TWELFTH ANNUAL REPORT
OF THE
OHIO STATE
ARCHAEOLOGICAL AND HISTORICAL
SOCIETY
FOR THE YEAR
FEBRUARY 18, 1896 TO FEBRUARY 1,
1897.
GEN. R. BRINKERHOFF, President.
E. 0. RANDALL, Secretary.
COLUMBUS, O., JANUARY, 1897.
(291)
|
(292) |
To His Excellency, Asa S. Bushnell,
Governor of Ohio:
SIR:-I
have the honor to submit herewith the twelfth annual
report of the Ohio State Archaeological
and Historical Society,
covering the year from February 19,
1896, to February 1, 1897.
This report, while complete as to the
more important pro-
ceedings of the Society, is made as
concise as possible, and for the
greater convenience of the reader, the
chief items of interest are
arranged topically. For the benefit of
those not heretofore famil-
iar with the Society, a brief statement
of its history and objects
follows the regular report.
With very great respect, I remain,
Yours truly,
E. O. RANDALL, Secretary.
(293)
OFFICERS
FROM FEBRUARY 18, 1896 TO FEBRUARY 1,
1897.
GEN. R.
BRINKERHOFF, .. .
President
REV. WM. E. MOORE, D. D., LL. D.,
. . . Vice
President
HON. S. S. RICKLY, . . .. Treasurer
EDWIN F. WOOD, . .. Assistant Treasurer
E. O. RANDALL, PH. B., LL. M., .
. . . Secretary
PROF. WARREN K. MOOREHEAD, . Curator
TRUSTEES ELECTED BY THE SOCIETY.
TERM EXPIRES IN 1897.
HON. CALVIN S. BRICE, ... Lima
HON. ELROY M. AVERY, . . ..
Cleveland
BISHOP B. W. ARNETT, . . . . . Wilberforce
HON. S. S. RICKLY, . . Columbus
MR. G. F. BAREIS, .. Canal
Winchester
TERM EXPIRES IN 1898.
GEN. R. BRINKERHOFF, . . ..
Mansfield
HON. M. D. FOLLETT, .. Marietta
HON. D. J. RYAN, .
. . . .
. . Columbus
REV. H. A. THOMPSON, ..
Dayton
MR. R. E. HILLS,
. . ..
Delaware
TERM EXPIRES IN 1899.
HON. JOHN SHERMAN, .. Mansfield
PROF. G. F. WRIGHT, . . .. Oberlin
REV. WM. E. MOORE, .. Columbus
HON. JOHN B. PEASLEE, .. Cincinnati
MR. A. H. SMYTHE, .. Columbus
APPOINTED BY THE GOVERNOR.
HON. CHARLES P. GRIFFIN, Toledo, 1897; HON. A. ROBE-
SON, Greenville, 1897; *HON. W. J. GILMORE, Columbus,
1898;
HON. ISRAEL WILLIAMS, Hamilton, 1898; HON. ALEXANDER
BOXWELL, Red Lion, 1899; HON. E. O. RANDALL, Colum-
bus, 1899.
*Deceased August 9, 1896.
(294)
TWELFTH ANNUAL MEETING.
For important reasons it was found
necessary to postpone
the eleventh annual meeting of the
Society from the date then
provided in the Constitution, viz. the
third Tuesday in February
until February 27 (1896). On that day
the twelfth meeting
(eleventh annual) of the Society
convened in the Library Room
of the State Capitol, Columbus, Ohio, at
2 P. M., with General
R. Brinkerhoff, the President, in the
chair, and Mr. E. O. Randall
Secretary. The following members were
present:
George F. Bareis, Canal Winchester; A.
R. McIntire. Mt.
Vernon; J. H. Todd, Wooster; F. O. Hart,
West Unity; J. L.
Oldham, Reynoldsburg; Israel Williams,
Hamilton; R. E. Hills,
Cyrus Platt, Delaware; M. D. Follett, Marietta;
B. W. Ar-
nett, Wilberforce; J. C. Reeve, H. A.
Thompson, Dayton; W.
K. Moorehead, L. C. Herrick, W. H.
Jennings, D. H. Gard, J.
H. Anderson, George B. Wright, William
E. Moore, John J.
Janney, E. O. Randall, Benigna G. Kalb,
Edwin F. Wood, A. H.
Smythe, Frank Howe, Rutherford Hayes,
Charles Parrott, Harry
P. Ward and James Kilbourne, Columbus.
The minutes of the last (tenth) annual
meeting (February 19,
1895) of the Society were read and
approved. The concise re-
port of the Executive Committee to the
Governor of the State,
which had been prepared by the
Secretary, was presented as the
report of the Excutive Committee to the
Society, and was re-
ceived and approved as such. The
Secretary stated the following
life members had died during the year, viz:
Gen. E. C. Dawes, of
Cincinnati; Hon. Allen G. Thurman, of
Columbus; Prof. N. S.
Townshend, of Columbus, and A. A.
Graham, late Secretary of
the Society.
In regard to the
"Archaeologist," which had for the year
1895 been the official organ of the
Society, the Secretary ex-
plained that September 1895, the
"Archaeologist" had been sold
(295)
296
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
by its proprietors to The Popular
Science News Company of
New York, and merged into that
publication. This last named
company had assumed and continued the
contract of the "Arch-
aeologist" with this Society until
the expiration of said contract
January, 1896, when it was thought best
not to renew said con-
tract, and the Society now has no
official publication.
In the matter of the Greenville
Centennial celebration, (Aug-
ust 1895), the Secretary stated that as
the Legislature had failed
to make the appropriation necessary to
enable the Society to par-
ticipate in that event, it was, of
course, unable to take part as a
Society. However, Judge W. J. Gilmore,
on behalf of the Society,
had delivered an address on the occasion
of the celebration, which
had reflected great credit on the
Society, and which had been
published. Dr. H. A. Thompson was also
present at the centen-
nial as a representative of the Society.
On motion of Mr. Rickly, the President,
Vice President and
Secretary were made a committee to
prepare and enter upon the
minutes of the Society suitable
memorials of life members de-
ceased during the past year.
The election of trustees was then taken
up, five to be elected.
On motion a nominating committee,
consisting of Messrs. Bareis,
Wood and Randall, was appointed to
nominate to the Society.
The report of this committee was
unanimously adopted, with
the following result: Hon. John Sherman,
Mansfield, Pro-
fessor George F. Wright, Oberlin, and
Rev. William E. Moore,
Columbus, whose terms expired at this
time, were re-elected to
succeed themselves for the following
three years, to February,
1899, and Hon. John P. Peaslee, of
Cincinnati, and Mr. A. H.
Smythe, of Columbus, were elected to
succeed Major E. C.
Dawes and Prof. N. S. Townshend,
deceased. The terms of
Messrs. Peaslee and Smythe being also
for three years from date
of election until February, 1899.
The terms of A. H. Smythe and E. O.
Randall, appointees
by Gov. McKinley, expired on February
18, 1896, and Gov.
Bushnell appointed E. O. Randall to
succeed himself for three
years ending February, 1899, and the
Hon. Alexander Boxwell
to succeed Mr. Smythe. Mr. Boxwell's
term to be also for three
years ending February, 1899.
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 297
Upon inquiry the Secretary made a report
of the efforts made
by the Executive Committee towards
securing a proper appro-
priation for the Society from the
Legislature, the gross amount
asked for being $5,000.00, which amount
it was believed the Leg-
islature would grant.
On motion of Mr. Williams, seconded by
Dr. Moore, the Ex-
ecutive Committee were instructed to use
such means as they
might find advisable for increasing the
membership of the Society,
and especially to bring the work and
aims of the Society to the
attention of the colleges and various
other institutions of learn-
ing throughout the State.
The following amendment to Article V,
Section 1, of the
Constitution, proposed by Mr. Wood, was
adopted, viz.:
"SEC. 1. The annual meeting of the
Society shall be held
in the City of Columbus at such time
during the month of Feb-
ruary of each year as the Executive
Committee may select. Due
notice of the meeting shall be mailed to
all members at least ten
(10) days before the said meeting is
held."
Mr. Bareis offered the following
amendment to Article III,
Section 3, of the Constitution, which
was adopted, making said
section read as follows:
"SEC. 3. There shall be an
Executive Committee, which
shall consist of the President, Vice
President, Secretary and
Treasurer, and not less than five other
members as the trustees
shall select from their own number. Five
members of said com-
mittee shall constitute a quorum for the
transaction of business.
The Executive Committee shall have full
power in the interim
to conduct and administer the affairs of
the Society."
A committee consisting of Messrs.
Bareis, Moore and
Thompson were appointed to await upon
the Governor and ex-
tend to him the congratulations and good
wishes of the Society.
Upon their return they reported a
pleasant and satisfactory
call upon the Governor, that he returned
greetings to the Society,
that it had his good wishes and would
have his cordial attention
and support.
The business portion of the meeting
having been concluded,
Mr. Cyrus Platt, of Delaware, read a
paper narrating the jour-
298
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
neyings of Col. James Kilbourne and
companion from Connec-
ticut to Ohio in the year 18-. This
paper proved of much inter-
est to his listeners, a number of
citizens of Columbus, not mem-
bers, being present. On motion a vote of
thanks was tendered
Mr. Platt for his paper, and he was
asked to deposit the same
with the Secretary of the Society for
preservation with the docu-
ments of the Society.
Mr. Warren K. Moorehead, Curator of the
Society, made
a detailed statement of what had been
done in the way of field
work for the Society during the past
year, and what it was desired
to accomplish during the coming year.
Following this a most
entertaining paper was read by Mr. J. J.
Janney, relating the
adventures of one of his ancestors, who
had been a prisoner of
the Indians during the early period of
Ohio's history. The paper
was listened to with evident interest
and appreciation, and upon
motion Mr. Janney was tendered a vote of
thanks and asked to
furnish the Secretary with a copy of the
paper for preservation.
On motion meeting adjourned.
The meeting of the Society was
immediately followed by
the annual meeting of the trustees.
ANNUAL MEETING OF THE TRUSTEES.
The following trustees were present:
Messrs. Arnett,
Bareis, Brinkerhoff, Follett, Hills,
Moore, Randall, Rickly,
Smythe, Thompson, Williams. General
Brinkerhoff was selected
as temporary chairman, and Mr. Randall
chosen temporary sec-
retary. The officers of the Society
elected by the trustees to
serve for the ensuing year from date of
February 27 were as
follows: President, R. Brinkerhoff,
Mansfield; Vice President,
William E. Moore, Columbus; Secretary,
E. O. Randall, Colum-
bus; Treasurer, S. S. Rickly, Columbus;
Assistant Treasurer,
E. F. Wood, Columbus. In addition to the
officers of the Soci-
ety, who are ex officio members, the
following Executive Com-
mittee was selected: Messrs. Bareis,
Gilmore, Hills, Ryan,
Smythe, Arnett.
On motion the matter of compensation to
the officers and
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 299
other agents found necessary to be
employed, was referred to
the Executive Committee with power to
act.
The Executive Committee adjourned to
meet on the morn-
ing of the 28th.
THE ANNUAL BANQUET.
On the evening of February 27, following
the custom of the
Society in closing their annual session
with a banquet, a most
interesting and enjoyable dinner was
given at the Neil House.
About eighty ladies and gentlemen were
seated at the board,
which was graced by the presence of
Governor and Mrs. Bush-
nell, Speaker D. L. Sleeper, Senator and
Mrs. Ely, Auditor and
Mrs. W. D. Guilbert, Senators Garfield,
Whittlesey, Mayor C. C.
Waddle of Chillicothe, Drs. Gladden and
Canfield and other dis-
tinguished guests, Governor and Mrs.
Bushnell occupying the
place of honor at the head of the table.
Secretary E. O. Randall
acted as toastmaster.
Hon. D. M. Massie, who was to have
responded to the toast,
"The Chillicothe Centennial,"
was unavoidably detained in that
city and Mayor C. C. Waddle filled his
place in a very creditable
manner.
President Roeliff Brinkerhoff began the
evening's ora-
tory in an admirable brief address which
deserves preservation
and is here given in full.
PRESIDENT BRINKERHOFF'S ADDRESS.
I congratulate the members and friends
of the Ohio Archae-
ological and Historical Association upon
the very encourag-
ing conditions under which we have met
to hold our annual meet-
ing and participate in our annual
banquet.
It is now twenty-one years since the
Archaeological and His-
torical Association had its beginning.
For the first ten years
it was the Archaeological Association
alone, and did a good work,
and then for eleven years as the
Archaeological and Historical
Association it did a larger work, and
now at last, upon its arrival
at the mature age of twenty-one, like a
young man who has
reached his majority, it is prepared to
go forth with more aggress-
iveness than ever before.
300 Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
More than ever before, I am sure, the
people of Ohio appre-
ciate the importance of preserving the
memorials of its greatness,
whether historic or prehistoric; often
in both directions it is un-
surpassed by any State in the Union.
For unknown centuries the area of land
known as the State
of Ohio has been one of the most favored
portions of the earth
for the support and comfort of the
various races who have come
and gone.
Centuries ago it was the dwelling place
of great nations, and
their memorials in the form of mounds
and fortifications, imple-
ments of war and warships, are scattered
all over the State. To
our shame and sorrow it must be said
that, in the preservation and
study of their memorials, other States
have done more than we
have ourselves.
Six months ago, in one single
collection, in the city of Sal-
isbury, England, I saw a museum of Ohio
Archaeology more rep-
resentative in its character than all
our Ohio collections put to-
gether. It was the famous Squire and
Davis collection described
in the first volume of the Smithsonian
publication, and was pur-
chased by William Blackmore in 1864, for
less than it cost to
gather it, and is now preserved in a
fireproof building erected
for that purpose, and is now known as
the Blackmore Museum.
All over Europe are spoils from Ohio
hunting grounds. So
also in the collections of other States,
and especially in the great
collection of the Smithsonian
institution in Washington.
As with prehistoric, so with later
years, in what is known as
the historic period, we have been
negligent of our duties, and
have not preserved such record of events
as we should have done.
Nations like men grow in strength and
wisdom by accumu-
lating experiences, and not to do this
is to remain stationary or
to lapse into barbarism. Another element
of growth is the pos-
session of inspiring ideals, and that
nation is greatest when
ideals are the highest, and ideals to be
effective must be embodied
in a life.
Under these circumstances it becomes the
highest duties of
a State to preserve a record of its
noblest men for the inspiration of
future generations.
No State in the Union has furnished
nobler men or nobler
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 301
deeds than the State of Ohio, and not to
preserve a record of
them is an outrage upon posterity.
To preserve these records is what the
Ohio Archaeological
and Historical Society is trying to do.
We have done something already, but we
want to do a great
deal more, and we appeal to the people
of Ohio, and to the Leg-
islature of Ohio to help us.
It is true there are local institutions
which have done good
work, and of these the Western Reserve
Historical Society de-
serves high commendation, but no local
society, with only local
support, can do what ought to be done
for the State.
Our Society is already a State
institution, and in its govern-
ment the State is represented by six
trustees, appointed by the
Governor, and we have received
assistance from the State, but
it is not sufficient for the work that
ought to be done.
What we need very much, and what we
ought to have in the
near future, is a fireproof building for
the preservation of his-
toric and prehistoric relics.
In Wisconsin a few years ago the State
appropriated
$180,000 for such a building in addition
to the annual amount
for its ample support, and it is the
only State west of the Alle-
ghenies that has done so well.
We believe that the people of Ohio would
approve similar
action, and the sooner it is done the
better.
It is true we can go forward on small appropriations, and
accomplish something, but the great
State of Ohio, the greatest
in the Union, ought not to be satisfied
with small things.
"To him that hath shall be
given" is a declaration especially
applicable to such an institution as
ours, for it grows like a snow-
ball, and the bigger it gets the larger
is its attractive force.
Such a building as we desire would bring
to it in contribu-
tion in a single year more than its
actual cash value.
These contributions would come in the
way of archaeological
collections, in historic documents, in
books, in pamphlets and
in many other things of historic value,
which are now scattered
all over the State, waiting for a
permanent resting-place in a
302 Ohio
Arch. and His. Society Publications.
fireproof building under the permanent
direction and protec-
tion of the State government.
In conclusion let me urge upon all who
are interested in our
cause to do what they can to bring about
the conditions we desire.
RESPONSES TO TOASTS.
Mr. Randall was the next speaker. About
three years
ago, he said he was unexpectedly called
into the presence of
Governor McKinley, who requested from
him information as to
the nature and purpose of the
Archaeological Society; to the Gov-
ernor he had explained in as "lucid
and luminous" a statement
as possible, that it was a society for
the preservation of the "bric-
a-brac" of his administration;
among a portion of that bric-a-brac
Governor Bushnell was now seated. Mr.
Randall, in a fitting
speech, then introduced Governor
Bushnell, who spoke as fol-
lows:
He thanked the Society for the cordial
greeting extended
to him. He said he felt as the boy did
at the revival. The min-
ister requested all who wanted to go to
heaven to stand up,
and all except one good-sized boy arose.
He then requested all
who wanted to go to the other place to
stand up. No one re-
sponded, and puzzled as to the action of
the boy who had both
times remained sitting, he asked him why
he had done so. The
boy replied that he didn't want to go to
either place, that Ohio
was good enough for him, and that was
just the way he felt
about it himself.
He was pleased with the bric-a-brac of
his administration.
We all love Ohio, he continued, for what
she was, for what she
is, and what she has in promise. Another
thing we love Ohio for
is that she has furnished men for every
occasion, whether in war
or peace, referring to the men whom she
had sent to battle, and
the indomitable leaders she gave to
them, Grant, Sherman
and Sheridan, and now she is to contest
the title of the "Mother
of Presidents" with her sister
State of Virginia, and the people
of the State will not object to Ohio
furnishing another President
of the United States in the person of
Governor McKinley.
President Brinkerhoff, who is a
Democrat, remarked that
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 303
they were going to run Campbell, which
sally interrupted the
address of the Governor by the round of
laughter which followed
from those present. The Governor replied
by relating an appro-
priate story.
One of the most important features of
the Ohio of the pres-
ent was the enlargement of the capital
building in this city. He
suggested the building of a wing on the
south for the accommo-
dation of the Supreme Court, and later a
wing on the north
for additional offices, another story
over the center, and finally
a handsome dome surmounting all. He
thought the improve-
ments could be made for $2,500,000, and
hoped some plan would
be arranged by which the amount could be
raised within the next
year. He predicted an improved condition
of the people and
institutions of every character that
would make Ohio a good
State for any man to select as his home,
and thus closed a char-
acteristically happy address.
"Early Politics and Politicians in
Ohio," was next discussed
by Hon. D. J. Ryan. Mr. Ryan said that
the politics of the day,
the partisanship and the men who mingled
in them were far
advanced from their condition in the
early days. He reviewed
in a somewhat humorous manner the
political history of the
State from its inception up to the
present time, and the bitter
partisanship that was injected into the
contests of bygone days
as compared with politics of the
present, and closed with the
assurance that the people and the
character of politics were both
growing better.
The next address was delivered by Gen.
George B. Wright
on "The Railroads and Telegraphs in
Ohio." He gave an inter-
esting review of the history and growth
of the railroads in the
State, and the regulations and customs
that governed their con-
struction and operation in the early
days. With a striking com-
parison of the mechanism and speed of
the railroad trains of the
present day and a short history of the
telegraph, he closed a most
entertaining address.
The Historical resources of the Hocking
Valley were most
ably and entertainingly recounted by
Hon. D. L. Sleeper, who
selected as his subject, "The
Hocking Valley as a Field for His-
torical Research."
304 Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
In opening his address he entered a
vigorous protest against
the name by which the beautiful and
picturesque valley was called.
It was a misnomer, the proper name being
Hock-hocking Valley,
a beautiful Indian name, which means
"a bottle," and having
been reared upon that bottle he would
insist upon proper respect
and deference.
The Hock-hocking Valley was prolific in
historical relics.
Within a few miles of Athens were a
number of mounds of great
symmetry and beauty. Abounding in the
beautiful valley were
abundant relics of the ancient
inhabitants who had made the
valley their home. In that valley is
found the oldest city of the
State, Marietta; the oldest inland city
of the State, Athens; the
first college that was established in
the State and the first library
that was founded. It was organized
February 7, 1804, and was
called the Coon Skin library from the
fact that it was founded
and sustained from the sale of the fur
of wild animals. Mr.
Sleeper closed with a short reference to
the legends and historical
events connected with the Valley.
Rev. William E. Moore next spoke
interestingly upon "The
Treasures of Fort Ancient." He said
that while a number of
archaeological specimens had been taken
from the fort, the prin-
cipal treasure of the fort was the fort
itself, which had remained
almost without evidence of change during
the many years it had
been cultivated. He advanced the theory
that the fort was con-
structed for military defense by the
prehistoric inhabitants of the
State. It seems that when the State
purchased the fort, a num-
ber of acres were left outside the fort,
though from what reason
was not known, and he strongly advocated
the purchase of that
portion of the structure without the
possession of the State.
Mayor Waddle, in responding to the
toast, "The Chillicothe
Centennial," for Hon. D. M. Massie,
expressed for Mr. Massie
his deep regret at being denied the
pleasure of attending the
banquet and called the attention of the
assemblage to the coming
centennial celebration of the city of
which he was the represen-
tative. He referred to the history of
Chillicothe, its interest to
the student of history, the illustrious
men who reposed within
its churchyard and closed with an
invitation to the Society and
those present to attend the coming
celebration.
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 305
Hon. James R. Garfield delivered a happy
speech in his
response to the toast, "Importance
of History in the Schools and
Colleges of the State." In opening
his address he said that he
could not determine why when a man
entered politics and was
elected to office that the title
"Hon." was prefixed to his name.
Men followed the ordinary pursuits of
life, but the title was never
conferred upon them, and the logical
deduction was that politics
was synonymous with honor and the
distinction followed natur-
ally. The Society had shown great
foresight and sagacity in
inviting a number of members of the
Legislature to the banquet
and then, after the inner man had been
thoroughly satisfied, to
have delicately intimated that they too
wanted an appropriation.
Reverting to the subject of his address,
Mr. Garfield discussed
its influence upon the formation of the
character in school chil-
dren and the benefit that would accrue
to them when they were
men and women.
Following Mr. Garfield Mr. John J.
Janney spoke upon "Do
Any of the Earthworks of the
Moundbuilders Have Any Military
Significance?" He was skeptical as
to the positive statements
in regard to the significance attached
to the relics unearthed and
the mounds in the State and contended
that all explanations
offered for their presence or assertions
as to their builders, or the
age of their existence was the merest
speculation, for the period
of their creation antedated the
country's history. In speaking
more particularly of the text of his
address he controverted the
statement of Rev. Mr. Moore, that Fort
Ancient was constructed
for warlike purposes. In argument he
said that the inhabitants
at that time did not fight in a manner
that would require fortifica-
tions of that nature and to his mind
such works were more closely
associated with the sports and pleasures
of the race, and that the
purpose of the mounds, the date of the
race and the date of their
departure was merely guesswork.
Dr. Washington Gladden followed with an
eloquent and
masterly address upon "Life of the
People in History." He be-
gan his address by saying that one of
the strong proofs of the
rise of the people can be found in
history. It was not long ago
that historians were occupied with camps
and courts, warriors
306
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
and lawyers, slayers and tax eaters. Of
late years his-
tory has taken on a new phase. The first
instance of this
change was given to the world by
Macaulay, which was followed
by a succession of more signal
illustrations of this new develop-
ment up to the present time. There was
yet unfilled great op-
portunity for further development in
historical research and com-
pilation along the lines of State
education, canals and railroads,
the economic history of the State, its
depressions and the rem-
edies which had been applied to their
correction. The life of the
people of the State and country was an
inexhaustible source of in-
formation and instruction. A study of
history was necessary
to the advancement of the people, who
were the coming kings,
and nothing would elevate them more than
an interest in and
study of their own history.
In beginning his address upon
"Relations of the 0. A. &
H. S. to the 0. S. U.," Dr. James
H. Canfield entertained the
guests with a number of well-told and
humorous stories that im-
mediately placed him in the best of
favor with his hearers. Re-
verting to the subject of his address,
he said that it was with
great regret that he saw the absence of
the proper interest that
should be manifested in the work of the
Society, but thought that
the right course to enlist this interest
had not been followed.
Not that he meant to criticise the work
of the Society, but that
other plans could be employed with, in
his mind, greater results.
The present generation was too busily
employed with the other
cares of life, the responsibility was
too great, and the pressure
too constant to permit of the proper
attention being paid to the
Society and its mission.
We must look for the increased interest
in archaeological
research in the generation to come, and
the work of establishing
this must be undertaken at once, and
through the medium of
the schools of the State. The initial
step should be taken by in-
spiring in the student a spirit of
inquiry into historical subjects
by requiring him to trace out the
history of his home, his school,
his city, and gradually broadening the
scope until it embraces
the objective point. History, in his
opinion, had always been
taught backward; teachers had always
begun with ancient his-
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 307
tory and followed its instruction until
the immediate history of
a scholar's country was reached and
there it stopped, probably
from the fact that it was supposed that
he either knew of it him-
self, or it was not of sufficient
importance to merit the time ex-
pended in its teaching. This, he
contended, was the most im-
portant feature of history and should be
taught before any of
the other branches. He advocated the
offering of prizes by the
Society for answers upon the subjects of
archaeological research
to the pupils of the schools and
colleges of the State, and pre-
dicted most gratifying results from the
plan.
Referring to the university, he said
that it was and should
be the Mecca of every great task in
literature or other branch of
mental attainment, and he hoped to see
the day not far off when
there would be a library building built
by the State, or the public
spirit of its citizens, should occupy
the center of the campus and
that therein should be combined the
magnificent library of the
university and the works and collection
of the Archaeological
Society. Whether one of the statesmen
present would act upon
the suggestion he did not know, but said
that it would be one
of the happenings of the near future.
The following guests were present: Governor and Mrs.
Bushnell, Judge and Mrs. Spear, Dr. and
Mrs. Edgar Hatton,
Mr. and Mrs. B. D. Hills, Hon. and Mrs.
F. S. Monnett, Dr. L. C.
Herrick, Frank Henry Howe, D. C.
Baldwin, Mrs. Hartsough,
Hon. Tod B. Galloway, John J. Janney,
Mr. and Mrs. H. E. Bar-
low, Mr. and Mrs. Frank E. Kalb, Hon.
and Mrs. W. D. Guilbert,
Miss Clara Howe, William G. Pengelly, A.
H. Smythe, Miss
Rita Randall, Miss Nellie Hayden, Hon.
D. J. Ryan, W. H. Jen-
nings, Col. J. Linn Rodgers, Prof.
Warren K. Moorehead, Mr.
and Mrs. E. F. Wood, Mr. and Mrs. M. E.
Lovejoy, Professor
and Mrs. J. A. Shawan, General George B.
Wright, Rev.
A. A. E. Taylor, Dr. and Mrs. William E.
Moore, Pres-
ident James H. Canfield, Dr. and Mrs.
Washington Gladden,
Dr. Gard, Dr. C. C. Shepherd, Hon. C. C.
Waddle, Chillicothe;
Israel Williams, Hamilton; Senator
Whittlesey, Senator James R.
Garfield, Mentor; General Roeliff
Brinkerhoff, Mansfield; Cyrus
Platt, Delaware; Mr. and Mrs. J. H. Todd,
L. Backus, Bishop B.
308
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
W. Arnett, Wilberforce; Rev. H. A.
Thompson, Dayton; Gerard
Fowke, Hon. D. L. Sleeper, Athens; R. D.
Jacobs, Senator and
Mrs. Ely, Mr. and Mrs. G. F. Bareis,
Canal Winchester; Mr. and
Mrs. R. E. Hills, Delaware; Mr. and Mrs.
E. O. Randall.
PURCHASE OF FORT ANCIENT.
As the records of the Society kept by
the previous Secretary
contain little or no account of the
first purchase of Fort Ancient,
a detailed statement is here made, that
it may be permanently
recorded.
In order that the property of Fort
Ancient, then in the hands
of private parties, might be properly
preserved by the State, at
the earnest solicitation of the Society,
the Legislature on April
28, 1890, passed an act known as Senate
Bill 308 "To provide
for the preservation of Fort
Ancient." The provisions of this
bill were as follows:
FIRST PURCHASE.
SECTION 1. Be it enacted by the General
Assembly of
the State of Ohio, That for the purpose
of preserving the pre-
historic earthworks known as Fort
Ancient, situate in Warren
county, Ohio, a committee of five shall
be appointed, two by the
President of the Senate, two by the
Speaker of the House of
Representatives, and one by the Attorney
General. Said com-
mittee are hereby authorized in behalf
of the State, to purchase
for the State the lands upon which Fort
Ancient are (is) located,
or so much thereof as may be necessary,
to include all, or the most
important part of said works, not less
than one hundred and eighty
acres in the aggregate, at a price not
exceeding forty dollars per
acre. Such purchase shall be approved by
the Governor and
the Attorney General of the State. The
title to such lands must
be approved by the Attorney General of
the State before the
same is accepted, and when accepted
shall be conveyed to the
State of Ohio, and the deed thereof
shall be duly recorded and
deposited with the Auditor of State.
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 309
SEC. 2. That for the purpose of carrying
out the provisions
of this act, there is hereby
appropriated out of any moneys in
the treasury, and not otherwise
appropriated, to the credit of
the general revenue fund, the sum of
seven thousand two hun-
dred dollars, or so much as may be
necessary to purchase said
lands.
SEC. 3. This act shall take effect and
be in force from and
after its passage.
A. C. ROBESON,
Speaker pro tern. of the House of
Representatives.
WILLIAM V. MARQUIS,
President of the Senate.
Pursuant to this act, a committee of the
Legislature and of
the Society visited the property, and it
was subsequently pur-
chased, the deed of the grantors to the
State being properly
accepted by the State authorities on May
11, 1891, but it de-
veloped that the State, either through
some misunderstanding
of the committee acting for the State,
or of the immediate parties
between whom the negotiations were
perfected, failed to purchase
the entire property of the Fort, and the
State came into posses-
sion of only one hundred and eighty
acres, embracing the cen-
tral portion of the Fort, and a strip of
land immediately east of
the center of the Fort, and leaving
unpurchased the south end
of the Fort and the north end, known as
the Couden and Ridge
tracts respectively.
SECOND PURCHASE.
Since the time of the first purchase
(May 1891) the Society has
urged the Legislature to make a
sufficient appropriation to secure
the remainder of the Fort. The
Seventy-second General As-
sembly upon a presentation of this
matter by the Secretary of
the Society, made an appropriation
(April 16, 1896), in the gen-
eral appropriation bill, of the sum of
$5,200 (see 92d Ohio Laws,
174), for the "purchase of
remaining portion of Fort Ancient."
This sum was deemed sufficient at the
time, as at the same price
per acre paid for the previous tract, it
would secure the remain-
ing portions that were desired, and land
at this date (1896), if
changed at all, was thought worth less
than a few years
310
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
ago. Upon an attempt by the Secretary
and a committee to
negotiate with the owners for the
portions desired, it was found
that the Couden strip, at the south end
of the Fort, consisted of
85 acres embracing the Fort proper, and
some 22 acres immedi-
ately east of and without the center of
the Fort. This property
the proprietors would not part with at a
price less than fifty
dollars an acre, or $5,200 for the
entire amount consisting of one
hundred and five acres more or less. As
to the strip at the north
end, consisting of some twelve acres,
known as the Ridge prop-
erty, it had been purchased, as was
claimed, by a corporation
for the purpose of erecting thereon a
summer hotel, plans for
which had been drawn and advertisements
for the sale of lots
adjacent to the hotel, published in
various papers. This com-
pany, known as the Fort Ancient Hotel
Company, demanded
some three thousand dollars for the
property, with the prospective
privilege of completing the hotel. The
securing of the Ridge prop-
erty on such a basis by the Society, for
the State, was of course
out of the question, and negotiations
proceeded no further with
those parties. After due consultation by
the Secretary of the
Society with the Auditor of State and
the Attorney General, it
was decided that in accordance with the
opinion rendered by
Attorney General Monnett, the State,
through the Society, could,
under the provisions of the
appropriation, purchase the Couden
tract, expending therefor the total
amount appropriated ($5,200),
and leaving the Ridge tract still
unpurchased. This purchase
was accordingly made, the abstract and
deed for the Couden
tract being approved by the proper State
officers, December 5,
1896. This purchase is indicated on the
plat, a copy of which
is herewith printed. This leaves
unpurchased the Ridge tract
of about twelve acres immediately north
of the Fort Ancient and
Clarksville pike, and embracing the
embankments at that end of
the Fort. In addition to this, during
the negotiations made for
the purchase of the Couden tract, it was
discovered that there
is about one acre of land cutting into
the Fort in a wedge-shape
manner, on the west side of the center
of the Fort, belonging to
the adjacent outside property of Mr.
Poor. It is desirable that
the State obtain entire possession of
the Fort in due time by pur-
chases of the Ridge tract and the Poor
wedge. In the negotia-
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 311
tions for the purchase of the Couden
tract, the Secretary of the
Society was materially assisted by the
Hon. Alexander Boxwell,
and Messrs. Moore and Bareis, trustees
of the Society, and Mr.
D. W. Humphreys, representative of the
grantors of the Couden
tract.
CARE OF FORT ANCIENT.
The committee, with Rev. William E.
Moore as chairman
and superintendent, having the custody
and care of Fort Ancient
in charge, have diligently and
faithfully performed its work. The
funds appropriated by the State for this
special purpose have been
profitably expended. Several visits
during the year have been
made to the fort by the chairman and
other members of the Ex-
ecutive Committee,and personal
supervision has been given to the
repair and preservation of this famous
prehistoric spot. On
August 1, 1896, the contract, which the
Society had with Messrs.
Moorehead and Cowen, as to the custody
of the fort terminated,
and on the 19th day of September, 1896,
a new contract was
made with Mr. Warren Cowen, as the
immediate party to take
charge of and have certain uses of the
property of the fort. This
contract dates back to August 1, 1896,
and is to continue for three
years, terminating August 1, 1899. Mr.
Cowen has proved,
through two years experience, to be a
most reliable and com-
petent man for this work, as is shown by
the report of Dr. Moore,
chairman of the committee on Fort
Ancient, which report is
herewith submitted.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE ON FORT ANCIENT.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, Dec. 20, 1896.
To E. O. Randall, Secretary:
My Dear Sir:-The sub-committee on Fort
Ancient, on No-
vember 14, 1896, inspected the work done
by Warren Cowen,
by direction of the Executive Committee.
They found the work
done satisfactory.
The ground cleared of undergrowth last
year had been care-
fully gone over and the new growth of
sprouts and weeds cut
312 Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
off. The tile sewer drains of last year
were found to be in perfect
order, carrying the accumulations of
water in the low places
inside the walls through and beyond
them. The washes within
the walls, which last year were stopped
by dams of stone and
logs, were found to have done their work
so far effectually, and
to need only care from year to year,
reinforcing these dams to
close the openings completely. The very
serious wash and open-
ing made years ago on the eastern side
of the fort to let out the
accumulated water, has been effectually
stopped. A sewer drain
of tile put in and the wall brought up
to its original height. No
attempt otherwise has been made to
restore the walls. Nor is it
contemplated, save as the result of the
completion of the plans
now pursued for stopping the washes and
draining the ponds.
There being no water for drinking within
the walls, other
than the well at the house near the
entrance, the Executive Com-
mittee directed a well and pump to be
put in where it would be
convenient for the use of visitors. Mr.
Cowen was directed to
contract for and superintend the work.
A well has been driven in the lower fort
in the grove which
will be most probably preferred for
excursion gatherings in the
fort. The well is 107 feet in depth,
with an iron pump in steel
casing, and yields an abundant supply of
pure water.
The field in corn last year has been
sown with wheat and
seeded with grass.
Additional work in clearing away the
undergrowth, dead
and fallen trees, etc., on the lines of
last year has been satisfactorily
done. The aim of the committee has been,
and is, to clear grad-
ually the whole property, both within
and without the walls, of
all undergrowth, so as to give
everywhere a clear view of this
wonderful work; to leave the forest
trees and, so far as possible,
to get the whole in grass, making a
beautiful park, worthy of the
State and of the Society. To accomplish
this result at no distant
day, we believe that a comparatively
small appropriation from
year to year will suffice and that in a
few years the property will
pay its own expenses. Respectfully,
WM. E. MOORE, Chairman.
Twelfth Annual Meeiing. 313
WORK OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE.
The Executive Committee has been most
faithful, efficient
and indefatigable in its supervision of
the affairs of the Society,
in its efforts to protect its interests,
promote the objects of the
Society and economically expend the
funds placed at the disposal
of the Society by the appropriation of
the Legislature. The
committee as a whole has held ten
regular meetings on the fol-
lowing dates: February 28, March 3,
April 7, May 5, July 6,
August 17, September 12, October 12,
December 8, January 14,
Special meetings of the Finance
Committee, Committee on Fort
Ancient and Committee on Library and
Museum were held at
various times, and never before in the
history of the Society have
its officers and trustees shown so much
interest in, or devoted so
much time to, the affairs of the
Society. Every detail of the
work in the Society has been directed by
the Executive Commit-
tee, or at least been carefully
scrutinized by it.
The Committee on Museum and Library
makes the follow-
ing report:
REPORT OF COMMITTEE ON MUSEUM AND
LIBRARY.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, Dec. 20, 1896.
To E. O. Randall, Secretary:
DEAR SIR:-The past year has been one of
marked improve-
ment in the museum of the Society.
Heretofore the specimens
owned by or loaned to the Society and
those of the Ohio State
University were scattered among the
different cases belonging
to both institutions; the Curator could
readily tell to which col-
lection each specimen belonged, but
visitors found it difficult to
identify one from the other collection.
Then came the thousands
of specimens secured during the year, as
a result of the "field
work"; of donations; of purchases
and exchanges of extra rare
articles which necessitated relics being
placed two and in some
instances three tiers deep, thus hiding
many from view. Five (5)
handsome new cases, with a display space
of some 400 square
feet, have just been placed in position;
these, in addition to the
space formerly occupied by the
university collection, have per-
314
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
mitted a proper display and
arrangement. So that now all the
specimens are plainly and neatly
numbered and a type-written
catalogue made and the specimens so
separated that visitors have
no difficulty in distinguishing the
collections of the Society. To
one not having seen the collection for a
year there will appear
a most marked evolution. From a
"lot of relics" there has grown
up the beginning of a
"personnel" which it is hoped will develop
to such a degree that the students can
trace the rise and progress
of the stone age in all its features as
found in our State. Many
historic and pioneer documents and other
valuable articles have
been added to the museum and properly
labeled and catalogued.
Of the library not so flattering a
report can be given. On
account of the lack of book-cases and
suitable room our books
and pamphlets are nearly all stored in
boxes. Many maps and
charts are also stored away for lack of
proper display space. It
is hoped that the arrangements now
nearly consummated to
occupy an alcove in the Ohio State
Library rooms will give the
Society at least temporary quarters to
place its valuable library
at the disposal of those who desire to
use it. The great need of
the library (this also applies to the
museum) is proper quarters
in the Capitol building.
Respectfully submitted,
GEO. F. BAREIS, Chairman.
PUBLICATIONS.
The Society has now in press, and will
probably have issued
by the time this report is printed, the
fifth volume of its publica-
tion of documents and papers. This
volume comprising some
five hundred pages, with maps and
illustrations, will prove one
of the most valuable yet issued by the
Society. Its main feature
is a history of the land title to the
State of Ohio, commencing
with the original land charters by the
English kings to the colo-
nial companies, and tracing the abstract
of title from mother
country sources to the establishment of
the boundary lines of
the State of Ohio and the formation of
the State Constitu-
tion of 1802. This volume also contains
a full and interesting
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 315
account of the work done by the Society
during the past year
in archaeological research and
explorations, with illustrations.
The Society has now published, not
including the extensive report
of the Society's exhibit at Chicago (80
pages, 1894), five volumes
of interesting, valuable matter,
pertaining to Ohio, its history,
biography and archaeology. Most of this
material has been
either originally prepared or
exclusively preserved by the Society,
and the work of the Society in this line
alone is sufficient reason
for its being and cause for ample
support by the State. These
publications are in great demand by the
leading historical socie-
ties and libraries, not only of the
United States, but even those
in Europe. These books are all in well
preserved plates. Sec-
ond editions have already been required
of the first three volumes
and no doubt a second edition of volume
four will soon be de-
manded.
LIBRARY AND EXCHANGES.
The Society is in constant
correspondence with the other
State societies and the leading
historical societies of the country.
With all these a system of exchange of
publications is established,
and a large and valuable library is in
this manner being accu-
mulated-a library which can be obtained
in no other way, and
which will be of inestimable interest
and value to all who wish
to consult this class of literature. The
State of Ohio has been
most negligent in collecting and
preserving historical material
pertaining to Ohio. Our Society is doing what it can to assist
in accumulating an Ohio historical
library.
In accordance with the instructions of
the trustees at the
last annual meeting (February, 1896),
the Secretary has had kept
a Society Scrap Book in which are
carefully preserved articles and
newspaper clippings from the leading
papers of the State on
all subjects bearing upon the purpose
and aims of the Society.
316 Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
QUARTERS FOR THE SOCIETY.
More than ever must the Secretary urge
the great necessity
of the Society for adequate quarters for
the placing and preser-
vation of its property, and facilities
for its work. The Society
is very much hampered by its lack of a
"local habitation." The
archaeological collections of the
Society are now located in Orton
building of the Ohio State University,
upon the second or gal-
lery floor of the museum, where the
University authorities have
generously accorded us such space as
they can spare. Our
library is mostly packed in boxes in the
basement rooms of the
same building, and in the office of the
Treasurer. The State
of Ohio cannot afford to ignore the
wants of the Historical and
Archaeological Society in this matter.
As has been suggested
elsewhere in this report, the State
Library Commission have
offered us an alcove in the State
Library, which we may occupy
until permanent quarters are accorded
us, and it is fully expected
that when the new addition to the State
House is built, ample
quarters for our exclusive use will be
provided in some excellent
portion of the present building. Many
valuable donations of
books, documents and specimen
collections are only waiting to
come into the possession of the Society
when it has proper and
safe quarters to receive them. The
Society has grown in the value
and extent of its work and its
reputation till it is recognized as
being in the front rank of similar State
socieies, and our great
State cannot do otherwise than liberally
promote its progress.
No State can surpass Ohio for wealth of
material in the line of
Archaeology, Biography and History. The
Ohio State Archae-
ological and Historical Society is the
only State agency for the
collecting and preserving of this
wealth. It should be afforded
every means and facility required for
the full accomplishment of
its purpose.
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 317
TREASURER'S REPORT.
FEBRUARY 1, 1896 TO FEBRUARY 1, 1897.
RECEIPTS.
Balance on hand February 1, 1896, . . $ 328 82
Membership Dues, . . . . 96 00
Banquet Tickets, .. . 58 00
Sale of Picks, .
. . . . . . . . .. . .60
From State Treasurer for Current Expenses, . . 1,700 00
"
" "
Publications, . . . . 349 04
" Field Work, . . . 826 30
"
" " Care of Fort
Ancient, . . 501 55
"Purchase of Fort Ancient, . 5,200 00
Interest on Permanent Fund, . . 29
00
Total, . . . . . $9,089 66
DISBURSEMENTS.
Purchase Portion of Fort Ancient, . .. $ 5,200 00
Improvements at Fort Ancient, . 468 10
Expenses Incident to Care and Purchase, . 53 10
Field Work,
. . .826 30
Five (5) Cases for Specimens at Museum, . .. 270
00
Volume 4, Balance in full, . .. 371 50
Binding Publications and Miscellaneous Books, . . 78 95
Books Purchased,
. . . 49 84
Job Printing, . . . 108 75
Postage Account, . . . . . 80 57
Salary Account, . . . . 1,146 67
Stenographer, Balance for 1895, .. 25 00
Annual Banquet, February, 1896, . . 80
00
Supplies and Sundries, . 47
10
Clerical Work at Museum, . 20
00
Railroad Fare Mileage (Trustees), . 17
31
Express, Drayage, ete., .. 10
95
Balance in Treasury February 1, 1897, . 235
52
Total, . . .
. . . $9,089 66
S. S. RICKLY, Treasurer.
EDWIN F. WOOD, Assistant Treasurer.
318
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
OUTSIDE WORK OF THE SOCIETY.
In no year of the history of the Society
has so much been
done throughout the State to bring the
work and value of the
Society to the attention of the
citizens. This has been done by
distribution of literature of the
Society and by lectures at various
points, especially by Mr. Moorehead,
whose report of his work
speaks for itself, and which is herewith
added in full.
MR. MOOREHEAD'S REPORT.
COLUMBUS, OHIO, Dec. 30, 1896.
E. O. Randall, Secretary:
Sir:-I have the honor to report that the
collections of the
Society have been more than doubled
during the year 1896, and
that-taken as a whole-the growth of the
Museum has been
exceedingly gratifying. In accordance
with the wishes of the
Society, my time during the past year
has been exclusively oc-
cupied in field work, and when not in
the field in conducting cor-
respondence with numerous individuals
throughout the State,
with a view to procuring from them
collections to be preserved
by the Society. We have added something
like 22,000 speci-
mens, about three-fourths of which are
the property of the So-
ciety, the others are loaned
collections. Fifteen lectures have
been deliverd in various cities of Ohio,
and at all of these the
literature of the Society was
distributed. I am persuaded that
we will reap great benefits from the
advertising which we have
had. Nearly one hundred county and city
papers have kindly
published editorials for us calling
attention to the necessity of
preserving archaeological and historical
specimens. By means
of this cooperation on the part of the
press of the State, we have
received a number of valuable donations.
Of most importance is our State
Archaeological Map. There
are now upon it nearly three thousand
marks, representing about
six thousand prehistoric village sites,
mounds, fortifications and
enclosures. They are recorded by
townships and sections, and
this map will be of great value to
future generations when most
of these structures have become
obliterated.
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 319
The Society has been heartily commended
by several Sci-
entific institutions of the East for
undertaking the production of
this map.
Nearly all the summer was devoted to
field work, and my
assistants and myself covered the
territory from the head waters
of the Muskingum to the Ohio River, up
the Scioto to Rich-
mondale and along the Ohio from the
mouth of Brush Creek to
Ironton.
A total of thirty-two tumuli and mounds
were explored. In
some of these we found copper plates and
ear ornaments, pipes,
mica and ocean shells, beads and stone
tomahawks, etc. Many
perfect crania were secured, and as
mound skulls are exceeding
rare in museums, they will be of great
value in the study of the
physical characteristics of our ancient
tribes.
The famous mound at McConnelsville was
thoroughly ex-
plored, and many interesting remains
found therein.
The collections of the Society are all
in order, properly
labeled and numbered, and are mounted
according to the locality
(river valleys) in which they were
found.
I would suggest the advisability of
sending some one
through the northern and central
portions of the State next
summer in order to locate accurately the
several thousand an-
cient remains which are not upon our
map, and which we can-
not secure by correspondence.
People all over the State are
continually writing to the Mu-
seum with reference to the proper names,
uses, etc., of speci-
mens in their possession; for
information on the mounds and
earthworks, and for literature upon the
subject. This is evi-
dence of the growing interest in our
Society, and that it is
now regarded as an educational, and if I
may be permitted to use
the term-an authoritative society, from
which can be obtained
assistance and information heretofore
only obtained from the
Eastern museums.
At the present rate of growth more
commodious quarters
will soon be absolutely necessary for
our collections.
Although the appropriation has been
inadequate for the
work assumed, it is fair to state we
have added more specimens
320
Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
than some institutions which have a
greater revenue. I bespeak
for the Museum larger appropriations.
In conclusion I beg to thank you and the
trustees for the
hearty support you have given me.
WARREN KING MOOREHEAD, Curator.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.
In closing this report I desire in
behalf of the trustees of
the Society to express our appreciation
of the courteous consid-
eration and friendly support accorded
the Society by Governor
Bushnell, Attorney General Monnett and
Assistant Attorney Gen-
eral Lott, and also to President
Canfield and Professor Edward
Orton of the Ohio State University.
Personally I acknowledge my
indebtedness, for valua-
bles assistance, in the discharge of the
duties of my office, to the
officers of the Society, and
particularly to the members of the
Executive Committee of the Trustees.
Respectfully submitted,
E. O. RANDALL, Secretary.
Columbus, Ohio, February 1, 1897.
NECROLOGY.
Hon. William J. Gilmore, formerly judge
of the Ohio
Supreme Court, a life member and for
many years a trustee
of the Society died at his residence in
Columbus, August 9th,
1896. He was buried at Eaton, Ohio, August 11th, the Society
being represented by the secretary at
the ceremonies of inter-
ment. In the decease of Judge Gilmore
the Society lost a most
valued member and a most faithful and
wise counsellor and
officer.
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 321
ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION- MARCH 13,
1885.
The undersigned citizens of Ohio, having
associated them-
selves together, and desiring to form a
corporation not for profit,
under the laws of the said State of
Ohio, do hereby subscribe and
acknowledge the following articles of
incorporation:
1. The name of such corporation shall be
The Ohio State
Archaeological and Historical Society.
2. Said corporation shall be located and
its principle busi-
ness transacted at the City of Columbus,
County of Franklin,
and State of Ohio.
3. Said Society is formed for the
purpose of promoting a
knowledge of archaeology and history,
especially of Ohio, by
establishing and maintaining a library of
books, manuscripts,
maps, charts, etc., properly pertaining
thereto; a museum of pre-
historic relics and natural or other
curiosities or specimens of
art or nature promotive of the objects
of the Association-said
library and museum to be open to the
public on reasonable
terms-and by courses of lectures and
publications of books,
papers and documents touching the
subjects so specified, with
power to receive and hold gifts and
devises of real and personal
estate for the benefit of such Society,
and generally to exercise
all the powers legally and properly
pertaining thereto.
4. Said Society has no capital stock.
The Articles of Incorporation were
signed by twenty-eight
persons.
HISTORY OF THE OHIO STATE ARCHAEOLOGICAL
AND HISTORICAL SOCIETY.
During the year 1875, an archaeological
society was formed
at General Brinkerhoff's home, in
Mansfield, Ohio. This society,
through the efforts of General
Brinkerhoff, received an appro-
priation from the State of Ohio of two
thousand five hundred
dollars, to be expended in making an
exhibit at the Centennial
Exposition at Philadelphia. Prof. John
T. Short, of the Ohio
State University, was secretary of the
society, and it flourished
322 Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
under his secretaryship until his
untimely death, when the society
became dormant and practically
inoperative. Governor Hoadly,
who took an active interest in all
matters pertaining to the arch-
aeology and history of the State, upon
his accession to office con-
ferred with Mr. A. A. Graham and
suggested a revival of the old
society. A meeting for the purpose of
carrying into effect this
suggestion was called to convene at the
Secretary of State's office,
on the twelfth day of February, 1885. A
number of prominent
gentlemen, including leading citizens,
scholars and professors
from various parts of the State,
responded to this call, and de-
cided to extend to all persons in the
State interested in the for-
mation of such a society, an invitation
to meet on the twelfth day
of March following, at Columbus, Ohio.
In response to the cir-
culars sent out, some sixty gentlemen
from all parts of Ohio, rep-
resenting the various departments of
scholarship, convened on
the day specified in the Library Room of
the State Capitol. The
meeting having been called to order by
Hon. S. S. Rickly, the
Hon. Allen G. Thurman was made
President, and Mr. A. A.
Graham elected Secretary.* This
convention continued in session
for two days and resulted in perfecting
an organization known
as The Ohio State Archaeological and
Historical Society, which
was duly incorporated on the 13th day of
March, 1885. The
Articles of Incorporation succinctly set
forth the purposes and
aims of the Society.
The following have served as Presidents
of the Society since
its organization: Allen G. Thurman,
Francis C. Sessions, Ruth-
erford B. Hayes and Roeliff Brinkerhoff.
For twelve years the Society has
faithfully pursued the lines
of study and investigation for which it
was organized, and has
held regular annual meetings at
Columbus. In that time it has
accumulated a valuable collection of
relics and intiquities, now
consisting of over 30,000 specimens,
mostly archaeological in char-
acter, but embracing also many papers
and articles of historical
value. This collection has been
catalogued and arranged in
cases, and now occupies temporary
quarters in the Museum of
*Mr. Graham occupied the office of
secretary until December, 1893,
when ill health compelled him to move to
the West. He died in Albu-
querque, N. M., in February, 1896.
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 323
Orton Hall at the Ohio State University.
The library of the
Society, which numbers several hundred
volumes of considerable
value, is being constantly augmented by
exchanges and other-
wise, is now placed in an alcove of the
State Library. The Mu-
seum in Orton Hall is accessible to
visitors on each week day,
between the hours of 9:00 a. m. and 5:00
p. m.
The Society's archaeological collection
was placed on ex-
hibition at the Centennial Exposition of
the Ohio Valley, 1888,
and also at the World's Columbian
Exposition at Chicago, 1893,
where it was acknowledged the finest and
most complete display
of the kind made by any of the States.
MEMBERSHIP.
Article II, of the Constitution,
provides for membership to
this Society as follows:
SECTION 1. The membership of this
Society shall be
divided into four classes, designated as
follows: Life Members,
Active Members, Corresponding Members,
and Honorary Mem-
bers. Application for membership shall
be made to the Secre-
tary of the Society and by him referred
to the Executive Com-
mittee. Upon the approval of the
Executive Committee, such
applicants shall be declared members.
SEC. 2. The payment at any one time of
twenty-five dollars
($25.00) to the Society shall constitute
the person so paying a
life member. Life members shall be
exempt from all further
dues, and shall be entitled to all the
privileges of active member-
ship. Any person who shall make a
donation to the Society,
the value of which shall be determined
by the Trustees, to be
not less than twenty-five dollars
($25.00), shall be entitled to life
membership. Said life membership
payments shall constitute
a permanent fund to be invested at the
discretion of the Execu-
tive Committee. The income only of this
fund shall be used
by the Society for such purposes as the
Executive Committee
may direct.
SEC. 3. Active members shall be
residents of Ohio and
shall pay in advance an annual fee of
three dollars ($3.00). They
shall be entitled to vote and hold
office. They shall receive free
324 Ohio Arch. and His. Society Publications.
all publications of the Society and have
free access to the museum
and library.
SEC. 4. Corresponding members may be
residents of any
locality and shall be persons who take
an interest in the Society,
and its objects, and are willing to aid
it by representing its in-
terests and securing donations for its
museum and library. Sec-
retaries of historical or kindred
societies whose publications are
furnished to this Society, may be
constituted corresponding
members.
SEC. 5. Honorary members shall be
persons distinguished
for scientific and literary attainments,
particularly in the depart-
ment of archaeology and history.
About one hundred and twenty-five
persons have become
life members of the Society and some
three hundred have at
various times been enrolled as active
members.
GOVERNMENT OF THE SOCIETY.
The government of the Society is vested
in a board of twenty-
one (21) trustees, fifteen of whom are
elected by ballot by the
Society at its annual meetings. They are
divided into three
classes, five only being elected each
year to serve for three years
each from the time of their election, or
until their successors are
elected and qualified. The other six
trustees necessary to com-
plete the number of twenty-one (21), are
appointed by the Gover-
nor of Ohio, as provided by the
legislative enactment of April
16, 1891, two to be appointed each year
to serve for the period
of three years, or until their
successors are appointed and
qualified.
ARCHAEOLOGICAL DEPARTMENT.
Particularly is the Society strong in
archaeological research.
No State in the Union is so rich in
archaeological resources, con-
sisting of mounds, forts, graves and
monuments of prehistoric
periods.
This department of the Society is under
the direction of
Prof. Warren K. Moorehead. Mr. Moorehead
is Professor of
Archaeology in the Ohio State
University, Fellow of the Amer-
ican Association for the Advancement of
Science, and is a most
Twelfth Annual Meeting. 325
accomplished scholar on this subject,
being the author of "Primi-
tive Man in Ohio," and a complete
work on "Fort Ancient."
The Society is the custodian of Fort
Ancient, the largest,
best preserved and most interesting
remains of its character now
extant. Models of this fort are in some
of the leading museums
of Europe, and it is often visited and
studied by distinguished
scholars, not only of other states but
of foreign countries.
The Society, through a corps of
explorers, is doing splendid
and valuable work in examining and
making permanent record
of the innumerable points of
archaeological interest in the State.
An archaeological map is being prepared,
which will designate
the location of all important mounds,
monuments, graves, etc.,
within Ohio. It is estimated that these
places of interest number
no less than fifteen thousand.
TWELFTH ANNUAL REPORT
OF THE
OHIO STATE
ARCHAEOLOGICAL AND HISTORICAL
SOCIETY
FOR THE YEAR
FEBRUARY 18, 1896 TO FEBRUARY 1,
1897.
GEN. R. BRINKERHOFF, President.
E. 0. RANDALL, Secretary.
COLUMBUS, O., JANUARY, 1897.
(291)