NOTES
131
Tod Lum, August 4, 28, 1961; Henry
Spencer, August 28, 1961; and Mrs. William A.
Starin, July 27, 1961.
45. Personal interview with Tod Lum,
August 4, 1961.
46. Personal interview with Mrs. William
A. Starin, July 27, 1961.
47. Charles R. Brown, They Were
Giants (New York, 1934), 211.
48. Personal interview with Mrs. William
A. Starin, July 27, 1961.
49. "Washington Gladden," The
Outlook, CVI (1914), 161.
50. Brown, They Were Giants, 214.
51. Gladden, Recollections, 292.
52. Ibid., 337.
53. Ohio State Journal (Columbus),
February 14, 1900.
54. As in the popular sermon-lecture
series, "Columbus and Other Cities," delivered
in 1890, 1897, and 1898.
55. Gladden, Recollections, 329,
330.
56. Ibid., 333-334.
57. Ohio State Journal, March 17,
1884.
58. Ibid., April 2, 1892.
59. Columbus City Directory, 1901.
60. Gladden, Recollections, 341.
61. Ohio State Journal, August 3,
1900.
62. Ibid., February 5, 1901.
63. Ibid., March-April 1901.
64. Ibid., April 27, 1901.
65. Gladden, Recollections, 345.
66. Ibid., 351.
67. The Ohio Blue Book (Toledo,
1917), 138.
68. Personal interview with Mrs. F. C.
Caldwell, September 5, 1961.
69. Personal interview with William E.
Henderson, August 25, 1961.
70. Atkins, "Gladden and
After," 600.
71. "Washington Gladden," The
Outlook, CVI (1914), 160-161.
JANNEY'S
RECOLLECTIONS OF THOMAS CORWIN
1. The "Recollections of Thomas
Corwin" appears in a 164-page journal in which
Janney, an inveterate amateur essayist,
recorded, presumably for more permanent
keeping, some of his memories of
persons, places, and things. It was recently presented
to the library of the University of
California, Berkeley, by a granddaughter, Mrs.
Thomas Brown of Berkeley. A rough draft
of the "Recollections of Thomas Corwin"
is in the Janney Papers at the Ohio
Historical Society. The draft is written on scraps
of paper, some carrying complete dates,
the latest of which is January 1, 1902. Janney
was then nearly ninety years old.
2. Homer C. Hockett, "Thomas
Corwin," in Dictionary of American Biography, IV,
456-458.
3. The brief biography of Janney to
follow is taken from three sources: an auto-
biographical note in the back of his
twenty-one page history of The State Bank of
Ohio (Cleveland, 1885), an obituary in the Columbus
Dispatch, December 11, 1907, and
the aforementioned journal.
4. The date of Janney's arrival in Ohio
is given as 1833 in the autobiographical
note in his State Bank of Ohio and
in the obituary in the Columbus Dispatch. In the
opening sentence of the
"Recollections of Thomas Corwin," however, he says he came
to Ohio in 1831. Elsewhere in the
journal he also speaks of coming to Ohio in 1831.
5. John Jay Janney, "Banks and
Banking," in Alfred E. Lee, History of the City of
Columbus (New York, 1892), I, 410.
EARLY OHIO
PAINTERS
1. Ebenezer S. Thomas, Reminiscences
of the Last Sixty-Five Years, Commencing
with the Battle of Lexington (Hartford, 1840), II, 208.
2. Frances Trollope, Domestic Manners
of the Americans, edited by Donald Smalley
(New York, 1949), 326.
3. Harriet Martineau, Retrospect of
Western Travel (London, 1838) II, 48.
4. Henry T. Tuckerman, Book of the
Artists (New York, 1867), 437.
5. Thomas, Reminiscences, 207;
Charles T. Webber, "Pioneer Art in Cincinnati," in
Henry Howe, Historical Collections of
Ohio (Norwalk, Ohio, 1896), I, 856.