455; West looks covetously

in public sentiment, 434-435; need for                                      upon Canada, 455; and would punish

more settlers, therefore for more land,                                     Great Britain, 455; Indian uprisings,

434-435; the Indians must go, 435-436;                                     456; whites organize, 456-457; Con-

demands for extinction of Indian land                                      gressional war-hawks, 457-465; British

titles, 436; government authorizes land                                     fan the flames, 457; the Twelfth Con-

purchases from  Indians, 436; Jeffer-                                       gress and war spirit, 458-465; activity

son and the Indians, 436; conditions    of Henry Clay, 459-464; war imminent,

in the South, 436; evil influence of      461; Congressional debates, 461-465;

close contact between whites and In-                                       army bills passed, 461; naval appro-

dians, 437; bad effects of liquor, 438;                                       priations defeated, 461; influence of

Indians threatened   with                     starvation,                     young    war-hawks,  462;   Madison's

438; impossible for them                      to obtain                                   weakness, 462; real reasons for de-

justice, 438; their dependence on the                                       claring war, 462-465; Great Britain

fur trade, 439; Indian hostility not                                             averse to war, 463; secret debates,

entirely caused by the British, 439;     463; Madison annexes Spanish West

rise of Tecumseh, 440; influence of                                         Florida, 465; SoutherN enthusiasm,

Tecumseh and the Prophet, 440; Har-                                                 466; eastern   opposition, 466; Ken-

rison's land purchases, 440-441; Burr's                                               tucky's preparations, 467; Harrison

conspiracy, Indiana fight on slavery,                                       chosen leader, 467; Battle of River

contributing causes, 441; division of                                         Raisin, 468; indifference of the East,

Indiana  Territory, 442; Harrison's    468; part played by Kentucky, 468;

pro-slavery party, 442; Harrison pro-                                                 death of Tecumseh marks close of an

motes an aggressive land policy, 442;                                                 era, 469; cost of expelling the Brit-

politics active in Indiana Territory,                                          ish, 469; price paid for Indian lands,

443; increasing danger from Indians, 469; Treaty of Ghent, its results, 470-

443; evil influence of traders, 443-444;                                    473; puts war in its true light, 471;

influence of Canada, 444; Northwest                                                  quotation from   Henry Clay, 470-471;

Company, 444; false alarms, 444-445;                                                 Indian  barrier-state, 470-472; sum-

Tippecanoe town    founded, 445; in-                                                  mary, 472-474; bibliography, 475-476.

fluence of "The Prophet," 445; Har-  Western Confederacy, 432, 445, 449-450,

rison's letter to Secretary of War,      453.

445; uneasiness among Indians, 446;  Western Territory, government of, 117-

anti-British feeling rising, 446; 1809   121.

an  important year, 446; Harrison's    "What the Trees teach us," 81.

attitude excites alarm, 450; official    Wheat lands, Diary of Aaron Miller,

permission  to purchase more land,     while in quest of, 66-79.

447; three million acres of land ceded                                      Whipping, a common punishment in early

to United States, 447; war inevitable,  days, 370; in use to 1812, 370.

447; Tecumseh threatens, 447-448; he                                     Whitaker, Jonas, 32; letter to Felix Ren-

and   Harrison  clash, 448; Prophet      ick, 55.

plans Confederacy, 448; Tecumseh   White, John, 93.

appears with four hundred warriors,  White, William, 93.

• 16
 

Index                                    613

 

White race, evil influence of, upon In-                                         Wood, Dr., 223.

dian, 437-438.                                                                         Worthington, Governor Thomas, 375.

"Whitehall Sultan," 65.                                                                   Wright, Barzillai, 388-389

Whitaker, Dr. H. O., 353-354.

Williams, M. T., 379.                                                                      Wright, Dr. M. S., 400.

Willis, Senator F. B., 187, 499, 527.                                               Wright, Samuel M., 341, 349, 350.

Wilson, Archibald, 93.                                                                   Wright Group of Pre-historic  Earth-

Wilson, Colonel Benjamin, 93.                                                          works, Exploration of, 341-358; loca-

Wilson, Hill Peebles, John Brown, Sol-                                             tion, 341; first notice of, 342-344; de-

dier of Fortune, 217.                                                                  scription of, 342-344; exploration of,

Wilson, John, 93.                                                                                344-350; Bureau of Ethnology survey

Wilson, Mrs. William M., address at                                                 at fault, 348-349; valuable discoveries,

dedication of tablet at Fort Gower,                                           349-350; the Krumm mound, 350-352;

89.                                                                                               Smith group, 352-353; McGuerer burial

Wilson, Woodrow, 102.                                                                     site, accidental discovery  of, 353;

Wing, John, 349.                                                                                many skeletal remains, 354-358.

"Witchcraft, Ohio's only case," by Albert

Douglas, 205-214.

Wittke, Professor Carl, address to the

Patriotic  Societies, on  "What the

Patriotic Societies can do to aid the                                       Zane's Trace, 6.

Organization of Work in Ohio His-                                       Zanesville, 6; suggested as site for State

tory," 101.                                                                                   Penitentiary, 379.

• 17