Ohio History Journal




BOOK REVIEWS

BOOK REVIEWS

 

In Winter We Flourish. By Anna Shannon McAllister. (New

York, Longmans, Green and Co., 1939. 398p. $3.50.)

Outstanding in the civic and charitable enterprises of early

Cincinnati was Sarah Worthington King Peter, of whom Anna

Shannon McAllister has written in her new book, In Winter We

Flourish. Daughter of Thomas and Eleanor Swearingen Worth-

ington, the former at one time governor of Ohio, Sarah was from

childhood accustomed to the assumption of leadership.

Following what was for that time (the early nineteenth cen-

tury) a very thorough education for a woman, she married at

an early age the son of Senator Rufus King of New York,

Edward King, with whom she made her home in Cincinnati for

twenty years. Following her husband's death in 1836 she moved

east to attend to the details of their children's schooling. In 1844

she married William Peter, British consul at Philadelphia, and

in that city continued philanthropic work of the kind she had

been associated with in Cincinnati. She founded the Philadelphia

School of Design, the first educational institution for teaching

industrial art in the United States. After William Peter's death

she returned to Cincinnati where, following her conversion to

Roman Catholicism, she was responsible for bringing to that city

many religious orders devoted to charitable purposes. During

the Civil War she was active in hospital work, giving generously

of her time and money. She died in Europe in 1877.

Sarah Peter was an exceptional individual--in the attributes

of her personality and in the episodes of her life, and Mrs. Mc-

Allister has dealt fully with her many faceted character and exist-

ence. While a little less adulation for her subject might have

resulted in a more definitive portrait, it is difficult to quarrel with

the author's enthusiasm for the gifted, energetic, social-minded

woman of whom she wrote.

L. R. H.

(216)



BOOK REVIEWS 217

BOOK REVIEWS                    217

 

Michael Beam. By Richard Matthews Hallet. (Boston, Hough-

ton Mifflin Company, 1939. 451p. $2.50.)

One of the most attractive of recent novels dealing with the

American frontier and its inhabitants is Michael Beam, the story

of a rugged individualist who broke open the vault of the United

States Bank at Chillicothe, Ohio, in 1819 so that the sheriff from

Columbus might collect the $100,000 tax levied on the Bank by

the State of Ohio. To escape the ire of the Federal Government,

Michael went west and north, settling in the Illinois country at

Sorry Crossing, where he was instrumental in ending the Black

Hawk War.

Mainly concerned with Michael's relations with two women,

the Indian, Red Bloom, and the white aristocrat, Charlessie Car-

teret, the book is valuable for other features as well: its sharply

drawn minor characters; its anecdotes of frontier life; and the

beauty of Mr. Hallet's style of writing. Altogether, it is one of

the most interesting and appealing of recent historical novels.

L. R. H.

 

 

Hannah Courageous. By Laura Long. (New York, Longmans,

Green and Co., 1939. 246p. $2.00.)

Runaway Linda. By Marjorie Hill Allee. (Boston, Houghton

Mifflin Company, 1939. $2.00.)

These two books have many likenesses. Written for juve-

niles, each has a Quaker heroine, is laid in Indiana, the former

in the days preceding and the latter in the days following the

Civil War, and each gives illuminating sidelights on the kind of

life found in rural Quaker communities of the Midwest during

the latter half of the nineteenth century.

Hannah Courageous is the story of a Quaker girl who wanted

to be an artist, of her brother Samuel who wanted to be a river

man, and of their parents who wanted the children to grow up

God-fearing citizens. Of particular interest is the account the

book gives of the Underground Railroad and of the bitterness



218 OHIO ARCHAEOLOGICAL AND HISTORICAL QUARTERLY

218   OHIO ARCHAEOLOGICAL AND HISTORICAL QUARTERLY

 

engendered in the border states among friends and relatives who

held differing views on the slavery question.

Runaway Linda recounts what befell fifteen-year-old Linda

and her younger brother Joel following their escape from "Uncle"

Jethro Drysdale, and their taking sanctuary in the pleasant home

of William Saint. Put together with Mrs. Allee's usual facility,

the book contains detailed pictures of every-day life in a happy

family group.

Both of these books are well written, tell of interesting epi-

sodes and have strong, clearly delineated characters, whose por-

trayals are indicative of the two authors' refreshing senses of

humor.

L. R. H.

 

From Indian Trail to Iron Horse. By Wheaton J. Lane. (Prince-

ton, Princeton University Press, 1939. 420p. Illus. $3.75.)

In this book the author depicts the gradual development, from

1620 to 1860, of the means of travel and transportation in New

Jersey, an important thoroughfare between such metropolitan cen-

ters as New York and Philadelphia. He points out the successive

stages of establishing trade-routes from the times of Indian trails,

pack horses and stage wagons, to the development of the canal-boat

and, finally, the railroad. Economic history is related to the social

customs which were prevelant in the various periods.

Routes of trade and travel were determined by the terrain and

waterways of New Jersey. Indian trails were influenced by the

natural topography of the land, the whites in many instances only

broadening these trails to accommodate the horse and wagon. The

growth of the system of roads directed the progress of the early

settlement and was essential to New Jersey's prosperity in agricul-

ture, trade and commerce. Its extensive waterways were a means

of access from the outside and of internal transportation. Besides

the development of land for agriculture, private efforts in other

fields, such as exploitation of the natural resources of the area, led

directly to internal improvements and the development of trans-

portation.



BOOK REVIEWS 219

BOOK REVIEWS                     219

 

The author gives details on the methods used in financing and

maintenance of roads, bridges, ferries, stage lines, railroads and

other means of transportation at the time.

Most of the material is pertinent to other parts of the country

as well as New Jersey. The story of transportation and communi-

cation in this colony and subsequent state is in large measure appli-

cable to the entire country and to Ohio in particular. Thousands

of New Englanders and New Yorkers had to cross New Jersey in

order to reach Philadelphia, one of the great gateways to the West,

before setting out for their new homes in the Ohio region.

Although the book is invaluable as a reference tool to New Jersey

students of local history, it may also be of use to the Ohio his-

torian for comparative study.

The author drew heavily on official, semi-official and un-

official manuscript material as well as newspapers and secondary

sources. Factual material is interspersed with interesting tavern

tales and sketches of incidents in a traveler's life at the time. In

general it is written in a popular style and, as far as can be ascer-

tained, is historically accurate.

The book is well illustrated and documented, has a partial

bibliography and a satisfactory index. It is the first volume in a

proposed series of monographs on New Jersey history. Other

volumes in this Princeton series should also be interesting.

A. J. O.