HOMES OF THE MOUND
BUILDERS.
WILLIAM JACKSON ARMSTRONG.
[Col. W. J. Armstrong was inspector of
the United States consulates
under the administrations of President
Grant. He is the author of "Siberia
and the Nihilists," "The
Heroes of Defeat," etc. - EDITOR.]
The Mound Builder is still a mystery.
His story has not been
told. He is not yet intelligibly tangent
to any known race. He
is not only prehistoric, but
unconnected. His clues are shy and
evasive, lacking the thread of either
written speech or hiero-
glyphic memorials. His silence is
impressive. He is the Pelas-
gian of the Western World, without
articulate voice to reach his
successors. On the Latin theory, omne
ignotum pro magnifico,
he tends in popular fancy to enlargement
and idealization. Some-
thing, however, is being concretely, if
slowly, learned of him.
For a century or more he has been
studied empirically and super-
ficially in these western valleys along
the great Mississippi basin.
Generations of the early modern settlers
here, the pioneers of the
woods, and their successors, the
cultivators of the soil, looked
with inquiring wonder on his huge
traces, his burial tumuli, his
gigantic earth-works, his implements of
flint and diorite. Then
they gave him up as an unresolved and
impossible problem. They
had dimly heard, however, that he was an
"Aztec," or "Toltec,"
or possibly a Tartar. And learned
investigation has not pro-
ceeded much further. The scholar is
still a fumbling sciolist,
dealing with the now mute inhabitant,
who, in the twilight cen-
turies, settled down here amid the
mysterious forests. Or, who
knows, he may have been, like the forest
themselves, autochthon-
ous-the Adam and Eve of the occident?
But, as has been intimated, some
progress has been made in
the knowledge of this misty and elusive
denizen of the early
wilds. The unearthing and inspection of
his remains in recent
years having thrown new light upon his
habits and customs, pos-
sibly, his grade in civilization. As is
fitting, in the region where
(28)
Homes of the Mound Builders. 29
the evidences most abound, Ohio has
taken the lead in this more
minute and scientific search; the work
being undertaken here, as
in other sections of the country, under
the direction of the Ohio
State Archaeological and Historical
Society, whose field examina-
tions have been latterly conducted by
Professor W. C. Mills,
curator of the Society and to the Museum
of the State University.
I accepted, in a recent year, the
invitation of the Ohio
Archaeological and Historical Society to
accompany its annual
field party in search of the relics of
the mysterious race. The
site of explorations was fixed near the
village of Bourneville, in
Ross County, central in the tier of
counties crossing the southern
regions of the State, this site having
already yielded in one or
two previous years valuable osteological
results to the pick
and shovel.
For, to-day, the inquisition for these
early settlers, the "first
families" of Ohio, so to speak, is
largely a matter of bones.
Though his origin and scheme of empire
be elusive, the primitive
citizen did not fail to manufacture
abundant testimony of his
occupation here. The colossal mounds
still rear their heads along
the lowlands of the river courses, and
their builders, whitherso-
ever their race may have finally
departed, have left their skeletons
in and around these monumental
earth-heaps, where they remain
to-day as startlingly distinct effigies
of humanity as at the hour
of their deposit. The Mound Builder
lies by the side of his
mound. He is neither speculative nor a myth. Whatever may
have been his aspirations in the flesh,
or whether his intentions
may have been more or less honorable in
his furtive residence
here, he is as obvious and clear in his
osteology as the Anglo-
Saxon who has succeeded him. His
physical proportions and
cranial architecture are in substantial
evidence.
The scene selected for his exhumation
under review was a
magnificent valley two miles in breadth,
winding along Paint
Creek, or river, a stream of irregular
turbulence, watering the
fertile Ohio lowlands and emptying into
the Scioto. Along its
sides stretches to-day, for twenty
miles, an expanse of rank, opu-
lent grain fields, the soil now tame
under four generations of the
civilized plough and harrow. The county
of Ross prides itself
on its fecund fields and its antiquity
among Ohio communities.
30 Ohio Arch. and Hist. Society Publications.
Chillicothe, its county seat, from the
tower of whose ancient
Court House Daniel Webster, on a passage
through the State,
three quarters of a century ago, praised
the unrivaled prospect of
springing crops, was the early capital
of the commonwealth. The
opening years of the late century mark,
on the headstones in the
local graveyards, the dates of demise of
the early pioneers from
the trans-Alleghany settlements. But
over the smooth, culti-
vated fields, along the water of Paint
River, the landmarks of
nature are still unchanged, wild and
rugged, as in the days when
the Mound Builders, with an unerring eye
to succulence, pitched
on the valley for an enduring habitat.
The straight line of hills
lifted almost to grandeur on one side of
the stream, and clad as
then with primeval forests, is the same
in aspect as when it looked
down on his encampment on the opposite
shore of the river; while
rearward of his ancient abode, the
heights, similarly clad in their
aboriginal green, swing into superb
amphitheater, rising in suc-
cessive terraces to miniature mountain
cones against the sky line.
For imposingly picturesque effect the
hills of the Rhine and lower
Hudson are hardly their superior. The
crescent arena under-
neath, two miles in breadth, forming the
hoar camp of the
departed race, on which we pitched our
modern tents, looked on
every side toward this frowning circlet
of heights. The prospect
was magnificent, with a touch of gloom;
the shadow of this lofty
environment, even through the sunny
days, falling upon us in
the level of the sombre cornfields with
suggestions of the gray
primeval time. Without much effort of
the imagination, the
olden scene could be nearly perfectly
recalled-the pre-historic
squatters from their valley settlement
looking to these green-
robed hills. It was to become yet more
real through our subse-
quent diggings here. But the antique
settler on this site, as else-
where in his selection of locality, gave
evidence of an eye for
natural beauty as well as of a
solicitude for venison and corn.
For the Mound Builder, though singularly
carnivorous, was a
cultivator of the maize.
The immediate spot chosen for our summer
exploitation was
in an open field of newly-mown wheat
stubble, over an ancient
village site extending from the base of
a lofty mound-one of
several tumuli dotted along the twenty
miles of this fertile valley
nes of the Mound Builders. 31
plain. From the center and slope of the
mound itself had been
taken, in a previous year, bones and
relics of the mysterious archi-
tects, not less than seventy of their
skeletons having been
unearthed from the level of the
cornfield neighboring its base.
Over this whole lowland, or river-bottom
plain, indeed, to the
distance of a quarter of a mile in
superficial extent, and possibly
in yet uninspected territory far beyond,
are the profuse relics of
the ancient occupation; arrow point,
wrought spear-heads in
flint, and obsidian, fragments of
pottery, carved shells and imple-
ments of diorite, lying so thickly
strewn over the alluvial soil that
the plowboy, for a century back, has
only needed to stoop and
select at pleasure from these mementoes
of the forgotten epoch;
though, in fact, they are so thickly and
visibly cast that they have
gone for generations virtually unheeded
by the residents here.
The listless curiosity, however, even of
these practical sons of
agriculture would have been stirred had
they realized over what
they stepped. It was a city of the dead
that, within a few inches
of the disturbing plowshare, lay with
its grinning skeletons
upturned to their feet!
It is to these previously unnoted
village sites, rather than to
the imposing and more sensational
tumuli, that the recent quest
for the secret of the Mound Builder has
been chiefly attracted.
His true vestiges and inwardness are to be
uncovered here -his
home, his habits, his tastes, his
relations to his dead.
In this new and curious archlaeologic
quest, the Ohio Society,
so liberally sustained by the State
representative assembly, is
taking, as has been said, a marked
prominence; the fact being due
to its enlightened board of officers,
aided by the vigorous and
intelligent labors of its distinguished
secretary.
To me, a neophyte in necrologic search,
the accounts of these
mysterious village habitations, with
their domestic graveyards
and refuse-heaped ash pits yielding
testimony of the daily life of
the outworn folk, sounded strange and
unreal. The Mound
Builder found in his alleged identical
skeleton was a probable
myth, or, at best, a galvanized Indian
of the later and tangible
epoch - whose tribe could have deposited
him at will, by way
of conspicuous sepulture, in or near the
barrows of the more
ancient people. But on the first day
of our operations on this
32 Ohio Arch. and Hist. Society Publications.
Bourneville site, under the first thrust
of the spade, there, yellow
and shining in the July sun, lay the
clean, indubitable skull of
the pre-historic man! At its side was a
pot of coarse, heavy
earthenware, with crudely ornamented
rim. The spot was only
a few hundred feet distant from the
central mound, around whose
base nearly a hundred other skeletons
had been previously
unearthed. The Indian tribes of the Ohio
Valley did not build
mounds nor fashion clay pots. To them,
as to their pale modern
successors, these monumental earth-heaps
were a mystery beyond
the call of tradition.
The skull at our feet, then, was not the
cranial relic of an
Indian, but that of an architect of the
giant barrow under whose
shadow it reposed. Here was reality and
history! The burial
plat was the rounding bank of the
ancient river bed, the soil
worn thin and close to the features of
the olden dead by the
modern plow.
As from the initial spade stroke we
proceeded into this shal-
low shore, the skeletons came everywhere
thickly into sight; the
burials in places seemingly having been
imposed upon one
another, as if occurring at widely
separated intervals. The work
grew interesting almost to excitement.
We were face to face
with the representatives of the vanished
race! Under the heads
of a few were polished stones for
head-rests, while, near others,
were broken or entire pots of varying
size, containing flint arrow-
heads, ornamental trinkets in bone,
minute fragments of copper
and deposits of food for the dead; this
latter persisting in the
form of kernels of Indian corn and the
shriveled seeds of fruits,
distinct in their identity as on the day
of interment.
How long had these human remnants laid
here thus, integral
and intact? One hundred, two hundred,
four hundred years?
Longer than that. The Indian tribes that
met our fathers on this
soil knew nothing of these burials.
Probably six hundred, ten
hundred, two thousand years, then--from
the days when the
Montagus warred with the Capulets or the
skin-clad ancestors
of the civilized Saxon, now exhuming
them, fell under the sword
of the Celtic Dagobert in the forests by
the Rhine--or from
still beyond in the pagan mists. How
long will the frame of
man last, anyhow? That depends: three
thousand years, as
Homes of the Mound Builders. 33
exampled in the cairns of western
France, or by the experience
of Schliemann with his Mycenaean
kings--five thousand, ten
thousand, as instanced by the remains of
upper Egypt. Here, at
least, grinning and pertinent before us,
lay the bony relics of
departed tribes of men, infract and
substantial as in their days
under the sunlight, shocking the senses
almost with their mock-
ery of contrast with man's brief day in
the flesh. The soil in this
Bourneville burial camp is alluvial over
a porous clay, itself
imposed on a drainage stratum of loose
river gravel--offering
the Mound Builder unusual conditions for
posthumous endur-
ance. He thus remains to-day in
conspicuous evidence.
Before the end of a week, we had exposed
not less than
twenty of these amazingly distinct human
forms, lying in the
veritable attitudes in which they had
been laid away in the long-
ago epochs. Method of direction as to
the points of the com-
pass had been ignored in these burials,
as there was also lacking
evidence of religious or superstitious
rites of interment. Scru-
pulous care, however, had in many
instances been taken as to the
decorous composure of the bodies and
limbs of the dead.
The process of uncovering these remains
was exceedingly
careful; for, although perfectly natural
in appearance, the bones
of these age-worn deposits were, for the
most part, soft and
brittle. After throwing off, therefore,
by the aid of mattock
and shovel, the superficial layers of
soil, it was necessary to com-
plete the exposure with minute trowels
or even with the blades
of penknives; the delicate, painstaking
care of the proceeding
being equal to that of the anatomical
expert with his specimens
for a museum.
Sometimes a group of not less than seven
or eight skeletons
would be thus prepared for the
photographer's camera; the
human shapes, with their deliberate
meaning attitudes and grin-
ning skulls, so outlined in relief
against the earth, having, at
times, a sinister and even menacing
distinctness, as if in sardonic
rebuke of our intrusion on their ancient
rest. Faced to the liv-
ing, the mysterious dead - our
unmistakable kindred - seemed
to speak in irony out of the ages. There
was no answering back;
though, at times, the prolonged, almost
intelligent stare of these
reproachful relics produced an effect so
nearly appalling that the
Vol. XIV--3.
34 Ohio Arch. and Hist. Society Publications.
tension of nerves found its natural
physiological relief in bursts
of hilarious counter-mockery. We
addressed the outraged vic-
tims of our spades as "John,"
"Jonathan," the "first citizens,"
the "late lamented," etc. But
the limit of gruesome humor was
reached when our artist, taking
conventional stand, admonished
his helpless subject, with professional
courtesy, to "lie still" and
"look pleasant!"
In our preliminary diggings during the
first ten days, more
than thirty skeletons, lying over an
area of scarcely more than
as many square feet, were thus uncovered
and photographed; the
place seeming in sections, a veritable
teeming charnel pit of the
mound-building tribe. The forms ranged from untoothed
infancy, to toothless old age, more than
one-half of the
burials, however, being those of infants
and children from a few
weeks to a few months or years of age.
The early inhabitants
here were clearly not economical of
babies. Scarlet rash, teeth-
ing and a diet of imperfectly boiled
green corn had inferentially
done their perfect work.
At the head or by the side of an
occasional adult lay the
carved pipe of stone, the model, in size
and form, of the conven-
tional pipe, savage or civilized, in all
the centuries since. A thou-
sand years, mayhap, earlier than Raleigh
and his pampered North
Carolina aristocrats knew the luxury of
the weed, the primeval
American in the enjoyment of its curling
fragrance sat here
before his hut door, on the river bank,
watching the failing sun
over the wooded magnificence of these
hills. From all evidences
the Mound Builder was an ardent lover of
tobacco.
Here and there, also, near the
skeletons, lay the spearhead,
the stone hatchet or other implements,
in bone or flint, of the
primitive warrior or hunter-notably
among these being the
shapely, carved bone awl, for the
piercing of skins, or similar
domestic use.
The physical proportions of the Mound
Builder have not yet
been adequately studied by the methods
of ethnological compari-
son. The adult skeletons found by us
here, and generally over
this Bourneville site, have a size not
much varying from that of
average modern civilized humanity, but
tending to inferior rather
than to larger dimensions. Many of the
male specimens, meas-
Homes of the Mound Builders. 35
ured by us, did not exceed the length of
five feet three or four
inches. One almost gigantic figure,
however, atoned for the
brevity of his neighbors; his huge,
naked skeleton, as it lay
grimly composed with head resting on a
polished stone slab,
stretching, from crown to heel, the full
six feet of manly propor-
tions. In life he must have exceeded
that stature by several
inches, while in girth of ribs and
massiveness of bone he was truly
colossal - evidently from his size and
distinction in burial a tow-
ering Saul among his race.
The skull of the Mound Builder, as it
came under our inspec-
tion, if subjected to minute
examination, would furnish a curious
study and one far more fruitful in
inference than has yet been
made. The specimens upturned by us were
apparently not of the
Indian type with which we are familiar,
there being both greater
regularity and delicacy than mark that
type. They were still
further removed from the type of the yet
lower savage races,
distinguished by the prognathous jaw and
heaviness in the occip-
ital region. On the contrary, while the
jaw of the Mound archi-
tect as here found is regular and
massive, as became his carniv-
orous habit, there is a distinct
tendency to elevation and sym-
metry in the cerebral parts, ranking him
rather with the best of
the Turanian types of men. Much,
however, must be awaited
to reduce speculation to scientific inference on this point.
Exhausting after a few days the limits
of the some thirty-
feet square graveyard, we proceeded in
our excavations into the
immediately adjacent dwelling sites.
The Mound Builder deposited his dead
under two feet of
earth, at his doorway; his habitation
and sepulchre--possibly
from lazy convenience sake -knowing
little distinction. Life or
death had for him little of the
civilized panorama. The necessi-
ties of both were pressing and
imperative. Sentiment and imag-
ination, or even considerations of
health, were not his masters.
Unquestionably, in spite of his mounds
and his pots and his
somewhat equivocal military
fortifications, he was not greatly
superior in habits to the Indian who
succeeded him. His burials,
his stone tools, his crude art and his reckless care of his babies
attest this. But he was clever in the
ways of the semi-barbarian.
His dwelling sites, which we now
entered, revealed something
36
Ohio Arch. and Hist. Society Publications.
of his methods and status. To us delving
and creeping amid
these day after day the atmosphere of
the primitive life and time
stole with curious effect over the
imagination, the impression
verging at times on the weird and
uncanny. Here were the
penetralia, the Lares and Penates, the
home and current life, of
the ancient race. The Mound Builder,
outside of his mound,
was not an architect. Beyond his
primitive implements, he
wrought neither in wood nor in stone.
His home was probably
a wigwam of skins and twisted boughs.
There are no remains
or evidences to the contrary - only here
and there a still existing
earth hole or socket, into which he
thrust the stake or pole that
propped his dwelling. The inference,
subject to correction, may
do him vast injustice; but the Mound
Builder, barring his zealous
proclivity for heaping his huge barrows,
was a lazy son of the
soil. The testimony is against him. He
carried his dead only
beyond his door lintels; and here,
around and underneath his
immediate habitation, he dug circular
holes, from three to six
feet in depth, into which to empty his
ash pots and toss the rem-
nants of his broken food and other
refuse from domestic uses.
In vulgar parlance, they have
"given him away." Through
them, like the Indians in the comic
opera of "Columbus," he has
been "discovered" - in his
habits, his tastes and his indolence.
His reputation for industry, so
laboriously wrought up in his
stupendous monuments over the surface of
the earth, has disap-
peared in these discreditable apertures
beneath it. As to his deal-
ings with the soil, the Mound Builder,
prudent for his fame,
should have limited his efforts to the
superior direction. But
history has been served. As has been
intimated, within these
circular pits, clearly defined by the
softness of their soil against
the hard wall of the untouched
neighboring clay, are to be found
the true vestigia of the home life of
the early American. As
with the minute trowels we painfully
disemboweled these cavities
of their contents, the fruits of our
labors became intently curious.
Remnants of food, broken and entire
implements of stone or bone
for household use, shells of the native
river mussel and land tor-
toise, flint quirts, fish hooks and
arrowheads-all flung with
careless hand into these convenient
domestic abysses--were
found in plethoric abundance. Ashes, in
layers or heaps, most
Homes of the Mound Builders. 37
frequently intervened between these more
significant finds of
family debris. The Mound Builder cooked
his victual.
The mode of clearing these waste pits
was grotesquely
and, at times, comically uncomfortable;
their limited circular area
requiring the delver, with his tiny
spade, to squeeze himself into
cross-legged sitting posture and sink
gradually, in the process of
the evacuation, from the sight of his
fellows. The slowly-vanish-
ing vision of one bald-headed member of
our party, as he thus
disappeared from the surface, was the
unfailing signal for
merriment.
These cavities were uniformly prolific
in their yield of the
customary finds in flint and stone, such
as hammers, hatchets,
knives, chisels, wedges and similar
instruments. But addition-
ally significant of the industries of
the mystic people were the
implements and utensils in bone and
shell. Notable among these
were needles fashioned from the delicate
bones of birds and the
so-called "scrapers," sharply
and curiously carved from the bones
of the elk and deer and, inferentially,
used in the cleaning and
preparation of the skins of these and
other animals. The articles
in shell, quite commonly from the
favorite and ornamental land
tortoise, were the more than inferential
cups and ladles and
spoons employed in the distribution of
the family soup. Still
added to these were the constantly
abundant fragments of the
earthen pot, indicating a varying size
of the vessel from two
inches to nearly as many feet in
diameter. Indeed, from the
everywhere profuse remains of this
family receptacle over and
underneath the soil hereabouts, it must
have been nearly as plen-
tiful with the tribes as modern crockery
with their civilized
successors.
The taste and supply in ornament of
these strange folk was
evinced in our frequent discoveries of
bone beads and diminutive
specimens of copper, together with other
articles of decorative
gear, not infrequently fashioned from
material transported from
remote sections of the country.
But most significantly characteristic of
all in the contents
of these pits were the varied and
literally massive remains of
animal life, the relicts of food of the
human inhabitants here.
The shells of the river mussel were
found in literal heaps, while
38 Ohio Arch. and Hist. Society
Publications.
every thrust of trowel
or shovel threw to light the bones of deer,
elk or bear; the
accumulation of these being sufficient to make a
respectably impressive
mound by the side of each pit. The
remains, indeed, of
not less than twenty species of animals, mostly
native to the region,
were found not sparingly in these excava-
tions, including the
elk, deer, bear, panther, wolf, wildcat, squir-
rel, rabbit, coon,
wild turkey, opossum, polecat, dog, and many
others, most of which
had been apparently utilized in the way of
subsistence. The
succulent marrow of the bones of the deer and
kindred animals had
been cleanly extracted or carved, in every
instance, from its
investment. With every hour and step of the
investigation there
grew the overmastering impression of the
carnivorous voracity
of these ancient denizens of the soil. In
whatever else the
primal American may have been lacking, he
had in our modern
vernacular his "appetite always with him."
He evidently lived
close to nature in his struggle with her here.
He was a tickler, if
not a rude cultivator, of the earth and a hun-
ter among men. His weapons for the largest game
were
obviously ample. His pots were capacious, and he
filled his
stomach. But beyond his specialty of the towering
mound,
neither his art nor
his ornament was high or elaborate.
From the contents of
these curious earth cavities adjacent to
his hearthstone, it
may not be quite fair, indeed, to conclusively
judge of the ancient
inhabitant of the soil--to construct the
imaginary temple of
his civilization from the fragments of his
domesticity, by
himself rejected. Even civilized man would not
elect to be so deduced
by his successors.
His gigantic barrows
and crude fortifications in the ultimate
verdict make for the
Mound Builder measureable amendment.
His cranium is not
unpromising; the discovery of an occa-
sional
grotesquely-carved pipe or copper ornament may elevate
him toward the rank of
the Zuni or Aztec; but it stands to reason
that these tell-tale
cavities, fecund with the broken paraphernalia
of his daily
existence, are the true memorabilia and evidence of
his half-barbarous,
evanished race. Taking the case as it stands,
at least, it is
disconcerting to acknowledge how barely he is res-
cued by his mound and
his pot from the status of the familiar
Indian, of whose arts
and habits he so abundantly partook.
HOMES OF THE MOUND
BUILDERS.
WILLIAM JACKSON ARMSTRONG.
[Col. W. J. Armstrong was inspector of
the United States consulates
under the administrations of President
Grant. He is the author of "Siberia
and the Nihilists," "The
Heroes of Defeat," etc. - EDITOR.]
The Mound Builder is still a mystery.
His story has not been
told. He is not yet intelligibly tangent
to any known race. He
is not only prehistoric, but
unconnected. His clues are shy and
evasive, lacking the thread of either
written speech or hiero-
glyphic memorials. His silence is
impressive. He is the Pelas-
gian of the Western World, without
articulate voice to reach his
successors. On the Latin theory, omne
ignotum pro magnifico,
he tends in popular fancy to enlargement
and idealization. Some-
thing, however, is being concretely, if
slowly, learned of him.
For a century or more he has been
studied empirically and super-
ficially in these western valleys along
the great Mississippi basin.
Generations of the early modern settlers
here, the pioneers of the
woods, and their successors, the
cultivators of the soil, looked
with inquiring wonder on his huge
traces, his burial tumuli, his
gigantic earth-works, his implements of
flint and diorite. Then
they gave him up as an unresolved and
impossible problem. They
had dimly heard, however, that he was an
"Aztec," or "Toltec,"
or possibly a Tartar. And learned
investigation has not pro-
ceeded much further. The scholar is
still a fumbling sciolist,
dealing with the now mute inhabitant,
who, in the twilight cen-
turies, settled down here amid the
mysterious forests. Or, who
knows, he may have been, like the forest
themselves, autochthon-
ous-the Adam and Eve of the occident?
But, as has been intimated, some
progress has been made in
the knowledge of this misty and elusive
denizen of the early
wilds. The unearthing and inspection of
his remains in recent
years having thrown new light upon his
habits and customs, pos-
sibly, his grade in civilization. As is
fitting, in the region where
(28)